Our enemies are in truth our benefactors; they close the door of hell and open to us the path of salvation; they are as useful as the Buddhas (110). The Buddhas identify themselves with creatures; in loving creatures, we please the Buddhas; in offending them, we offend the Buddhas (134).
1) All these good works, charity, the worship of the Buddhas, with which the saint has enriched himself over centuries, hatred destroys them [as a spark destroys a heap of straw].
2) So there is no sin as destructive as hatred, nor any mortification as good [and as difficult] as patience. Apply yourselves therefore to patience with all your strength and by the various methods [that we are going to set out].
3) What heart envenomed by hatred will ever know calm, the joy of benevolent feelings, the sleep of the body, firmness of thought?
4) The gifts, the attentions, the services and even the protection he grants do not defend against ill will a master whose irritability makes him unbearable.
5) Even his friends are afraid of him; his servants avoid him although he is lavish; in a word, there is no remedy: the angry man cannot be happy.
6) Anger produces all these evils and many others, [not to speak of the life to come]; it is an enemy that must be attacked energetically, that must be destroyed in order to be happy in both worlds.
7) If hatred gathers strength and kills me, it is because it feeds on discontent; discontent is born of thwarted desire or repugnance.
8) I will destroy the food on which my enemy feeds, my enemy who, day and night, conspires only for my ruin.
9) Even the most painful circumstances must not disturb my joy: discontent serves no purpose but to squander merit.
10) If there is some remedy for the evil, what good is grieving? What good is grieving, if there is nothing to be done?
11) Suffering [physical and moral], insults, wounding words, slander: that is what we fear for ourselves and for those we love. And, by a contrary effect, we suffer from the happiness of an enemy.
12) At the cost of great efforts [in the practice of good] one sometimes obtains enjoyments [imperfect, and which feed transmigration]; [suffering, on the contrary, appears everywhere, and there is no lack of occasion to grow used to it; now] it is by suffering alone that one can escape from existences. Be patient, then, O my soul!
13) [Even the pagans consent to suffer to obtain a great good:] the devotees of the goddess Durgâ, inhabitants of the Carnatic, in the vain hope of salvation, [submit to fasting on the occasion of the great feasts]: they do not hesitate to burn and lacerate their bodies; and I [who pursue, for universal salvation, the enlightenment of the Buddhas, so hard to obtain], should I show unworthy weakness?
14) There is nothing difficult [in the arts, in virtue, in endurance] that practice does not make easy; by training oneself to bear slight sufferings, one makes even the most violent ones harmless.
15) Mosquitoes, gadflies, flies, hunger, thirst, itching, and what else? — why leave [these opportunities to exercise patience] barren?
16) Cold, heat, rain, wind, a wearisome road, sickness, prison, blows... Are you going to play the spoilt child? That is to increase suffering.
17) There are soldiers whom the sight of their own blood fills with extreme courage; others think they will die on seeing the blood of their comrades flow.
18) The thought of the first is trained to courage; that of the second to cowardice. [Valour is therefore in your power:] make yourself invincible to suffering and you will have overcome it.
19) Even when he suffers, the saint keeps his thought at peace [in the Buddha, firm in the good], for [life] is a combat against the passions, and what combat is without sufferings?
20) Those who triumph over the enemy by offering their breast to the enemy’s blows, they are victors and heroes: those who prevail by cunning are called “slayers of corpses”,
21) Pain is infinitely advantageous: it inspires holy dread [of sin]. Pride [of youth and of wealth] is brought low; one becomes charitable towards suffering creatures; one fears sin [which ripens into pain]; and the Buddha [who showed the path to the destruction of pain], one loves him, [one adores him, one believes in him, one sets one’s thought at peace in him],
22) A great fool would be he who grew angry with the humours whose [disorder engenders] such painful illnesses! Just as unreasonable is anger against beings endowed with thought, for they too are disordered only under the influence of causes.
23) Just as [the humours, altered by such and such causes, become irritated and cause] a suffering they do not intend; so, [when its causes have ripened], there springs forth, and without resentment [on the part of the being endowed with thought], the anger [that will be injurious to us],
24) Will you say, in fact, that man grows angry voluntarily and reflects: “I am going to get angry”; or that anger takes counsel with itself and decides to burst out at its appointed hour?
25) All faults, whatever they may be, all evil actions proceed from the chain of necessitating causes: nothing moves or acts of itself.
26) The complex of antecedents [that engenders the effect] does not think: “I am going to produce”; and the effect engendered does not think: “I am produced”.
27) [But, you will say, there exists something autonomous,] what the heretics call by the name of pradhâna, or what they call by the name of âtman — These are pure imaginings. Neither the one nor the other is born after reflecting: “I am being born”.
28) Before being born, [neither the one nor the other] exists: and what is not cannot desire to be. [Will you say that it is a question, not of the passage from nothingness to being, but of the passage from the state of indistinction to the state of distinction? We shall refute this sophism further on. Will you say that the âtman is, by its nature, eternal, unborn? Our objection remains:] if the âtman is in activity, in contact with the object [presented by prakrti], how will this activity come to an end?
29) If the âtman is eternal, devoid of thought, like space, it is all too clear that it is inactive. Whatever external forces you surround it with, being unalterable, it cannot act.
30) For, remaining at the moment of action what it was before, what part does it take in the action? “The action of the âtman”, you say: but what sort of relation is there between the action and the âtman?
31) Thus everything depends on its cause, and that cause in its turn is dependent. Beings have the same kind of activity as magical creations: anger against them is not justified.
32) [Very well;] but then it is impossible to stop [anger]? Where then is the [autonomous] being who will stop it? What is the force [autonomous, and not necessitated in its results, desire or hatred,] that will be stopped? [We answer:] You are mistaken, for [this universe of thought and suffering] is only the chain of causes, and that is how the cessation of suffering is possible.
33) When an enemy, or even a friend, offends one’s neighbour, one must think: “Such are the causes acting in him”, and keep one’s serenity.
34) If it were enough to desire in order to obtain what one wants, no one would suffer; for who desires suffering?
35) Thoughtless, under the sway of anger or covetousness, for women or riches beyond their reach, men make themselves their own enemies: see them [on difficult roads], torn by brambles, bruised by stones, [deprived of water and food].
36) Some put an end to their own days: they hang themselves, throw themselves over precipices, swallow poison, eat or drink too much, or else commit crimes [punishable by death].
37) Slaves of the passions, men torture their own body, which is dear to them. How could they spare others?
38) Maddened, [possessed] by [those demons that are] the passions, men apply themselves to their own ruin, [whether they make themselves their own executioners or torment their neighbour]. More worthy, in truth, of pity than of anger!
39-40) [Another point.] Either these senseless people are naturally wicked: to be angry with them is as absurd as being angry with fire because it burns; or wickedness is adventitious in them: “beings are naturally pure”; and are you going to be angry with the air because of the smoke?
41) One is not angry with the stick, the immediate cause of the pain, but with the one who sets it in motion; now he is set in motion by hatred: it is therefore hatred that must be hated.
42) [Let us come to the heart of the matter:] I myself, formerly, tormented creatures as [my enemy] torments me today; my present suffering is well deserved, since I made creatures suffer.
43) Twofold is the cause of my suffering: the sword that strikes me and my body that is struck. My enemy took up the sword, I put on the body: with whom should I be angry?
44) What I have put on is a wound rather than a body, so sensitive is [the body]! Passion must be blinding me for me to grow angry [with my enemy, and not with myself].
45) I hate suffering, and, like a madman, I love the [first] cause of suffering, [which is my body]; the suffering of the body results from the evil committed by the body: why be angry elsewhere [, with the agents and auxiliaries of the first cause]?
46) It is my acts alone that produce the forest with sword-leaves and the vultures of hell; so too this present pain: with whom should I be angry?
It is the act committed by myself that sets in motion the men who do me harm; [which, consequently], hurls them into hell. Can one not say, [O my soul!] that it is I who ruin them [, while they do me no harm].
Thanks to them, if I patiently bear their offences, many sins are destroyed for me [by the very suffering into which they ripen]; whereas because of me my enemies go to the long tortures of hell.
It is I who do them harm while they do me good. Why be deceived, fool that you are! and grow angry?
If I do not go to hell, it is doubtless through the purity of my intention: if I succeed in safeguarding myself, that is no concern of theirs.
Do you want me to take revenge on my enemies? That is not the way to save them. And what happens? It is the end of my vows and of my practice as a future Buddha, and these unfortunates, these wretches are lost [and fall into hell].
[Suffering, it is commonly said, is of two kinds, bodily or moral.] The soul, being immaterial, cannot be touched in any place or by anything whatever: if it is touched by the pain of the body, it is as a result of the false judgements that make one say: “my body”.
As for the body, can one say that it suffers from verbal offences, insults, coarse words, slander? How, O my soul, can you justify your anger?
The ill dispositions of others are harmful neither in this life nor in the other. Why dread them and grieve over them?
But [slander] dries up the generosity of men? My goods will perish within a few days, and the sin [born of resentment] will accompany me into the other world.
Better to die on the spot, [for want of means], than to live a long life of sin. Even if I lived a hundred years, inevitable death holds the same pain in store for me.
One man dreams that he is happy for a hundred years; another, that he is happy for an hour: they wake up.
When they are awake, their happiness is interrupted for ever. Such, when they die, are the man who has lived long and the man who has lived but a few days.
In vain shall I possess riches, in vain shall I long enjoy pleasures: death, like a thief, will leave me neither provision for the journey nor clothing.
60) But, you will say, possessions prolong life, and I shall be able for longer to destroy my sin, to increase merit? But do not grow angry in the desire for possessions, for you would destroy merit and increase sin!
61) Cursed be life, if I miss the one goal of my life, if my whole life is spent in sin!
62) But, you will say, I hate the slanderer, not because he stands in the way of my profits, but because he makes others share his ill will and thus causes their ruin. How is it that those who slander others leave you so indifferent?
63) You easily bear the ill will of which a third party is the object: bear then the evil words that blame your vices.
64) Do not, out of piety, hate those who destroy or insult the images of the Buddhas, the stûpas, the good religion: the Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, Noble disciples and Pratyekabuddhas do not suffer from these insults.
65) If your masters, your parents, your friends are offended, recognize in what happens the manifestation of causes; put away anger.
66) Whether the instrument be an intelligent being or an inanimate thing, suffering results from necessitating causes; it always has its seat in the sensitive body: bear it then, O my soul, wherever it comes from.
67) Some, led astray by selfishness, give offence; others, also led astray, grow angry. Who is blameless? Who is guilty?
68) Why, O my soul, did you commit the sins through which you suffer today at the hands of your enemies? Do you hope to be able to escape? Beings are subject to their former acts.
69) Knowing this, I will apply myself with such energy to good works that all creatures, entering upon the good path, will be filled with mutual affection.
70) When a house is burning, one removes from the neighbouring house the straw and the wood that would feed the fire if it were to spread.
71) Likewise, the objects to which one becomes attached and which can kindle in the soul the fire of hatred must be cast away at once, lest the blaze destroy our merit.
72) A man is condemned to death: they cut off his hand and send him away. Can he complain? — To suffer human sufferings instead of infernal sufferings is pure gain.
73) What! you cannot bring yourself to bear sufferings that are of little account, and you give yourself up to anger, which ripens into infernal sufferings!
74) Thousands upon thousands of times anger has delivered me to the executioners of Yama — without my pains having served myself or my neighbour.
75) Far lesser are the pains of this life, and, made fruitful by patience, they are sources of infinite good. Let us rejoice in a pain that destroys universal pain.
76) Some men find personal satisfaction in praising the virtues of their neighbour: why, O my soul, not rejoice by joining in this praise?
77) But is not all joy attachment, and, by that very fact, evil? — This joy, which has for its principle the merit of others, is irreproachable; it is a source of happiness: it is not forbidden by the doctors of the Law; it is, par excellence, the means of winning over one’s neighbour.
79) Someone praises you, by chance, and you love the joy he draws from your qualities; the merit of another is praised, and you do not love your own joy.
80) What! you have made, for the happiness of every creature, the vow to become a Buddha; and you grow angry with those who, from this very day and of their own accord, are happy through love of the virtues of others!
81) Surely, you wish every creature the possession of the state of Buddha, adorable to the three worlds, and you are grieved at the perishable honours granted to your brothers!
82) He who feeds those whom you must feed, your friends, your children, is it not to you that he gives? You meet a benefactor who keeps your own family alive, no doubt you will rejoice? Not at all. You grow angry!
83) What good, worldly or supernatural, does he not wish for creatures who wishes them the state of Buddha? How could he possess the thought of Bodhi who grows angry at the happiness of others?
84) If your neighbour did not receive the alms you begrudge him, it would remain in the house of the “master of charity”. In both cases, you get nothing from it. What does it matter to you whether it is given or not?
85) Do you demand that your neighbour stop the fructification of his merits, which ripen into alms and honours; that he withdraw from the benevolence of generous laymen; that he make barren his qualities, the source of sympathy; that he refuse what is given to him? — Yes, that is it, get angry!
86) Not only do you not weep over yourself, over your sins, the sole causes of your sufferings, but you claim to rival the virtuous, not in good works, but in enjoyments, the fruit of good works.
87-88) You wish misfortune on your enemy: I will grant, absurd as it is, that your wishes disturb the law of causality; that your enemy, by the sole power of your desire, is unhappy: what a great gain for you! — But this misfortune, you say, makes my joy? — It is the greatest misfortune that could befall you!
89) It is a terrible net in the hands of the passions, those sinister fishermen, this web of your envious wishes: the guardians of the hells will come and catch you in it, poor fish, and cook you in their dens.
90) Praise, glory, honours serve neither merit, nor the prolonging of life, nor vigour, nor health, nor the joys of the body.
91) Now these are the goods that the wise man pursues, who knows what is useful; to drink, to gambling, to conversation gives himself up he who seeks the enjoyments of the mind.
92) But glory, for which senseless people squander their riches and sacrifice their lives! Does one eat syllables? Does one enjoy glory when one is dead?
93) A child weeps with heart-rending cries when his house of sand collapses: so does my thought, when the illusory edifice of my praises and my glory collapses.
94) This praise is nothing but a sounding breath, devoid of thought: will you say that this breath proclaims your merits? — But I hear you: what causes your joy is that your neighbour rejoices in you.
95) Whether I am its cause and object, or someone else is, what is the sympathetic satisfaction of others to me? He alone is happy whose joy shows itself in praise: I have no share in that joy.
96) What, you retort, is the saint not happy at the happiness of others? — Hypocrite, if those were your feelings, why make distinctions? Why are you not happy when your neighbour is the object of praise and the cause of joy?
97) Admit it, O my soul: if I rejoice when I am praised, it is because I am praised and not out of disinterested sympathy; and is this joy of self-love not unreasonable and childish enough?
98) For praise and honours dispel the dread of sin and of transmigration, dissolve attention and self-distrust, make the vain man jealous of the merit of others and envious of their prosperity.
[Honour] those who rise up against you to destroy your reputation, your vainglory and your riches! It seems that their only aim is to preserve you from the hells.
Possessions and honours are a chain for whoever aspires to deliverance: [my enemies, — should I not rather say my benefactors and the friends of my salvation?], free me from this chain. Shall I be mad enough to hate them?
I was rushing, voluntarily one might say, into suffering; my enemies, as if by an effect of the Buddha’s protection, come and bar my way: shall I be mad enough to hate them?
“But my enemy stands in the way of my good works!” A poor excuse, for there is no austerity comparable to patience, and it is the enemy who provides me [freely] with the occasion for it.
If, and it will indeed be my fault, I do not practise patience towards him, it is truly I myself who stand in the way of my holiness, who destroy its present cause.
If B does not exist without A; if, A existing, B exists, A is the cause of B. Do not call “obstacle” what is “cause”.
Does the beggar who presents himself at the proper hour stand in the way of charity? Does the religious, [the sight of whom incites one to the religious life], stand in the way of conversion?
[Now] one easily meets beggars throughout the world, but offenders only with difficulty: if I offend no one, who will offend me?
It is therefore like a treasure miraculously appeared in my house, an enemy who comes of his own accord, an incomparable helper in the practice of holiness: he must be cherished.
By our combined efforts, [he offending, I forgiving,] I shall obtain the fruit of patience, [the supreme knowledge of a Buddha]. It is to him first that I shall impart my conquest, for he is the source and the occasion of my patience.
“But my enemy has no intention of increasing my patience and deserves [neither my gifts], nor my worship, [nor my love].” — Why then venerate the Good Law, the unconscious cause of our sanctification?
“But the enemy intends to harm!” [Ah, I know it; that is why he is so precious:] do you expect to practise the forgiveness of injuries toward a devoted physician?
If there is patience, [forgiveness of injuries], it is because there is the intention to harm. It is through this intention that the enemy, the cause of patience, is worthy of veneration, as the Good Law is.
It is for this reason that the Buddha declared: “Creatures are one field [of merit], the Buddhas are another field.” Many are [the saints] who have reached the other shore of [worldly and supernatural] felicities, either by virtue of creatures or by virtue of the Buddhas.
In creatures and in the Buddhas resides the same efficacy for acquiring the nature of a Buddha. Why refuse to the one the veneration we grant to the other? Why make a difference?
The greatness of the intention must be judged, not by its own worth, but by the results it produces: now, from this point of view, creatures have the same importance [as the Buddhas]; therefore they shall be placed on the same rank.
What constitutes the greatness proper to creatures is that [the saint], through his charitable intention [toward them, becomes an] adorable [Buddha]. What constitutes the greatness proper to the Buddhas is the merit produced by faith in the Buddha and by love.
Creatures are comparable to the Buddhas because they contribute, in part, to the acquisition of the nature of a Buddha; but, in reality, there is not one of them comparable to the Buddhas, oceans of qualities everywhere unfathomable.
Of these unique accumulations of the essence of every quality, if a single atom exists in a creature, the triple world is an insufficient homage to honour it worthily.
Now, in creatures there exists, excellent though partial, this faculty of producing [in the charitable, in the patient, etc.] the nature of a Buddha. Creatures must therefore be honoured by reason of this partial faculty.
Besides, if not by serving creatures, how shall we obtain forgiveness from the [Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas], sincere kinsmen, priceless benefactors?
[The Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas], for the sake of creatures, tear their bodies and endure the pains of hell; what is done to creatures is done to the Buddhas; to my cruellest enemies I must do all the good that all the powers of my being can do.
Our Masters, [Buddhas and Bodhisattvas], freely, without a thought, give up even their lives for the salvation of creatures; and we, the servants of these charitable Masters, who ought to be the slaves [of these creatures so dearly loved], what selfishness! what pride!
When creatures are happy, the Buddha-Kings rejoice; they are grieved when creatures suffer; they are content, every one of them, when creatures are content: to offend creatures is to offend the Buddhas, [tender fathers of cherished children].
There is no delight, no pleasure for the wretched whose body is wrapped in flames: likewise, when creatures suffer, there is no joy for those who are compassion itself.
By making creatures suffer, I have therefore made all the Great Merciful Ones suffer. I wish to confess this sin today: may the Buddhas forgive me the harm I have done them.
From this moment, to appease the Buddhas [and fulfil their designs], I make myself the slave of creatures, body, voice, thought! Let the [kindly] crowd of men set their foot upon my head and crush it! May the Protector of beings [forgive me and] be satisfied!
“Can you doubt it? The [Buddhas], who are all compassion, have adopted every creature as their “self”. It is our Protectors themselves who appear in the guise of men; and you would despise them!
[To honour creatures and win their favour] is to honour the Buddhas and please them; it is to accomplish my own end [the state of a Buddha]; it is to drive suffering from the universe; it is therefore the vow to which I bind myself.
Without escort, one of the king’s men oppresses and outrages a numerous people: and the crowd, seeing from afar, lets itself be ill-treated without a word. It is because this man is not alone: the king’s strength is his strength.
Likewise, do not despise [because of his apparent weakness] the one who insults you: for the guardians of the hells and the [compassionate Buddhas] are, for him, like an army.
Respect creatures as a servant respects an irritable king. What furious king has torments like those of the hells, and what pleased king gives goods comparable to the state of a Buddha? Now creatures, displeased, damn us, and, pleased, make Buddhas of us.
But, not to speak of the state of a Buddha, the sure hope of one who satisfies creatures, do you not see that he secures for himself all perishable goods: popularity, glory, well-being, charming beauty, health, joy, long life, the abundant felicity of sovereign kings: such, in the course of existences, is the lot of the patient man.