This is what I have heard. Once the Blessed One was journeying through Kosala, accompanied by a great company of brethren, about five hundred in number. He came to the brahmin village of Kosala called Manasakāṭa. There, at Manasakāṭa, the Blessed One stayed in the mango grove, on the bank of the river Aciravati, to the south of Manasakāṭa.
At that time many very distinguished and wealthy brahmins were staying at Manasakāṭa: the brahmin Caṅkī, the brahmin Tarukkha, the brahmin Pokkharasāti, the brahmin Jānussoṇi, the brahmin Todeyya, and other very distinguished and wealthy brahmins.
Now a conversation sprang up between Vāseṭṭha and Bharadvāja, as they were taking exercise (after their bath) and walking up and down, thoughtfully, about the true path and the false.
The young brahmin Vāseṭṭha spoke thus:
“This is the straight path, this is the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma — I mean the one taught by the brahmin Pokkharasāti.”
The young brahmin Bharadvāja spoke thus:
“This is the straight path, this is the direct way
which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma —
I mean the one
taught by the brahmin Tarukkha.”
But the young brahmin Vāseṭṭha could not convince the young brahmin Bharadvāja, nor could the young brahmin Bharadvāja convince the young brahmin Vāseṭṭha.
Then the young brahmin Vāseṭṭha said to the young brahmin Bharadvāja:
“This samaṇa Gotama, Bharadvāja, of the Sâkya clan, who left the Sâkya tribe to embrace the religious life, is now staying at Manasākaṭa, in the mango grove, on the bank of the river Aciravatī, to the south of Manasākaṭa. Now such is the high reputation that has spread abroad concerning the venerable Gotama that he is said to be ‘fully awakened, blessed and worthy, abounding in wisdom and goodness, happy, knowing the world, unsurpassed guide of erring mortals, teacher of gods and men, a blessed Buddha.’
Come then, Bharadvāja, let us go to the place where the samaṇa Gotama is; and when we have arrived there, let us question the samaṇa Gotama on this matter. Whatever the samaṇa Gotama shall declare to us, let us keep it in mind.”
“Very well, my friend!” said the young brahmin Bharadvâja, in assent, to the young brahmin Vaseṭṭha.
Then the young brahmin Vaseṭṭha and the young brahmin Bharadvâja went to the Blessed One.
When they had arrived, they exchanged with the Blessed One the greetings and compliments of courtesy and friendship, and sat down beside him.
As they were thus seated, the young brahmin Vaseṭṭha said to the Blessed One:
“While we, Gotama, were taking exercise and walking up and down, a conversation sprang up between us about the true path and the false path. I said this:
“This is the straight path, the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma — I mean the one taught by the brahmin Pokkharasāti.”
Then Bharadvāja said:
“This is the straight path, the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma — I mean the one taught by the brahmin Tarukkha.”
“On this matter, Gotama, we disagree, we dispute, our opinions differ.”
“So then, Vaseṭṭha, you say that you said:
‘This is the straight path, the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma — I mean the one taught by the brahmin Pokkharasāti.’
While Bharadvāja said:
‘This is the straight path, the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma — I mean the one taught by the brahmin Tarukkha.’”
Wherein then, Vaseṭṭha, is there a quarrel, a dispute, a disagreement between you?
About the true path and the false, Gotama. Various Brahmins, Gotama, teach various paths: the Addhariya Brahmins, the Tittiriya Brahmins, the Chandoka Brahmins, the Chandava Brahmins, the Brahmachariya Brahmins. Do all these paths lead to salvation? Will they all lead him who follows them to union with Brahma?
Just as near a village or a town there are many different paths which nevertheless all lead to the village, so the various paths taught by the various Brahmins — the Addhariya Brahmins, the Tittiriya Brahmins, the Chandoka Brahmins, the Chandava Brahmins, the Brahmachariya Brahmins — do they all lead to salvation? Will they all lead him who follows them to union with Brahma?
“Do you say that they all lead to the goal, Vâsettha?”
“I say so, Gotama.”
“Do you really say that they all lead to the goal, Vâsettha?”
“Yes, that is what I say, Gotama.”
“But then, Vâsettha, is there a single one of the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas who has ever seen Brahma face to face?”
“No, indeed, Gotama.”
“But then, Vâsettha, is there a single one of the teachers of the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas who has seen Brahma face to face?”
“No, indeed, Gotama!”
“But then, Vâsettha, is there a single one of the pupils of the teachers of the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas who has seen Brahma face to face?”
“No, indeed, Gotama!”
“But then, Vâsettha, is there a single one of the brahmins, up to the seventh generation, who has seen Brahma face to face?”
“No, indeed, Gotama!”
“Well then, Vāseṭṭha, those ancient Rishis of the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, the authors of the verses, the reciters of the verses, whose ancient formulas the Brahmins of today chant or repeat, just as they were chanted, recited or composed, intoning or reciting them exactly as they were of old — namely Aṭṭaka, Vāmaka, Vāmadeva, Vessamitta, Yamataggi, Aṅgirasa, Bhāradvāja, Vāseṭṭha, Kassapa and Bhagu — did they themselves speak thus, saying: ‘We know it, we have seen it, we know where Brahma is, whence Brahma comes, whither Brahma goes’?”
“No, Gotama!”
“Then, Vāseṭṭha, you say [that none of the Brahmins, nor of their teachers, nor of their pupils, up to the seventh generation, has ever seen Brahma face to face. And that even the Rishis of
So the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas have indeed declared: “What we do not know, what we have not seen, to union with that we can show the way, and say: ‘This is the straight path, this is the direct way which leads him who follows it to union with Brahma!’”
“What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha? Does it not follow, this being so, that the talk of the brahmins, though versed in the Three Vedas, is foolish talk?”
“Verily, Gotama, this being so, it follows that the talk of the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is foolish talk!”
“Verily, Vāseṭṭha, that brahmins versed in the Three Vedas should be able to show the way to union with what they do not know and have not seen — such a situation does not exist!”
“Just as, Vāseṭṭha, when blind men hold on to one another by the hand, neither the first can see, nor the one in the middle, nor the last — so, it seems to me, Vāseṭṭha, the talk of the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is but the talk of the blind: the first does not see, the middle one does not see, and the last does not see either. The talk of these Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas thus turns out to be ridiculous, mere words, a vain and empty thing!”
“What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha? Can the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, like other common folk, see the sun and the moon when they pray to them, praise them and worship them, turning with joined hands towards the place where they rise and where they set?”
“Certainly, Gotama, they can.”
“What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha? The brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, who can very well — like other ordinary folk — see the sun and the moon as they pray to them, praise them and worship them, turning towards the place where they rise and where they set, with joined hands, are these brahmins versed in the Three Vedas able to point out the way that leads to union with the sun or the moon, saying: ‘This is the straight path, this is the direct way which leads him who acts according to it to union with the sun or the moon’?”
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“You say then, Vāseṭṭha, that the brahmins,
supporting one another, but in vain, and seeking in tears their guide as well as the way, have come to a miserable end!”
That they have seen], and you say further that [neither any one of them, nor any of their pupils, nor even any of their predecessors up to the seventh generation has ever seen Brahma]. And you say further that even the ancient Rishis, [whose words they hold in such deep respect, did not claim to know, or to have seen where, whence or whither Brahma is. Yet these Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas claim to be able to point out the way that leads to union with him whom they do not know and have not seen!]
What do you think, Vaseṭṭha? Does it not follow that, this being so, the talk of the Brahmins, though they be versed in the Three Vedas, is foolish talk?’
“Verily, Gotama, if this is so, it follows that the talk of the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is foolish!”
“Very good, Vāseṭṭha. Verily then, Vāseṭṭha, that the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas should be able to show the way leading to union with what they do not know and have never seen, such a thing does not exist.
“It is as if a man should say: ‘How I long for, how I love the most beautiful woman in this land!’
“And people should ask him: ‘Well, my friend! This most beautiful woman in the land whom you thus love and long for, do you know whether that beautiful woman is a noble lady, a Brahmin, a woman of the trader class or a Śūdra?’”
“But, when so asked, he would have to answer: ‘No.’
“And when people should ask him: ‘Well! my good friend! this woman, the most beautiful in all the land, whom you so love and long for, do you know what the name of this so beautiful woman is, or what her family name is, whether she is tall or short, dark or of medium complexion, black or fair, and in what village, town or city she dwells?’
“But, when so asked, he would have to answer: ‘No.’
“Then people would say to him: ‘So then, my good friend, you love and long for a woman whom you do not know and have never seen?’
“And, when so asked, he would have to answer: ‘Yes.’
“What do you think now, Vâseṭṭha? Would it not follow that the words of that man would be foolish words?”
“Verily, Gotama, it would follow, under these conditions, that the words of that man would be foolish words!”
“And it is precisely the same, Vāseṭṭha: though you say that the brahmins [are not able to point out the way that leads to union with him whom they have seen], and you say further that [neither any one of them, nor any of their disciples, nor any of their predecessors up to the seventh generation has ever seen Brahma]. And you say further that even the ancient Ṛṣis, [whose words they hold in such high esteem, did not claim to know or to have seen where, whence or whither Brahma is.
Yet these brahmins versed in the Three Vedas do indeed assert that they can point out the way that leads to union with him whom they do not know and have not seen!] What do you think, Vāseṭṭha? Does it not follow that, under these conditions, the words of the brahmins, however versed they may be in the Three Vedas, are foolish words?”
“Verily, Gotama, if this is so, it follows that the talk of the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is foolish talk!”
“Very good, Vāseṭṭha. Verily then, Vāseṭṭha, that the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas should be able to show the way that leads to union with what they do not know and have never seen, such a thing does not exist.
“It is as if a man were to build a staircase at the crossing of four roads, to climb up into a palace. And people were to say to him: ‘Well, my good friend, this palace, to climb up to which you are building this staircase, do you know whether it lies to the east, the south, the west or the north? Whether it is high, low or of middling size?’”
“And, if he were so questioned, he would have to answer: ‘No.’”
“And people would have to say to him: ‘But then, my good friend, you are building a staircase to climb up to something — which you take to be a palace — while you know very well that you have never known it or seen it!’”
“And, if he were so questioned, he would have to answer: ‘Yes.’”
“Now, what do you think, Vāseṭṭha? Would it not follow that the words of that man would be foolish?”
“Verily, Gotama, it would follow that the words of that man would be foolish!”
“And yet, Vāseṭṭha, though you say that the brahmins [are not able to point out the way leading to union with him whom they have seen], and you say further that [neither any one of them, nor their disciples, nor their predecessors up to the seventh generation have ever seen Brahma]. And you say further that even the Ṛṣis of old, [whose words they hold in such deep respect, did not claim to know or to have seen where, whence or whither Brahma is.
Yet these brahmins versed in the Three Vedas claim, forsooth, to be able to point out the way leading to union with him whom they do not know and have not seen!] Well, what do you think, Vāseṭṭha? Is it not evident that, this being so, the talk of the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is foolish?”
“Verily, Gotama, since this is so, it follows that the talk of the Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas is foolish talk!”
“Very good, Vāseṭṭha. Verily then, Vāseṭṭha, there is no such condition as that Brahmins versed in the Three Vedas could show the way leading to union with what they do not know and have not seen.”
“Again, Vāseṭṭha, if this river Aciravatī were full of water to the brim and overflowing, and a man with business on the other bank, bound for the other side, should come up and want to cross, and then, standing on this bank, he should invoke the further bank and say: ‘Come hither, O further bank! Come over to this side!’”
What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha? Would the opposite bank of the Aciravatī, because this man invokes it, prays to it, hopes for it and praises it, come over to this bank?
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“In the same way, Vāseṭṭha, the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas — neglecting the practice of those qualities which really make a man a brahmin, and adopting the practice of those qualities which really make men not brahmins — say: ‘We invoke Indra, we invoke Soma, we invoke Varuṇa, we invoke Īśāna, we invoke Prajāpati, we invoke Brahmā, we invoke Mahiddhi, we invoke Yama.’ Verily, Vāseṭṭha, that these brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, but neglecting the practice of those qualities which really make a man a brahmin, and adopting the practice of those qualities which really make men not brahmins, should become united with Brahmā after their death and the dissolution of their body, because they invoke him, pray to him, hope for him and praise him — verily, such a possibility does not exist!
“Just as, Vāseṭṭha, if this river Aciravatī were full to the brim and overflowing, and a man, having business on the other bank and bound for it, should come up and want to cross; and if, on this bank, his arms were bound fast behind his back with a strong chain. What do you think, Vāseṭṭha, would that man be able to get over from this bank of the river Aciravatī to the further bank?”
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“In the same way, Vāseṭṭha, there are five things leading to passion, which are called, in the Discipline of the Noble One, a ‘chain’ and a ‘bond.’”
“What are those five things?”
“Forms perceptible to the eye, desirable, agreeable, pleasant, attractive, accompanied by desire and arousing rapture. Sounds of the same kind, perceptible to the ear. Odours of the same kind, perceptible to the nose. Tastes of the same kind, perceptible to the tongue. Substances of the same kind, perceptible to the body by touch. These five things predisposing to passion are called, in the Discipline of the Noble One, a ‘chain’ and a ‘bond.’
And to these five things predisposing to desire, Vaseṭṭha, the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas are attached, they are infatuated with them, guilty with regard to them, they see not their danger, they know not how unreliable they are, and so they enjoy them.”
“And verily, Vāseṭṭha, that brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, but neglecting the practice of those qualities which truly make a man a brahmin, and adopting the practice of those qualities which truly make men non-brahmins — clinging to these five things predisposing to passion, infatuated by them, guilty with regard to them, not seeing their danger, not knowing their uncertainty, and thus delighting in them — that these brahmins, after their death and the dissolution of their body, should be united with Brahmā: such a situation does not exist.”
“Again, Vāseṭṭha, if this river Aciravatī were full of water to the brim and overflowing, and a man with business on the other bank, wishing to go there, should come up and want to cross it, and if, covering himself up even to his head, he should lie down on this bank to sleep —
“What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha? Would that man be able to get over from this bank of the river Aciravatī to the further bank?”
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“In the same way, Vāseṭṭha, there are these five hindrances in the Discipline of the Noble One, which are called ‘veils,’ ‘hindrances,’ ‘obstacles’ and ‘entanglements.’
“Which are the five?
“The hindrance of sensual desire,
The hindrance of ill will,
The hindrance of torpor and sloth,
The hindrance of pride and self-righteousness,
The hindrance of doubt.
“These are the five hindrances, Vāseṭṭha, which, in the Discipline of the Noble One, are called veils, hindrances, obstacles and entanglements.
“Now, Vāseṭṭha, the brahmins versed in the Three Vedas are veiled, hindered, obstructed and entangled by these five hindrances.
“And verily, Vāseṭṭha, that brahmins versed in the Three Vedas, but omitting to practise those qualities which truly make a man a brahmin, and practising those which truly make men non-brahmins — veiled, hindered, obstructed and entangled by these Five Hindrances — that these brahmins, after death, at the dissolution of the body, should become united with Brahmā: such a thing does not exist.
“What do you think now, Vāseṭṭha, and what have you heard said by the brahmins who are aged and well advanced in years, when pupils and teachers converse together? Has Brahmā wives and wealth, or has he none?”
“He has none, Gotama.”
“Is his mind full of anger, or free from anger?”
“Free from anger, Gotama.”
“Is his mind full of ill will, or free from it?”
“Free from it, Gotama.”
“Is his mind corrupt, or pure?”
“It is pure, Gotama.”
“Has he self-mastery, or has he not?”
“He has it, Gotama.”
“Now, what do you think, Vāseṭṭha, have the Brahmins versed in the Vedas wives and wealth, or have they none?”
“They have them, Gotama.”
“Does anger dwell in their hearts, or not?”
“It dwells there, Gotama.”
“Are they full of ill will, or not?”
“They are, Gotama.”
“Are their hearts pure, or not?”
“They are not, Gotama.”
“Have they self-mastery, or not?”
“They have not, Gotama.”
“You say then, Vāseṭṭha, that the Brahmins have wives and wealth, and that Brahma has none. Can there then be agreement and likeness between the Brahmins, who have wives and goods, and Brahma, who has none of these things?”
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“Very good, Vāseṭṭha. But verily, that these brahmins versed in the Vedas, who live married and in abundance, should after death, when the body is dissolved, become united with Brahma, who has none of these things — such a situation does not exist.”
“Then you say too, Vāseṭṭha, that the brahmins bear anger and ill will in their hearts, that they are sinful and without self-mastery, whereas Brahma is free from anger and ill will, sinless and master of himself. Can there then be agreement and likeness between the brahmins and Brahma?”
“Certainly not, Gotama!”
“Very good, Vāseṭṭha. That these brahmins versed in the Vedas, but who bear anger and ill will in their hearts, who are sinful and without self-mastery, should after death, when the body is dissolved, become united with Brahma, who is free from anger and ill will, sinless and master of himself — such a situation does not exist.”
“So then, Vaseṭṭha, the Brahmins, though they be versed in the Three Vedas, while they sit down (in confidence), are sinking down (into the mire); and sinking thus, they arrive only at despair, thinking all the while that they are crossing over into some happier land.
“Therefore the threefold wisdom of the Brahmins, learned in their Three Vedas, is called a waterless desert; their threefold wisdom is called a pathless jungle; their threefold wisdom is called destruction!”
When he had thus spoken, the young Brahmin Vaseṭṭha said to the Blessed One:
“I have been told, Gotama, that the Samaṇa Gotama knows the way that leads to union with Brahma.
“What do you think, Vaseṭṭha? Is not Manasakaṭa near here, and not far from this place?”
“It is just so, Gotama. Manasakaṭa is near here, it is not far from it.
“Now, what do you think, Vaseṭṭha? Suppose a man were born at Manasakaṭa, and people should ask him, who until then had never left Manasakaṭa, which is the way that leads to Manasakaṭa. Would that man, born and brought up at Manasakaṭa, be in doubt or difficulty?”
“Certainly not, Gotama! And why? If that man had been born and brought up at Manasakaṭa, every road that leads to Manasakaṭa would be perfectly familiar to him.”
Asiditva sawsidanti. I have no doubt that the commentator is right in his explanation of these figurative expressions. Confident in their knowledge of the Vedas and in their practice of the Vedic ceremonies, they neglect the higher things; and so, sinking into sin and superstition, “they only sink down into despair, while thinking that they are crossing over into some happier land.”
“That man, Vāseṭṭha, born and brought up at Manasakaṭa, might, if he were asked the way to Manasakaṭa, be seized by doubt and difficulty; but when the Tathāgata is questioned about the way that leads to the world of Brahma, he can feel neither doubt nor difficulty. For I know Brahma, Vāseṭṭha, the world of Brahma and the way that leads to it. Yes, I know it as one who has entered the world of Brahma and been born within it!”
When he had thus spoken, the young brahmin Vāseṭṭha said to the Blessed One:
“That is just what has been told me, Gotama: the samaṇa Gotama knows the way that leads to union with Brahma. It is well! Let the venerable Gotama be pleased to show us the way that leads to union with Brahma; let the venerable Gotama save the race of brahmins!”
“Listen then, Vāseṭṭha, give ear attentively, and I will speak!”
“So be it, Lord!” said the young brahmin Vāseṭṭha, in assent, to the Blessed One.
Then the Blessed One spoke and said:
“Know, Vāseṭṭha, that from time to time a Tathâgata appears in the world: a fully awakened one, blessed and worthy, abounding in wisdom and virtue, happy, knowing the world, unsurpassed guide of erring mortals, teacher of gods and men, a blessed Buddha. By himself he thoroughly understands and sees, as it were face to face, this universe — the lower world with all its spirits, and the higher worlds of Māra and of Brahmā — and all creatures, samaṇas and brahmins, gods and men; and then he makes known to others what he knows.
He proclaims the truth, both in its letter and in its spirit, lovely in its origin, lovely in its progress, lovely in its consummation; he makes known the higher life in all its purity and in all its perfection.”
“A householder (gahapati), or one of his children, or a man of low birth, of whatever class, hears that truth. On hearing the truth, he has faith in the Tathâgata; and when he has acquired that faith, he thus reflects within himself:
“‘Full of hindrances is the householder’s life, a path barred by passion; free as the air is the life of him who has renounced all worldly things. How difficult it is for the man who dwells at home to lead the higher life in all its fullness, in all its purity, in all its bright perfection! Then let me cut off my hair and beard, let me clothe myself in the
“‘Let me go forth from the household life into the homeless state!’”
“Then, before long, giving up his portion of wealth, be it great or small, giving up his circle of relatives, be they many or few, he cuts off his hair and beard, puts on the saffron-coloured robes, and goes forth from the household life into the homeless state.
“Having thus become a renunciant, he lives a life of self-restraint, according to the rules of the Patimokkha; uprightness is his delight, and he sees danger in the least of those things he should avoid. He adopts the precepts and trains himself in them; he surrounds himself with purity in word and deed; he sustains his life by means that are wholly pure; his conduct is good, the door of his senses is guarded; mindful and self-possessed, he is altogether happy.