Alāra and Uddaka were renowned among the brahmans, and no one in those days surpassed them in learning or in philosophical knowledge.
The Bodhisatta went to them and sat at their feet. He listened to their doctrines of the ātman or self, which is the ego of the mind and the doer of all deeds. He learned their views on the transmigration of souls and the law of karma: the souls of evil men were to suffer by being reborn in men of low caste, in animals or in hell, while those who purified themselves by libations, sacrifices and mortifications would become kings, brahmans or devas, and would thus rise ever higher in the grades of existence.
He studied their incantations and their offerings, as well as the methods by which, in states of ecstasy, they managed to free the ego from material existence.
Alāra said: “What is this self that perceives the actions of the five faculties of the mind: touch, smell, taste, sight and hearing? What is it that acts in the two kinds of movement, through the hands and through the feet? The problem of the soul reveals itself in the expressions: ‘_I_ speak’, ‘_I_ know and I perceive’, ‘_I_ come’, ‘_I_ go’ or ‘_I_ shall stay here’. Your soul is not your body; it is neither your eye, nor your ear, nor your nose, nor your tongue, nor your mind.
True liberation is attained by withdrawing from the crowd and leading a hermit’s life, depending entirely on alms for food. By putting away all desire and clearly recognising the non-existence of matter, we reach a state of perfect emptiness. There we discover the condition of immaterial existence. Like muñja grass freed from its tough sheath, like a sword drawn from its scabbard, or like the wild bird escaped from its cage, so the ego, freeing itself from all limitation, finds perfect deliverance. This is true liberation, but only those who have deep faith will learn it.”
True liberation is attained by withdrawing from the crowd and leading a hermit’s life, depending entirely on alms for food. By putting away all desire and clearly recognising the non-existence of matter, we reach a state of perfect emptiness. There we discover the condition of immaterial existence. Like muñja grass freed from its tough sheath, like a sword drawn from its scabbard, or like the wild bird escaped from its cage, so the ego, freeing itself from all limitation, finds perfect deliverance.
The Bodhisatta found no satisfaction in these teachings. He replied: “Men are in bondage because they have not yet given up the idea of the self.
“In our thought, the thing and its quality are different, but they are not so in reality. In our thought, heat is different from fire, but in reality you cannot separate heat from fire. You say that you can remove the qualities and leave the thing, but if you carry your theory to its end you will find that this is not so.
“Is not man an organism made up of many aggregates? Are we not composed of various attributes? Man consists of material form, sensations, thoughts, dispositions and, lastly, understanding. What men call the self when they say ‘I am’ is not an entity behind the attributes; it arises from their cooperation. There is mind; there are sensations and thoughts, and there is truth; and truth is mind when it follows the path of righteousness.
But there is no separate self-soul outside or behind human thought. He who believes that the self is a distinct being has no right conception of things. The very search for the ātman is mistaken; it starts from a false principle and will lead you in a wrong direction.
“How much confusion of thought comes from our attachment to ourselves and from our vanity when we think: ‘I am so great’, or: ‘I have done this wonderful deed!’ The thought of your self stands between your rational nature and the truth; banish it, and then you will see things as they are. He who thinks rightly will rid himself of ignorance and acquire wisdom. The ideas ‘I am’, ‘I shall be’ or ‘I shall not be’ do not occur to a clear thinker.
“Moreover, if our self remains, how can we attain true deliverance? If the self is to be reborn in one of the three worlds, whether in hell, on earth or even in heaven, we shall meet again and again the same inescapable fate of suffering. We shall remain chained to the wheel of individuality and entangled in selfishness and error.
“Every compound thing is subject to separation, and we cannot escape birth, sickness, old age and death. Is that a final deliverance?”
Uddaka said: “Consider the unity of things. Things are not their parts, and yet they exist. The limbs and organs of your body are not your self, but your self possesses all these parts. What, for instance, is the Ganges? Is the sand the Ganges? Is the water the Ganges? Is this bank the Ganges? Is the opposite bank the Ganges? The Ganges is a great river that possesses all these various qualities. It is exactly the same with our self.”
But the Bodhisatta replied: “No, sir! If we leave aside the water, the sand, this bank and the opposite bank, where can any Ganges be found? In the same way, I observe the activities of man in their harmonious union, but nothing allows us to establish a self apart from its parts.”
The wise brahman nevertheless insisted on the existence of the self, saying: “The self is the doer of our deeds. How can there be karma without a self to perform it? Do we not see around us the effects of karma? What makes men different in their character, their station, their possessions and their destiny? It is their karma, and karma includes merit and demerit. The transmigration of the soul is subject to its karma. We inherit from former existences the evil effects of our evil deeds and the good effects of our good deeds. If it were not so, how could we be different?”
The Tathâgata meditated deeply on the problems of transmigration and karma, and discovered the truth they contain.
“The doctrine of karma,” he said, “is undeniable, but your theory of the self has no foundation.
“Like everything that exists in nature, the life of man is subject to the law of cause and effect. The present reaps what the past has sown, and the future is the product of the present. But there is no evidence of an immutable self-being, of a self that remains the same and migrates from one body to another. There is rebirth, but no transmigration.
“Is not this individuality of mine a combination, material as well as mental? Is it not made up of qualities that have arisen in the course of a gradual evolution? The five sense faculties of this organism come from ancestors who exercised them. The ideas I think came to me partly from others who thought them, and partly they arise from combinations of ideas in my own mind. Those who used the same sense organs and thought the same ideas before I took shape in this individuality of mine are my former existences; they are my ancestors just as the _I_ of yesterday is the father of the _I_ of today, and the karma of my past deeds conditions the destiny of my present existence.
“Supposing there were an ātman that performed the acts of the senses, then, if the door of sight were torn down and the eye plucked out, that ātman could look through the enlarged opening and see the forms of its surroundings better and more clearly than before. It could hear sounds better if the ears were torn away; smell better if the nose were cut off; taste better if the tongue were pulled out; and feel better if the body were destroyed.
“I observe the preservation and transmission of character; I perceive the truth of karma, but I see no ātman which, according to your doctrine, would be the doer of your deeds. There is rebirth without the transmigration of a self. For this ātman, this self, this ego of the ‘_I_ say’ and the ‘_I_ will’, is an illusion. If this self were a reality, how could one escape from selfhood? The terror of hell would be infinite, and no deliverance could be granted. The ills of existence would not be due to our ignorance and our evil deeds, but would constitute the very nature of our being.”
And the Bodhisatta went to the priests who officiated in the temples. But the gentle mind of the Sakyamuni was shocked by the needless cruelty performed on the altars of the gods. He said:
“Only ignorance can drive these men to prepare feasts and hold great assemblies for sacrifices. It is far better to revere the truth than to try to appease the gods by shedding blood.
“What love can a man possess who believes that the destruction of life will atone for evil deeds? Can a new wrong atone for old wrongs? And can the slaughter of an innocent victim blot out the evil deeds of mankind? That is practising religion while neglecting moral conduct.
“Purify your hearts and cease to kill; that is true religion.
“Rituals have no efficacy; prayers are but vain repetitions; and incantations have no power to save. But to abandon covetousness and lust, to become free from evil passions, to give up all hatred and all ill will: that is the right sacrifice and the true worship.”