← Back to the lesson (Lesson 23)

Buddhism

The Gospel of Buddha, XLIX — The Two Brahmans.

Once, when the Blessed One was passing through Kosala, he came to the Brahman village called Manasākata. There he stayed in a mango grove.

Two young Brahmans belonging to different schools came to him. One was named Vāsettha and the other Bhāradvāja. Vāsettha said to the Blessed One:

“We have a dispute about the true path. I say that the straight path which leads to union with Brahmā is the one taught by the Brahman Pokkharasāti, while my friend maintains that the straight path which leads to union with Brahmā is the one taught by the Brahman Tārukkha.

“Now, considering your high reputation, O samana, and knowing that you are called the Awakened One, the teacher of men and gods, the blessed Buddha, we have come to ask you: are all these paths paths of salvation? Many roads surround our village, and all lead to Manasākata. Is it the same with the paths of the sages? Do all paths lead to salvation, and do they all lead to union with Brahmā?”

The Blessed One put these questions to the two Brahmans: “Do you think that all paths are right?”

Both answered: “Yes, Gotama, we think so.”

“But tell me,” continued the Buddha, “has any one of the Brahmans versed in the Vedas seen Brahmā face to face?”

“No, sir!” was the reply.

“But then,” said the Blessed One, “has any teacher of the Brahmans, versed in the Vedas, ever seen Brahmâ face to face?”

The two Brahmans answered: “No, sir.”

“But then,” said the Blessed One, “has any one of the authors of the Vedas ever seen Brahmâ face to face?”

Again the two Brahmans answered in the negative and exclaimed: “How could anyone see Brahmâ or understand him, since the mortal cannot understand the immortal?” And the Blessed One gave an illustration, saying:

“It is as if a man were to build a staircase at the crossing of four roads, to mount up into a palace. And people asked him: ‘Where, good friend, is this palace to mount up into which you are building this staircase? Do you know whether it is in the east, the south, the west or the north? Whether it is high, low or of middle size?’ And when so asked he answered: ‘I do not know.’ And the people said to him: ‘But then, good friend, you are building a staircase to mount up into something — which you take to be a palace — when you do not know what it is and have never seen it.’

And when so asked he answered: ‘That is exactly what I am doing; yes, I know that I cannot know it.’ What would you think of him? Would you not say that this man’s talk is foolish?”

“Truly, Gotama,” said the two Brahmans, “that would be foolish talk!”

The Blessed One continued: “Then the Brahmans should say: ‘We show you the way to union with what we do not know and have not seen.’ Since this is the foundation of Brahman learning, does it not follow that their task is vain?”

“It does follow,” replied Bhāradvāja.

The Blessed One said: “It is therefore impossible that Brahmans versed in the three Vedas should be able to show the way to a state of union with what they neither know nor have seen. It is like a string of blind men holding on to one another. Neither the first can see, nor those in the middle can see, nor the last can see. In the same way, it seems to me, the talk of the Brahmans versed in the three Vedas is but blind talk; it is ridiculous, consists of mere words, and is vain and empty.”

“Now suppose,” added the Blessed One, “that a man came here, to the bank of the river, and that, having some business on the other bank, he wanted to cross. Do you think that, if he were to invoke the other bank to come over to him, to this side, it would come in answer to his prayers?”

“Certainly not, Gotama.”

“Yet such is the way of the Brahmans. They omit to cultivate the qualities that truly make a man a Brahman, and they say: ‘Indra, we call upon you; Soma, we call upon you; Varuna, we call upon you; Brahmā, we call upon you.’ Truly, it is impossible that these Brahmans, by their invocations, their prayers and their praises, should be united with Brahmā after death.”

“Now tell me,” continued the Buddha, “what do the Brahmans say of Brahmā? Is his mind full of desire?”

And when the Brahmans answered in the negative, the Buddha asked:

“Is the mind of Brahmā full of malice, sloth or pride?”

“No, sir!” was the reply. “He is the very opposite.”

And the Buddha went on: “But are the Brahmans free from these vices?”

“No, sir!” said Vāsettha.

The Holy One said: “The Brahmans cling to the five things that lead to worldliness and yield to the temptations of the senses; they are caught in the five hindrances: desire, malice, sloth, pride and doubt. How could they be united with what is so contrary to their nature? Thus the threefold wisdom of the Brahmans is a waterless desert, a pathless jungle and a hopeless desolation.”

When the Buddha had thus spoken, one of the Brahmans said: “We are told, Gotama, that the Sakyamuni knows the path that leads to union with Brahmā.”

And the Blessed One said: “What do you think, O Brahmans, of a man born and brought up in Manasākata? Would he have any doubt about the most direct way from here to Manasākata?

— Certainly not, Gotama.

— Thus,” replied the Buddha, “the Tathâgata knows the straight path that leads to union with Brahmā. He knows it as one who has entered the world of Brahmā and has been born there. The Tathâgata can have no doubt.”

And the two young Brahmans said: “If you know the path, show it to us.”

And the Buddha said:

“The Tathâgata sees the universe face to face and understands its nature. He proclaims the truth in its letter as in its spirit, and his teaching is glorious in its origin, glorious in its progress, glorious in its consummation. The Tathâgata reveals the higher life in its purity and perfection. He can show you the path that leads to what is contrary to the five great hindrances.

“The Tathâgata lets his mind pervade the four quarters of the world with thoughts of love. And thus the whole wide world, above, below, around and everywhere, will continue to be filled with love, far-reaching, grown great and beyond measure.

“Just as a mighty trumpeter makes himself heard — and that without difficulty — in the four quarters of the earth, so it is with the coming of the Tathâgata: there is not one living being that the Tathâgata passes over or leaves aside, but he regards them all with a mind set free and with deep-felt love.

“And this is the sign that a man follows the right path: uprightness is his delight, and he sees danger in the least of the things he should avoid. He trains himself in the precepts of morality, he surrounds himself with holiness in word and deed; he sustains his life by means that are quite pure; his conduct is good, the door of his senses is well guarded; mindful and self-possessed, he is altogether happy.

“He who walks with unshaken resolve on the noble eightfold path is sure to attain Nirvâna. The Tathâgata watches anxiously over his children and, with tender kindness, helps them to see the light.

“When a hen has eight, ten or twelve eggs, over which she has properly brooded, the wish arises in her heart: ‘Oh, if only my little chicks could break the shell with their claws or their beaks, and come forth safely into the light!’ Yet those little chicks are sure to break the shell and will come forth safely into the light. In the same way, a brother who walks with firm resolve on the noble path is sure to come forth into the light, to attain the higher wisdom and to reach the supreme bliss of enlightenment.”

Source Paul Carus, The Gospel of Buddha (1894), Project Gutenberg #35895 — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents