← Back to the lesson (Lesson 60)

Buddhism

The Gospel of Buddha, LI — Simha’s Question Concerning Annihilation.

At that time many distinguished citizens were gathered in the town hall and were speaking in various ways in praise of the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha. Simha, the commander-in-chief, a disciple of the sect of the Nigganthas, was among them. And Simha thought: “Truly, the Blessed One must be the Buddha, the Holy One. I will go and visit him.”

Then Simha, the general, went to where the chief of the Nigganthas, Nātaputta, was; having approached him, he said: “Lord, I wish to visit the samana Gotama.”

Nātaputta said: “Why should you, Simha, who believe in the consequences of deeds according to their moral merit, go to visit the samana Gotama, who denies the consequences of deeds? The samana Gotama, O Simha, denies the consequences of deeds; he teaches the doctrine of non-action, and it is in this doctrine that he trains his disciples.”

Then the desire that Simha, the general, had felt to go and visit the Blessed One subsided.

Hearing again the praises of the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, Simha questioned the chief of the Nigganthas a second time; and Nātaputta again persuaded him not to go.

A third time, after hearing distinguished men extol the merits of the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, the general thought: “Truly, the samana Gotama must be the holy Buddha. What do the Nigganthas matter to me, whether they give their consent or not? I will go, without asking their permission, to visit him who is the Blessed One, the holy Buddha.”

And Simha, the general, said to the Blessed One: “Lord, I have heard that the samana Gotama denies the fruit of deeds; he teaches the doctrine of non-action, saying that the deeds of sentient beings do not receive their just reward, for he teaches annihilation and contempt for all things; and it is according to this doctrine that he instructs his disciples. Do you teach the abolition of the soul and the annihilation of the human being? I pray you, Lord, do those who speak thus tell the truth, or do they bear false witness against the Blessed One, passing off a false Dharma as your Dharma?”

The Blessed One said:

“There is a way, Simha, in which one who speaks thus speaks truly of me; but, Simha, there is also a way in which one who says the opposite also speaks truly of me. Listen, and I will explain it to you:

“I teach, Simha, not to do unrighteous deeds, whether by deed, by word, or by thought; I teach not to bring forth the states of heart that are evil and not good. However, Simha, I teach to do righteous deeds, by deed, by word, and by thought; I teach to bring forth the states of heart that are good and not evil.”

“I teach, Simha, that all the dispositions of the mind that are evil and harmful, all the unrighteous actions performed by the body, by speech, and by thought, must be burned away. He who has freed himself, Simha, from all these dispositions of the mind that are evil and harmful, who has destroyed them like an uprooted palm tree, so that they can never grow again, he has accomplished the eradication of self.

“I proclaim, Simha, the annihilation of egotism, of desire, of ill will, and of delusion. However, I do not proclaim the annihilation of patience, of love, of charity, and of truth.

“I hold, Simha, unrighteous actions to be contemptible, whether they are performed by the body, by speech, or by thought; but I hold virtue and righteousness to be worthy of praise.”

And Simha said: “One doubt still remains in my mind concerning the doctrine of the Blessed One. Will the Blessed One consent to dispel the cloud, so that I may understand the Dharma as the Blessed One teaches it?”

The Tathâgata having given his consent, Simha continued: “I am a soldier, O Blessed One, and the king has charged me with enforcing his laws and waging his wars. Does the Tathâgata, who teaches boundless kindness and compassion toward all who suffer, permit the punishment of the criminal? And, moreover, does the Tathâgata declare that it is wrong to go to war to protect our homes, our wives, our children, and our property?

Does the Tathâgata teach the doctrine of absolute self-surrender, so that I should let the evildoer do as he pleases and yield meekly to him who threatens to take by violence what belongs to me? Does the Tathâgata maintain that all strife, including a war waged for a just cause, should be forbidden?”

The Buddha replied: “He who deserves to be punished must be punished, and he who deserves a favor must receive one. Yet at the same time, he teaches to do no harm to any living being, but to be filled with love and kindness. These precepts are not contradictory, for whoever must be punished for the crimes he has committed suffers the injury not through the ill will of the judge, but because of his own misdeeds. It is his own acts that have brought upon him the injury inflicted by the executor of the law.

When a magistrate punishes, let him harbor no hatred in his heart; yet a murderer, when he is put to death, should understand that this penalty is the fruit of his own acts. As soon as he understands that this penalty will purify his soul, he will no longer lament his fate, but will rejoice in it.”

And the Blessed One continued: “The Tathâgata teaches that every war in which man seeks to slay his brother is lamentable, but he does not teach that those who go to war for a just cause, after having exhausted every means of preserving peace, are blameworthy. It is he who is the cause of the war who must be blamed.

“The Tathâgata teaches complete self-surrender, but he does not teach that anything should be yielded to the powers of evil, whether they be men, gods, or the elements of nature. One must struggle, for all life is a struggle of some kind. But he who struggles must take care not to struggle in his own interest, against truth and justice.”

“He who struggles in his own interest, so that he himself may become great, powerful, rich, or famous, will reap no fruit from it; but he who struggles for justice and truth will reap great fruit from it, for even his defeat will be a victory.

“The self is not a vessel fit to receive any great success whatsoever; it is small and fragile, and its contents will soon spill out, to the benefit — and perhaps also to the misfortune — of others.

“Truth, on the other hand, is vast enough to receive the aspirations and desires of all selves; and when these burst like soap bubbles, their contents will be preserved and, in the truth, they will lead a life everlasting.

“He who goes into battle, O Simha, even for a just cause, must be ready to be slain by his enemies, for such is the destiny of warriors; and if his fate strikes him, he has no reason to complain.

“But he who is victorious must remember the instability of earthly things. His success may be great, but however great it may be, the wheel of fortune may turn again and cast him down into the dust.

“However, if he masters himself and, extinguishing all hatred in his heart, raises up his stricken adversary and says to him: ‘Come, let us make peace and be brothers,’ he will win a victory that will not be a fleeting success, for its fruits will endure forever.”

“A great general wins great victories, O Simha, but he who has conquered himself is the greatest of conquerors.

“The doctrine of self-conquest, O Simha, is not taught to destroy the souls of men, but to preserve them. He who has conquered himself is more fit to live, to succeed, and to win victories than he who is the slave of self.

“He whose mind is free from the illusion of self will stand firm and will not fall in the battle of life.

“He whose intentions are upright and just will know no failure, but will succeed in his undertakings, and his success will endure.

“He who cherishes in his heart the love of truth will live and will not die, for he has drunk the water of immortality.

“Struggle, then, courageously, O general, and fight your battles with vigor, but be a soldier of truth, and the Tathâgata will bless you.”

When the Blessed One had thus spoken, Simha, the general, said: “Glorious Lord, glorious Lord! You have revealed the truth. Great is the doctrine of the Blessed One. You are truly the Buddha, the Tathâgata, the Holy One. You are the teacher of mankind. You show us the way of salvation, for this, in truth, is deliverance. He who follows you will not fail to find the light that will illumine his path. He will find bliss and peace. I take refuge, Lord, in the Blessed One, in his teaching, and in his community. May the Blessed One receive me, from this day and for the whole length of my life, as a disciple who has taken refuge in him.”

And the Blessed One said: “Consider first, Simha, what you are doing. It is fitting that persons of high rank like you should not act without due reflection.”

Simha’s faith in the Blessed One increased. He replied: “Had other teachers succeeded, Lord, in making me their disciple, they would parade their banners through the whole city of Vesālī, crying: ‘Simha, the general, has become our disciple!’ For the second time, Lord, I take refuge in the Blessed One, in the Dharma, and in the Sangha. May the Blessed One accept me from this day and until the end of my life as a disciple who has taken refuge in him.”

The Blessed One said: “For a long time, Simha, offerings have been made to the Nigganthas in your house. You should therefore also deem it right, in the future, to give them food when they come to you on their alms round.”

And Simha’s heart was filled with joy. He said: “I have been told, Lord: ‘The samana Gotama says: To me alone, and to no other, should gifts be given. My disciples alone, and those of no other, should receive offerings.’ Yet the Blessed One exhorts me to give to the Nigganthas also. Well, Lord, we shall see what is fitting in due time. For the third time, Lord, I take refuge in the Blessed One, in his Dharma, and in his brotherhood.”

Source Paul Carus, The Gospel of Buddha (1894), Project Gutenberg #35895 — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents