← Back to the lesson (Lesson 85)

Buddhism

The Gospel of Buddha, LIII — Identity and Non-Identity.

Kūtadanta, chief of the brahmans of the village of Dānamatī, having respectfully approached the Blessed One, greeted him and said to him: “I am told, O samana, that you are the Buddha, the Holy One, the All-knowing, the Lord of the world. But if you were the Buddha, would you not come like a king, in all your glory and all your power?”

The Blessed One said: “Your eyes are veiled. If the eye of your mind were not darkened, you could see the glory and the power of truth.”

Kūtadanta said: “Show me the truth, and I will see it. But your doctrine lacks consistency. If it were consistent, it would endure; but since it is not, it will pass away.”

The Blessed One replied: “The truth will never pass away.”

Kūtadanta said: “I am told that you teach the law, and yet you overthrow religion. Your disciples despise rites and renounce sacrifices, but reverence toward the gods can be shown only through sacrifices. The very nature of religion consists in worship and sacrifices.”

The Buddha said: “The sacrifice of self is better than the slaughter of bulls. He who offers to the gods his evil desires will see how useless it is to slaughter animals on the altar. Blood has no power to purify, but the uprooting of desire will make the heart pure. Better than worshiping the gods is it to obey the laws of righteousness.”

Kūtadanta, a man of religious disposition and anxious about his fate after death, had sacrificed countless victims. Now he saw the folly of atonement by blood. However, the teachings of the Tathāgata did not yet satisfy him, and Kūtadanta continued: “You believe, O Master, that beings are reborn; that they migrate in the course of the evolution of life; and that, subject to the law of karma, we must reap what we have sown.

Yet you teach the non-existence of the soul! Your disciples praise complete extinction as the supreme bliss of Nirvâna. If I am merely a combination of sankhāras, my existence will cease when I die. If I am merely a compound of sensations, ideas, and desires, where can I go when the body is dissolved?”

The Blessed One said: “O Brahman, you are religious and sincere. You care deeply about your soul. Yet your work is in vain, for you lack the one thing needful.

“There is rebirth of character, but no transmigration of a self. Your thought-forms reappear, but no ego-entity is transferred. The stanza uttered by a teacher is reborn in the pupil who repeats the words.

“It is only through ignorance and delusion that men indulge in the dream that their souls are separate and self-existent entities.

“Your heart, O Brahman, still clings to self; you are anxious about heaven, but you seek there the pleasures of self, and thus you cannot see the bliss of truth nor the immortality of truth.”

“Truly, I say to you: the Blessed One has not come to teach death, but life, and you do not discern the nature of life and death.

“This body will fall apart, and no sacrifice, however great, will save it. Seek, therefore, the life of the mind. Where self is, truth cannot be; but when truth comes, self disappears. Let your mind, then, rest in the truth; spread the truth, put your whole will into it, and let it spread. In the truth you will live forever.

“Self is death, and truth is life. To cling to self is to die unceasingly; whereas to walk in the truth is to partake of Nirvâna, which is life everlasting.”

Kûtadanta said: “Where is Nirvâna, O venerable Master?”

“Nirvâna is wherever the precepts are observed,” replied the Blessed One.

“Am I to understand that Nirvâna is not a place and that, being nowhere, it has no reality?” the brahman went on.

“You do not understand me rightly,” said the Blessed One. “Listen now and answer these questions: where does the wind dwell?”

“Nowhere,” was the answer.

The Buddha retorted: “Then, sir, the wind does not exist.”

Kûtadanta did not reply; and the Blessed One asked again: “Answer me, O brahman: where does wisdom dwell? Is wisdom a place?”

“Wisdom has no allotted dwelling,” replied Kûtadanta.

The Blessed One said: “Do you mean that there is no wisdom, no enlightenment, no righteousness, no salvation, because Nirvâna is not a place? Like a great and mighty wind that sweeps across the world in the heat of the day, the Tathâgata comes to blow upon the minds of men with the breath of his love, so cool, so sweet, so peaceful, so gentle; and those tormented by fever assuage their sufferings and rejoice in this refreshing breeze.”

Kūtadanta said: “I feel, O Lord, that you proclaim a great doctrine, but I cannot grasp it. Forgive me for asking you one more question: tell me, O Lord, if there is no ātman, how can there be immortality? The activity of the mind passes away, and our thoughts vanish when we have finished thinking.”

The Buddha replied: “Our thinking is extinguished, but our thoughts remain. Reasoning ceases, but knowledge endures.”

Kūtadanta said: “How is that? Are reasoning and knowledge not the same?”

The Blessed One explained the difference by a comparison: “It is as when a man wishes to send a letter during the night: after having his secretary called, he has a lamp lit and the letter written. Then, when that is done, he puts out the lamp. But although the letter is finished and the light has been put out, the letter remains. Thus reasoning ceases and knowledge endures; in the same way, mental activity ceases, but experience, wisdom, and all the fruits of our deeds endure.”

Kūtadanta continued: “Tell me, O Lord, I pray you, tell me: if the sankhāras are dissolved, where is the identity of my self? If my thoughts are passed on and if my soul transmigrates, my thoughts cease to be my thoughts and my soul ceases to be my soul. Give me an illustration, but I pray you, O Lord, tell me: where is the identity of my self?”

The Blessed One said: “Suppose a man lights a lamp; would it burn all night?”

“Yes, it might,” was the answer.

“Now, is the flame that burns during the first watch of the night the same as the one that burns during the second?”

Kūtadanta hesitated. He thought: “Yes, it is the same flame,” but, fearing the complications of a hidden meaning and seeking to be exact, he said: “No, it is not the same.”

“Then,” continued the Blessed One, “there are two flames: one during the first watch, the other during the second.”

“No, sir,” said Kūtadanta. “In one sense it is not the same flame, but in another sense it is the same. It burns the same kind of oil, sheds the same kind of light, and serves the same purpose.”

“Very well,” said the Buddha. “And would you call identical the flames that burned yesterday and that are burning now in the same lamp, filled with the same kind of oil, lighting the same room?”

“They may have gone out during the day,” suggested Kūtadanta.

The Blessed One said: “Suppose the flame of the first watch had gone out during the second watch; would you say it is the same flame if it burns again during the third watch?”

Kūtadanta replied: “In one sense it is a different flame; in another, it is not.”

The Tathâgata asked further: “Has the time that elapsed while the flame was out anything to do with its identity or its non-identity?”

“No, lord,” replied the brahman, “it has nothing to do with it. There is difference and identity, whether many years have passed or a single second, and also whether the lamp has been put out in the meantime or not.”

“Well, then, we agree that today’s flame is, in a certain sense, the same as yesterday’s, and that in another sense it is different at every moment. Moreover, flames of the same kind, which light similar rooms with equal power, are, in a certain sense, the same.”

“Yes, lord,” replied Kūtadanta.

The Blessed One continued: “Now, suppose there is a man who feels the same as you, thinks like you, and acts like you; is he not the same man as you?”

“No, lord,” interrupted Kūtadanta.

The Buddha said: “Do you deny that the same logic that applies to the things of the world applies also to yourself?”

Kūtadanta reflected, then replied slowly: “No, I do not think so. The same reasoning holds universally; but my self has a peculiarity that makes it quite different from everything else, and from other selves as well. Another man may feel exactly as I do, think as I do, and act as I do; suppose even that he bears the same name and owns the same property: he would not be me.”

“That is true, Kūtadanta,” replied the Buddha, “he would not be you. Now tell me: is the person who goes to school one person, and that same person, when he has finished his studies, another? Is it one person who commits a crime, and another who is punished by having his hands and feet cut off?”

“It is the same person,” he replied.

“Then is permanence constituted only by continuity?” asked the Tathâgata.

“Not only by continuity,” replied Kūtadanta, “but also, and above all, by identity of character.”

“Very well,” concluded the Buddha; “you agree, then, that persons can be the same, just as two flames of the same kind are said to be identical; and you must acknowledge that in this sense another man, of the same character and the product of the same karma, is the same as you.”

“Well, I acknowledge it,” said the brahman.

The Buddha continued: “And it is in this sense alone that you are today the same as yesterday. Your nature is not constituted by the matter of which your body is composed, but by your sankhâras, the forms of the body, of sensations, and of thoughts. Your person is the combination of the sankhâras. Wherever they are, there you are. Wherever they go, you follow them. Thus you will acknowledge, in a certain sense, the identity of your self and, in another sense, its difference.

But he who does not acknowledge this identity would have to deny all identity and say that the one who asks the question is no longer the same person as the one who, a minute later, receives the answer. Consider now the continuation of your personality, preserved in your karma. Do you call it death and annihilation, or life and continued life?”

“I call it life and continued life,” replied Kūtadanta, “for it is the continuation of my existence, but I do not care for this kind of continuation. All that matters to me is the continuation of self in the other sense, which makes every man, whether or not he is identical with me, an altogether different person.”

“Very well,” said the Buddha. “That is what you desire, and that is attachment to self. That is your error. All compound things are transitory: they grow and decay. All compound things are subject to suffering: they will be separated from what they love and joined to what they abhor. All compound things are devoid of self, of ātman, of ego.”

“How is that?” asked Kūtadanta.

“Where is your self?” asked the Buddha. And, as Kūtadanta did not reply, he continued: “The self to which you cling is in perpetual change. Years ago you were a little child; then you were a boy; then a young man, and now you are a man. Is there an identity between the child and the man? There is identity only in a certain sense. Indeed, there is more identity between the flames of the first and the third watch, even though the lamp may have gone out during the second watch. Now, which is your true self: that of yesterday, that of today, or that of tomorrow, whose preservation you demand?”

Kūtadanta was perplexed. “Lord of the world,” he said, “I see my error, but I am still in confusion.”

The Tathâgata continued: “It is through a process of evolution that sankhâras come into being. No sankhâra has arisen without gradual becoming. Your sankhâras are the product of your deeds in former existences. The sum of your sankhâras constitutes your self. Wherever they are impressed, there your self goes. In your sankhâras you will continue to live and, in your future existences, you will reap the harvest sown today and in the past.”

“Truly, O Lord,” Kūtadanta went on, “this is not a just retribution. I cannot acknowledge the justice that would have others, after me, reap what I sow today.”

The Blessed One waited a moment, then replied: “Is all teaching in vain? Do you not understand that those others are you yourself? It is you yourself who will reap what you sow, and not others.

“Think of a man ill-bred and destitute, who suffers from the wretchedness of his condition. As a child he was lazy and indolent, and when he grew up he had learned no trade by which to earn his living. Would you say that his misery is not the product of his own deeds, on the ground that the adult is no longer the same person as the child?”

“Truly, I say to you: neither in the heavens, nor in the midst of the sea, nor if you hide in the clefts of the mountains, will you find a place where you can escape the fruit of your evil deeds.

“At the same time, you are certain to receive the blessings of your good deeds.

“The man who has long been traveling and returns home safe and sound is welcomed by his kinsfolk, his friends, and his acquaintances. So too, the fruits of his good works welcome him who has walked the path of righteousness, when he passes from the present life into the hereafter.”

Kūtadanta said: “I have faith in the glory and excellence of your doctrines. My eye cannot yet bear their light; but I now understand that there is no self, and the truth is revealed to me. Sacrifices cannot save, and invocations are but idle words. But how shall I find the path to life everlasting? I know all the Vedas by heart, and I have not found the truth.”

The Buddha said: “Learning is a good thing; but it is not enough. True wisdom can be acquired only through practice. Put into practice this truth: your brother is the same as you. Walk the noble path of righteousness, and you will understand that, while there is death in self, there is immortality in truth.”

Kūtadanta said: “Let me take refuge in the Blessed One, in the Dharma, and in the community. Accept me as your disciple and let me taste the bliss of immortality.”

Source Paul Carus, The Gospel of Buddha (1894), Project Gutenberg #35895 — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents