Catholicism

Introduction to the Devout Life, chapter xx (44)

Of frequent communion.

It is said of Mithridates, King of Pontus, that having invented a certain potion called after his name Mithridate, he became so strong through the use he made of it that, wishing later to poison himself to escape servitude to the Romans, he could never succeed. In the same way the Saviour instituted the most august sacrament of the Eucharist, which really contains His flesh and His blood, so that whoever eats it may live eternally.

If the most tender fruits and those most subject to decay, such as cherries, apricots and strawberries, are easily kept all year round when preserved in sugar or honey, what wonder is it that our hearts, weak and feeble as they are, should escape the corruption of sin when they are steeped in the virtue and incorruptibility of the flesh and blood of the Son of God? O Philothea! the Christians who are damned will have nothing to answer when the just Judge shows them how wrong they were to let themselves die spiritually, since it was so easy for them to maintain their health and their life by feeding on His body, which He left them for that purpose. Wretches! He will say to them, why are you dead, you who had at your disposal the fruit and the source of life?

If the most tender fruits and those most subject to decay, such as cherries, apricots and strawberries, are easily kept all year round when preserved in sugar or honey, what wonder is it that our hearts, weak and feeble as they are, should escape the corruption of sin when they are steeped in the virtue and incorruptibility of the flesh and blood of the Son of God? O Philothea! the Christians who are damned will have nothing to answer when the just Judge shows them how wrong they were to let themselves die spiritually, since it was so easy for them to maintain their health and their life by feeding on His body, which He left them for that purpose.

To receive communion every day is something I neither praise nor blame. But to communicate every Sunday is something I approve, and which I counsel to everyone, provided the mind is free of all affection for sin. Such are the very words of Saint Augustine, and with him I neither blame nor absolutely approve daily communion: but on this point I refer each of the faithful to a director: for the dispositions required for so frequent a communion must be so perfect that it is not good to counsel it in a general way; and because those dispositions, exquisite though they are, may be found in many good souls, neither is it good to turn everyone away from it in general.

It is a matter to be dealt with according to the interior state of each one in particular. It would be imprudent to counsel so frequent a use of the Eucharist to all indiscriminately; but it would also be imprudent to blame it in those who practise it, especially if in this they follow the advice of some worthy director. Saint Catherine of Siena gave a very fitting answer on this subject: when it was objected to her, in order to turn her away from these frequent communions, that Saint Augustine neither blamed nor praised the practice of communicating every day: Well! she said, since Saint Augustine does not blame it, I pray you not to blame it either, and with that I shall be content.

But, Philothea, you see that Saint Augustine exhorts and strongly counsels that we communicate every Sunday; do so, then, as far as you possibly can. If, as I suppose, you have no kind of affection for mortal sin, nor any affection for venial sin, you are in the true disposition that Saint Augustine requires, and even in a still more excellent disposition, since not only have you no will to sin, but you have not even affection for sin; so that, if your spiritual father thought it good, you could profitably communicate even more often than every Sunday.

There might nevertheless be several legitimate hindrances, if not on your side, at least on the part of the persons with whom you live, which would give your director occasion to reduce the number of your communions. For example, if you are dependent on others, and those to whom you owe obedience or respect are so poorly instructed in their religion, or of so odd a temper, that they grow anxious and troubled at seeing you communicate so often, then, all things well considered, it will perhaps be good to yield somewhat to their infirmity, and to communicate only every fortnight; but this is to be understood in the case where their resistance absolutely cannot be overcome.

For the rest, it would be difficult to settle this in a general way. One must do what the spiritual father says, although I can affirm that the greatest interval between communions is from month to month for those who wish to serve God devoutly.

If you are truly prudent, there will be neither father, nor mother, nor husband, nor wife to prevent you from communicating often. For, since on the day of your communion you will not fail to give the care that befits your condition; since you will be all the gentler and more gracious towards those around you; since you will refuse them no kind of duty; it is not likely that they will wish to turn you away from a practice that causes them no harm, unless they are of an altogether vexatious and unreasonable spirit; in which case, as I have said, your director will be willing for you to show condescension.

As regards married people, it suffices to tell them that under the old law it was displeasing to God for creditors to demand, on feast days, payment of what was owed them, but it was in no way wrong for the debtor to pay his debts on those days if payment was demanded; likewise in the married state, to demand the marriage debt on the day of communion is to fail in a holy propriety, though it is not a grave sin; but to render this duty on those days if it is demanded is to conform to religion.

It is true, then, that this subjection of marriage should deprive of communion none of those who are moved by the desire to partake of it. Indeed, in the primitive Church, Christians did not fail to communicate every day, though they were married and had a great many children. That is why I have said that frequent communion causes no kind of inconvenience either to fathers, or to wives, or to husbands, provided the soul that communicates is prudent and discreet.

As for bodily illnesses, there is none that is a legitimate hindrance to this holy participation, except that which would frequently provoke vomiting.

Thus, to communicate every week, it is necessary to have neither mortal sin nor any affection for venial sin, and moreover one must have a great desire for communion. But to communicate every day, one must in addition have overcome most evil inclinations, and do so with the advice of the spiritual father.

Source François de Sales, Introduction à la vie dévote (1609), Project Gutenberg #53540 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents