Catholicism

Introduction to the Devout Life, chapter v (50)

Of more inward humility.

But you desire, Philothea, that I lead you further into humility; for in doing as I have said, there is almost more wisdom than humility. I will therefore satisfy you. Many dare not think of the particular graces that God has given them, for fear of taking vainglory from them; in which, certainly, they are greatly mistaken; for since, as the Angelic Doctor teaches, the true means of attaining to the love of God is to consider the benefits we have received from Him, the better we know these benefits, the more we shall love Him from whom we have them; and as particular graces touch us more powerfully than common graces, so too they must be considered more attentively.

Alas! are mules not always heavy and foul beasts, even though they are laden with the prince's precious and perfumed furnishings? _What good do we have that we have not received?_ says the Apostle; _and if we have received it, why glory in it, as if we had not received it?_ On the contrary, the lively consideration of the graces we have received must help us to become humble; for knowledge produces gratitude. But if, seeing the graces God has given us, some foolish vanity should come to tickle our heart, the infallible remedy would be to turn to the consideration of our ingratitude, our imperfections and our miseries: by considering what we have done when God was not with us, we shall know that what we do when He is with us is not of our own making nor of our own growing. We shall enjoy it nonetheless, and we shall rejoice in it, but we shall glorify God alone for it, because He is its author.

Alas! are mules not always heavy and foul beasts, even though they are laden with the prince's precious and perfumed furnishings? _What good do we have that we have not received?_ says the Apostle; _and if we have received it, why glory in it, as if we had not received it?_ On the contrary, the lively consideration of the graces we have received must help us to become humble; for knowledge produces gratitude. But if, seeing the graces God has given us, some foolish vanity should come to tickle our heart, the infallible remedy would be to turn to the consideration of our ingratitude, our imperfections and our miseries: by considering what we have done when God was not with us, we shall know that what we do when He is with us is not of our own making nor of our own growing.

Thus the holy Virgin confesses that God has done great things in her; but it is only to humble herself for it and to glorify God: My soul, she says, _glorifies the Lord, because He has done great things in me_.

We often say that we are nothing, that we are misery itself and the refuse of the world; but we would be very vexed if anyone took us at our word and spoke of us in that way. On the contrary, we pretend to flee and hide, so that people will run after us and seek us out: we make a show of taking the last place in order to arrive with more honor at the first. True humility does not pretend to be humility, and hardly ever speaks words of humility; for it desires not only to hide the other virtues, but also and above all it wishes to hide itself; and if it were permitted to lie, to feign or to scandalize one's neighbor, it would perform acts of arrogance and pride, so as to hide itself beneath them and live there entirely unknown and secret.

Here then is my advice, Philothea: either let us speak no words of humility at all, or let us speak them with a true inward feeling, in keeping with what we utter outwardly; let us never lower our eyes without humbling our hearts as well; let us not pretend to want to be the last, unless we heartily wish to be so. And I hold this rule to be so general that I admit no exception to it; I only add that courtesy sometimes requires us to offer precedence to those who clearly will not take it; which is neither duplicity nor false humility; for then the mere offer of precedence is a beginning of honor; and since we cannot give them the whole of it, we do no wrong in giving them its beginning.

I say the same of certain expressions of honor or respect which, strictly speaking, do not seem true, and which are nevertheless true enough, provided that the heart of the one who utters them truly intends to honor and respect the person to whom he says them; for although the words exaggerate the thoughts a little, we do no wrong in using them when common usage requires it; and still I would wish our words to be fitted to our feelings as closely as we possibly can, so as to follow simplicity and candor in all things and everywhere.

The truly humble man would rather that another said of him that he is wretched, that he is nothing, that he is worth nothing, than say it himself: or at least, if he knows that it is being said, he does not contradict it, but heartily agrees with the opinion of others; for, firmly believing it to be true, he is glad that people follow his opinion.

Many say that they leave mental prayer to the perfect, and that as for themselves they are not worthy to practice it; others protest that they dare not receive Communion often, because they do not feel pure enough; some claim they are afraid of bringing shame upon devotion by taking part in it, because of their great misery and frailty; others refuse to use their talent in the service of God and their neighbor because, they say, knowing their misery well, they are afraid of growing proud if they are the instrument of some good, and fear consuming themselves in trying to enlighten others.

All this is nothing but artifice and a kind of humility that is not only false but malicious, by which one tacitly and subtly seeks to find fault with the things of God, or at least to cover with the cloak of humility the love of one's own opinion, of one's moods and of one's laziness.

Now, God's desire is that we be perfect, uniting ourselves to Him and imitating Him as best we can. The proud man who trusts in himself is quite right not to dare to undertake anything; but the humble man is all the more courageous as he knows himself to be weaker; and the more he discovers his own nothingness, the bolder he becomes, because he places all his confidence in God, who delights in displaying His power in our weakness, and in raising the works of His mercy upon the foundation of our misery. We must therefore undertake, humbly and holily, everything that the directors of our souls judge suitable for our spiritual progress.

Now, God's desire is that we be perfect, uniting ourselves to Him and imitating Him as best we can. The proud man who trusts in himself is quite right not to dare to undertake anything; but the humble man is all the more courageous as he knows himself to be weaker; and the more he discovers his own nothingness, the bolder he becomes, because he places all his confidence in God, who delights in displaying His power in our weakness, and in raising the works of His mercy upon the foundation of our misery.

To think we know what we do not know is extreme foolishness; to wish to play the learned man about what we are ignorant of is an unbearable vanity: for my part, I would not even wish to play the learned man about what I did know, just as I would not wish to play the ignorant one either. When charity requires it, we must frankly and kindly share with our neighbor not only what is necessary for his instruction, but also what is useful for his consolation; for humility, which hides and covers the virtues in order to preserve them, nevertheless makes them appear, when charity commands it, in order to increase them, embellish them and perfect them.

In this, humility resembles that tree of the islands of Tylos which at night draws in and keeps closed its beautiful crimson flowers, and opens them only in the morning to the rising sun, so that the inhabitants of the country say that these flowers sleep at night. In the same way, humility covers and hides all that is virtue and human perfection; and never lets it appear except for the sake of charity, which, being not a human but a heavenly virtue, not moral but divine, is truly the sun of the virtues, over which it must always reign: and if it happens that humility harms charity, it is an unmistakable proof that this humility is false and bad.

Nor would I wish either to play the fool or to play the wise man; for if humility keeps me from playing the wise man, simplicity and frankness will likewise keep me from playing the fool; and if vanity is contrary to humility, artifice, affectation and cunning are contrary to frankness and simplicity. And if some great servants of God have pretended to be fools, we must admire them, but not imitate them; for they had such particular and extraordinary motives for it that no one should draw any conclusion from it for himself: and as for David, who danced and leaped before the ark a little more than custom and propriety required, it was not that he wished to play the fool; it was quite simply to give vent, through these outward movements, to the extreme and inconceivable gladness he felt in his heart.

It is true that when Michal his wife reproached him for it as a folly, he was not grieved to see himself abased, but, on the contrary, continuing the artless demonstrations of his joy, he showed that he was very glad to receive a little shame for his God. On which I will tell you that if, for acts of true and sincere devotion, you are accused of baseness, foolishness or folly, humility should make you find sweet this blessed humiliation, the cause of which will lie not in you, but in those who inflict it upon you.

Source François de Sales, Introduction à la vie dévote (1609), Project Gutenberg #53540 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents