On the honorableness of the marriage bed.
The apostle calls the marriage bed undefiled, that is to say, free from every kind of impurity; and it is perhaps for this reason that God willed to institute the first marriage in the earthly paradise, where there had as yet been no disorder of concupiscence.
Now, to explain to you the perfection that the Apostle requires of married persons on this point, I shall use a rather natural comparison: that of food and temperance. 1. Food is necessary for the preservation of life; and for that reason its use is good, wholesome and commanded. 2. However, to eat not precisely for that end, but to fulfill the duties that human society obliges us to toward one another, is a just and honorable thing.
3. If one eats by reason of one's duties, it must be with a sweet freedom, and showing that one takes pleasure in it. 4. To eat simply to satisfy one's appetite is a tolerable thing, but in no way praiseworthy; for the mere pleasure of the sensual appetite cannot make an action honorable; and it is quite enough if it is tolerable. 5. To eat beyond one's appetite and to excess is more or less blameworthy in proportion to the excess; and this excess consists not only in the quantity but also in the manner.
6. It is the mark of a low, coarse and wholly animal soul to dwell so much on food and pour out so many words about it before the meal, and still more after, like many sorts of people whose minds are always in the dishes, who are forever anticipating or recalling the pleasure of good cheer, and who, in a word, as Saint Paul says, make a god of their belly; whereas honorable people think of the table only when sitting down to it, and wash their hands and mouth after the meal so as to keep neither the taste nor the smell of the food.
These are the rules that are common to temperance and to the honorableness of the conjugal bed.
1. The use of the rights of the sacrament, being necessary to the propagation of human society, is undoubtedly honorable and praiseworthy, and especially holy in Christianity.
2. This use is called by the Apostle a mutual duty, a duty so great that, although one may refrain from claiming it, one is absolutely obliged to render it; so that neither may fail in it without the free consent of the other: not even for the exercises of devotion, much less for capricious pretensions to virtue, for bitterness or for contempt.
3. One must consider that it is not enough to fulfill this duty in a sullen way and with an indifferent patience: it must be with all the faithfulness and full responsiveness that this love demands, as if it were accompanied by the hope of having children, even though for reason of some circumstance one did not have it.
4. Here, as everywhere else, the mere satisfaction of the sensual appetite cannot make a thing honorable and praiseworthy in itself; it is a great deal if it can be called tolerable.
5. However just the use of the rights of marriage may be, however necessary one knows it to be in human society, however holy one believes it to be in Christianity, it carries dangers to salvation which must be very carefully avoided in it, so as to make oneself guilty neither of any venial sin, as happens in the simple excesses of this state, nor of any mortal sin, as happens when the natural and necessary order for the procreation of children is perverted.
Now in this case, according as one departs more or less from this order, the sins are more or less execrable, but always mortal: for the propagation of human society being the first and principal end of marriage, one can never lawfully depart from the order which it requires of you. Yet although this end cannot have its effect by reason of some impediment, such as barrenness or pregnancy, the commerce of conjugal love may nonetheless be just and holy, if one follows the rules that the procreation of children requires: no accident can ever prejudice the law that the principal end of marriage has imposed.
Certainly the infamous and execrable act of Onan against the laws of marriage was detestable before God, as Holy Scripture teaches us. And although some heretics of our time, a hundred times more blameworthy than the Cynics of whom Saint Jerome speaks in his commentary on the Epistle to the Ephesians, have chosen to say that it was the perverse intention of that wicked man that displeased God, Scripture speaks otherwise and affirms in particular that his act itself was detestable and abominable before God.
6. Natural and Christian honorableness requires that one not let one's mind become entangled in all this sensual commerce, and that one even try to purify it of it promptly, so that it may keep all the freedom needed for the more honorable and nobler obligations of this vocation. In truth, one would be surprised at the examples of natural honorableness that the Lord has given to men in certain animals, which will one day serve to confound the brutish coarseness of many people.
This counsel includes the perfect practice of the excellent doctrine that Saint Paul teaches the Corinthians in these terms: _the time is short: let those, then, who have wives live as though they had none._ For, according to the thought of Saint Gregory, to live in marriage as though one were not in it is to reconcile all that is natural in this state with all that is spiritual in Christianity. _Let those who use the world_, adds Saint Paul, _use it as though they used it not._ That is to tell everyone to use the world, each according to his vocation, but with so great a detachment from the world that one may keep for the service of God as much freedom and fervor as if one did not use the world.
Indeed, it is man's great evil, says Saint Augustine, to wish to enjoy the things he ought only to use, and to wish only to use those he ought to enjoy with delight: this applies to everything that relates to the senses and to the mind. Thus when this order is perverted, and use is turned into enjoyment, the soul, spiritual as it is, becomes wholly animal.
I believe I have said all that I wished to say, and have made understood, without saying it, what I did not wish to say.