← Back to the lesson (Lesson 113)

Catholicism

Introduction to the Devout Life, chapter xiii (99)

On spiritual and sensible consolations, and how we must make use of them.

God makes this great world pass through a series of perpetual changes, and we see in turn day changing into night, spring into summer, summer into autumn, autumn into winter, and winter into spring; one day is never perfectly like another: there are cloudy ones, rainy ones, dry ones and stormy ones, a variety that gives great beauty to this universe. It is the same with man, who is, according to the saying of the ancients, an epitome of the world; for he is never in the same state, and his life flows by on this earth like the waters of a river, carried along ceaselessly in a host of different movements, which now raise him up by hope, now cast him down by fear, now bend him to the right by consolation, now to the left by affliction; and never is a single one of his days, nor even a single one of his hours, entirely like another.

Now, in the midst of so great an unevenness of events and accidents, it is extremely important for us to preserve an unalterable evenness of heart; and although all things turn and combine variously around us, we must always have our gaze directed towards Heaven, and be unwavering in our resolution to tend ceaselessly towards God so as to reach Him. Let the ship take whatever course one pleases, let it sail east or west, north or south, whatever wind carries it, never will its mariner's needle look at anything but the beautiful pole star.

Likewise, let everything be turned upside down, I do not say only around us, but within us; that is to say, let our soul be sad, joyful, in sweetness, in bitterness, in peace, in trouble, in light, in darkness, in temptations, in rest, in relish, in distaste, in dryness, or in sweetness: let the sun burn it, or the dew refresh it, ah! always the point of our heart, of our mind, of our superior will, which is our compass, must look unwaveringly and tend perpetually towards the love of God its Creator, its Saviour, its only and sovereign good. _Whether we live or whether we die_, says the Apostle, _we are God's; and who shall separate us from the charity of Jesus Christ?_ No, nothing shall ever separate us from this love, neither tribulation, nor anguish, nor death, nor life, nor present evil, nor fear of evils to come, nor the wiles of evil spirits, nor the height of consolations, nor the depth of afflictions, nor sweetness, nor dryness, nor any creature in the world must ever separate us from this holy charity which is founded in Jesus Christ.

This resolution, so absolute, never to abandon God nor His sweet love, serves as a counterweight to our souls to keep them in a holy and perfect evenness amid all the unevennesses and all the movements that the condition of this life brings them. For, just as bees caught by the wind in the open country pick up little stones so as to be able to balance themselves in the air and not be so easily tossed by the storm, so our soul, having fervently embraced the resolution always to love its God, remains constant amid the inconstancy and variety of consolations and afflictions, whether spiritual or temporal, exterior or interior.

But besides these general rules, we need some particular instructions.

1. I say, then, that devotion does not consist in all these sensible sweetnesses, delights and consolations which move us to tears and sighs, and give us a certain agreeable satisfaction in some exercises of piety. No, Philothea, devotion and that are not one and the same thing; for there are many souls who have these consolations and who are nevertheless vicious, from which it follows that they have no true love of God, and still less any true devotion.

Saul, pursuing poor David to the death in the desert of Engaddi, went all alone into a cave where David was hidden with his men. David, who on this occasion could have killed him a thousand times, spared his life, and would not even frighten him; but, having let him go out at his ease, he called to him to show him his innocence, and to let him know that he had had him in his power. What did Saul not do then to show David that his heart was softened? he called him his child, he began to weep aloud, to praise him, to bless his generosity, to pray to God for him, to foretell his future greatness, and to commend to him the care of his own family.

What greater sweetness and tenderness could he show? nevertheless, in the midst of all this, his heart was not changed, and he continued to persecute David as cruelly as before. So there are people who, at the sight of God's goodness and the Saviour's passion, feel great tenderness of heart which makes them heave sighs and shed tears, accompanied by prayers and thanksgivings so heartfelt that one would think them seized by a very great devotion; but when it comes to the test, one finds that, just as the passing rains of a very hot summer fall in large drops on the earth without penetrating it, and serve only to produce mushrooms, so these tears of tenderness, falling on a vicious heart, do not penetrate it and are utterly useless to it; for with all this these poor people would not give up a single farthing of the ill-gotten goods they possess, they would not renounce a single one of their evil inclinations, and would not take the least trouble in the world for the service of this Saviour over whom they have wept so much; so that the good movements they have had are only spiritual mushrooms, which not only are not true devotion, but very often are even great wiles of the enemy, by which, amusing souls with these little consolations, he makes them content and satisfied with themselves, and thereby makes them neglect true and solid devotion, which consists in a constant, resolute, prompt and active will to carry out what one knows to be pleasing to God.

A child will weep tenderly if he sees the doctor lance his mother with a lancet; but if at the same time his mother, for whom he was weeping, asks him for an apple or a bag of sugared almonds he is holding in his hand, he will by no means let go. Such are most of our tender devotions: seeing Jesus Christ crucified given a thrust of the lance that pierces His heart, we weep tenderly. Alas! Philothea, it is well done to weep over the death and the sorrowful passion of our Father and our Redeemer; but why then do we not eagerly give Him the apple we have in our hands, and which He asks of us so insistently? namely, our heart, the only apple of love that this dear Saviour requires of us.

Why do we not sacrifice to Him so many little affections, satisfactions and indulgences that He wishes to pluck from our heart, without ever being able to succeed, because they are our favourite sweet, of which we are fonder than of the goods of His divine grace? ah! all that is the friendship of little children; tender, but weak, but fanciful, but without effect. Devotion, then, does not consist in these kinds of sensible affections, which sometimes come from a soft nature, easily receiving the impressions one wishes to give it, and sometimes also are a manoeuvre of the enemy, by which, the better to put us off the scent, he thus works up our imagination.

2. These tender and affectionate sweetnesses are nevertheless sometimes very useful; for they stir the appetite of the soul, they strengthen the spirit, and they add to the promptness of devotion a holy and lively gladness which makes our actions very beautiful and very pleasing, even outwardly. From this comes that relish for divine things which made David say: _O Lord! how sweet are Your words to my palate! they are sweeter to my heart than honey to my mouth._ And certainly it is very true that the least little consolation which devotion gives us is worth more in every way than the most excellent recreations of the world.

It is the milk of which Scripture speaks to us, which is preferable to the most exquisite wine; whoever has tasted it regards all other human consolations as gall and wormwood; and as those who hold the Scythian herb in their mouth receive from it so great a sweetness that they no longer feel either hunger or thirst, so those to whom God has given the heavenly manna of inward consolations can no longer desire or receive the consolations of the world, at least so as to take delight in them and fill their heart with them.

They are little foretastes of the immortal sweetnesses which God gives to the souls who seek Him; they are sugared morsels which He gives to His little children to draw them on; they are cordial waters which He offers them to comfort them; they are also sometimes pledges of the eternal reward that awaits them. It is said that Alexander the Great, being at sea, judged that he was not far from Arabia the Happy by the sweet fragrance with which the air was filled; which served him greatly to encourage his fleet: and thus it is that the sweetnesses of grace, amid the storms of this mortal life, give us a presentiment of the ineffable delights of the heavenly homeland to which we aspire.

The heart is good if it has good affections, and the affections are good if they produce in us good effects and holy actions. If, then, sweetnesses and consolations make us more humble, more patient, more tractable, more charitable and more indulgent toward our neighbour, more fervent in mortifying our passions, more diligent in our duties, more submissive and more yielding toward our superiors, more simple in our life, without doubt, Philothea, they are from God; but if these sweetnesses are sweet only for ourselves, if they make us curious, sour, touchy, impatient, obstinate, proud, presumptuous, harsh toward our neighbour, and if, thinking ourselves already little saints, we will no longer bear either correction or counsel, undoubtedly these are false and pernicious consolations. A good tree brings forth only good fruit.

The heart is good if it has good affections, and the affections are good if they produce in us good effects and holy actions. If, then, sweetnesses and consolations make us more humble, more patient, more tractable, more charitable and more indulgent toward our neighbour, more fervent in mortifying our passions, more diligent in our duties, more submissive and more yielding toward our superiors, more simple in our life, without doubt, Philothea, they are from God; but if these sweetnesses are sweet only for ourselves, if they make us curious, sour, touchy, impatient, obstinate, proud, presumptuous, harsh toward our neighbour, and if, thinking ourselves already little saints, we will no longer bear either correction or counsel, undoubtedly these are false and pernicious consolations.

4. When we have sweetnesses and consolations, 1.º let us humble ourselves greatly before God; let us take good care not to say because of these sweetnesses: oh! how good I am! no, Philothea, these are goods that do not make us better; for, as I have said, devotion does not consist in that; but let us say: oh! how good God is to those who hope in Him, and to the soul that seeks Him! Whoever has sugar in his mouth cannot say that his mouth is sweet, but rather that the sugar is sweet; so, although this spiritual sweetness is very good, and God who gives it is most good, it does not follow that the one who receives it is good.

2.º Let us acknowledge that we are still little children who need milk, and that these dainties are given to us only because our spirit is still tender and delicate, and because we need such lures to draw us to the love of God. 3.º But after that, speaking in general, let us receive these graces and favours very humbly, and regard them as most precious, not so much because they are so in themselves, as because it is the hand of God that works them in our heart, as a mother would do who, to please her little child, would put little sugared almonds into its mouth, one after another; for if the child had discernment, it would prize the sweetness of its mother's caresses far more than the sweetness of the sugared almond itself; and so, it is much, Philothea, to have sweetnesses; but it is the sweetness of sweetnesses to consider that it is God who with His loving and motherly hand places them in our heart, in our mind and in our soul.

4.º Having received them thus humbly, let us use them carefully according to the intention of Him who gives them to us. Why does God give us these sweetnesses? is it not to stir up our love toward Him and to make us gentler toward our neighbour? The mother gives sugared almonds to her child in order to obtain a few caresses from it; in the same way God, in return for His consolations, expects from us tokens of affection and gratitude.

Now, we have no surer means of proving both to Him than to humble ourselves before Him, to keep His commandments and to follow His desires. 5.º We must, besides this, renounce from time to time these kinds of consolations and sweetnesses, detaching our heart from them and declaring that, although we accept them humbly, and love them as things that come from God and that lead us to love Him, it is nevertheless not they that we seek, but God and His holy love; not the consolation, but the Consoler; not the sweetness, but the sweet Saviour; not the sensible relish, but Him who is the sweetness of Heaven and earth.

This disposition must be such that we are firmly resolved to remain steadfast in the holy love of God, even if in all our life we were to have no kind of consolation, holding ourselves equally ready to say on Calvary and on Tabor: O Lord, it is good for me to be with You, whether You are on the cross or You are in glory. 6.º Finally, I warn you that if you were to receive these kinds of sensible consolations in some abundance, or if you were to experience something extraordinary in them, you would need to confer sincerely about it with your director, in order to learn with what moderation and what prudence they must be used; for it is written: _Have you found honey? eat as much as is sufficient._

Source François de Sales, Introduction à la vie dévote (1609), Project Gutenberg #53540 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents