← Back to the lesson (Lesson 137)

Catholicism

Introduction to the Devout Life, chapter xiv (100)

Of spiritual dryness and barrenness.

When you have consolations, my dear Philothea, conduct yourself as I have just told you. But this fine weather, so pleasant, will not last forever. Sometimes you will be so deprived of all feeling of devotion that it will seem to you that your soul is like a desert land, fruitless, barren, where there is neither path nor road to go to God, nor any water of grace that can water it amid the droughts that consume it, and that, as it seems, reduce it entirely to waste.

Alas! how worthy of compassion is the soul in this state, above all when the trouble is violent! for then, after the example of David, it feeds on tears both day and night, while by a thousand suggestions the enemy, to drive it to despair, mocks it and says to it: Ah! poor wretch, where is your God? by what road will you be able to find Him? who will ever be able to give you back the joy of His holy grace?

What will you do, then, at that time, Philothea? Examine where the trouble comes from: we ourselves are often the cause of our barrenness and our dryness.

1. As a mother refuses sugar to her child who is subject to worms, so God takes away His consolations from us when we take some vain complacency in them, and when we are subject to the worm of presumption. _It is good for me, O my God, that You have humbled me_, said David; _for before I was humbled, I had offended You._

2. When we neglect to gather the sweetnesses and delights of the love of God at the time marked by Him, He withdraws them from us in punishment for our sloth. The Israelite who did not gather the manna early in the morning could no longer do so after the sun had risen, for it was found all melted away.

3. We sometimes rest softly amid the sensual satisfactions and the perishable consolations of this world, as did the bride in the Canticles. The Bridegroom of our souls comes knocking at the door of our heart; He inspires us to return to our spiritual exercises; but we bargain with Him, because it grieves us to leave these vain amusements and to renounce these false goods; that is why He passes on and leaves us to stagnate; then, when we want to seek Him, we have great difficulty in finding Him: which is a very just punishment, since we have been so rebellious to His love as to reject its attraction in order to follow that of the things of the world.

Ah! poor soul, you have stocked up on the flour of Egypt, you will not have the manna of Heaven. Bees hate all artificial scents; and the sweetnesses of the Holy Spirit are incompatible with the artful delights of the world.

4. The duplicity and cunning of mind that one brings to confessions and to the other spiritual communications one has with one's director draw down dryness and barrenness; for, since you lie to the Holy Spirit, it is no wonder if He refuses you His consolations; you do not want to be simple and artless like a little child, so you will not have the sugared almond of little children.

5. Our heart has glutted itself on the pleasures of the world; must we be astonished, after that, if you feel distaste for spiritual delights? Well-fed doves, says the old proverb, find cherries bitter. _God has filled with good things those who were hungry_, says the Blessed Virgin, _and He has sent away empty those who were rich._ Those, then, who are rich in the pleasures of the world are not capable of the joys of the Holy Spirit.

6. Have you carefully preserved the fruit of the consolations you received? you will have new ones; for to him who has, more will be given; but from him who does not have what was given him, and who has lost it through his own fault, even what he does not have will be taken away, that is to say, he will be deprived of the graces that were prepared for him. Rain gives life to plants that are green; but from those that are not, it takes away even the little life they seem to have, and destroys them altogether.

It is for these reasons and others like them that we lose the consolations of God, and that we fall into a thousand drynesses and barrennesses of spirit. Let us therefore examine our conscience, to see whether there are not in us some of these faults. But let us remember, Philothea, to make this examination without anxiety or curiosity. If, after faithfully considering our dispositions, we find in ourselves the cause of the trouble, we must thank God for it; for the trouble is half cured when its cause has been discovered.

If, on the contrary, you see nothing in particular that seems to you to have caused this dryness, do not waste time in a more curious search; but in all simplicity, do what I am going to tell you.

1. Humble yourself greatly before God in the knowledge of your nothingness and your misery. Say from the bottom of your heart: alas! what am I when I am left to myself? nothing, Lord, but a parched earth, cracked open on every side, which has an extreme need of rain, and which the wind reduces to dust.

2. Call upon God, and ask Him for the sweetness of His grace: _Restore to me, O Lord, the saving joy of Your Spirit. My Father, if it be possible, let this chalice pass from me._ O Saviour Jesus! stop this burning wind that dries up my heart; and you, O precious wind of consolations, come, blow upon me, and the plants of my garden will give forth a sweet and pleasant fragrance.

3. Go to your confessor, open your heart to him, let him see all the folds of your soul, take all the advice he gives you with great simplicity and humility; for God, who infinitely loves obedience, often makes useful the counsels one receives from others, and above all from those whom He has appointed to guide souls, even when there is little appearance of a happy outcome; thus it was that He made profitable to Naaman the waters of the Jordan, the use of which Elisha, without any appearance of human reason, had prescribed to him.

4. But after all this, nothing is so useful in such dryness and barrenness as not to desire too eagerly to be delivered from it. I do not say that one should not make simple wishes for deliverance, but I say that one should not cling to them too much, and that one must abandon oneself to Providence, so that it may put to our pain whatever end it pleases. Let us therefore say to God at that time: let us say, then, with those desires that we may allow ourselves and amid those thorns that we must bear: _O my Father! if it be possible, let this chalice pass from me_; but let us also add with great courage: _Nevertheless, let Your will be done, and not mine_; and let us rest in that with as much tranquillity as we can; for God, seeing us in this holy indifference, will favour us with many graces and consolations: as when He saw Abraham determined to sacrifice his son to Him, He was content with this act of resignation and rewarded him with a most pleasing vision and with the blessing He gave him and his posterity.

We must therefore, in all kinds of afflictions, bodily as well as spiritual, and amid the distractions or the privations of sensible devotion that befall us, say with all our heart and with deep submission: _the Lord gave me consolations; the Lord has taken them from me; blessed be Your holy name_; for, if we persevere in this practice of humility, He will restore to us His delightful favours, as He did to Job, who constantly used these same words in all his desolations.

5. Finally, Philothea, amid all our dryness and barrenness, let us not lose courage. But, waiting patiently for the return of consolations, let us always go on our way. Let us not on that account neglect any exercise of piety; on the contrary, let us multiply our good works, if it is possible; and, being unable to present anything better to our Bridegroom, let us offer Him our heart, dry as it is; this homage will be no less pleasing to Him, provided that we are firmly determined to love Him always.

When the spring is fine, the bees make more honey and fewer young bees; because, thanks to the fine weather, they are so taken up with gathering from the flowers that they forget the breeding of their brood; but when the spring is harsh and cloudy, they make more brood and less honey; for, being unable to go out to gather honey, they occupy themselves more with multiplying their race. It also happens many times, Philothea, that the soul, finding itself in the fair springtime of spiritual consolations, is so taken up with gathering and sucking them that, through the abundance of these sweet delights, it does far fewer good works; whereas amid spiritual harshness and barrenness, in proportion as it sees itself deprived of the pleasant feelings of devotion, it multiplies all the more its solid works, and abounds in the inward generation of the true virtues of patience, humility, contempt of self, resignation and detachment.

It is therefore a great error in many people, and especially among women, to believe that the service of God, without relish, without sweetness, without sensible attraction, is for that reason less pleasing to His divine Majesty; since, on the contrary, our actions are like roses, which when fresh have more grace, but when dry have more strength and fragrance: for, although our works done with relish are more pleasing to us, who look only to our own consolation, it remains true that, when done in dryness and distaste, they have more fragrance and value before God.

Yes, dear Philothea, in time of dryness our will carries us to the service of God as if by main force; and consequently it must be more vigorous and more constant than in the time of consolations; it is no great thing to serve a prince amid the sweetness of peace and the delights of the court; but to serve him amid the hardships of war, amid troubles and persecutions, is a true mark of fidelity and constancy. Blessed Angela of Foligno says that the prayer most pleasing to God is that which is made by force and constraint, that is to say, the prayer we make not from relish and inclination, but purely to please God, our will going to it only reluctantly, and having always to force and overcome the repugnances and the weariness it meets there.

I say the same of every kind of good work; for the more contradictions we find in them, whether outward or inward, the more they are esteemed and prized by God. The less there is of our own particular interest in the pursuit of the virtues, the more the purity of divine love shines forth in it; the child readily kisses its mother when she gives it sugar; but it is a sign that it loves her greatly if it kisses her after she has given it wormwood or bitter aloes.

Source François de Sales, Introduction à la vie dévote (1609), Project Gutenberg #53540 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents