He moves away from Manichaeism, though he still keeps more than one of its errors.
So You restored me from that sickness, and You saved the son of Your Handmaid in that body of a day, so as to give him back a health more precious and more sure. And at Rome I still kept up ties with those deceived and deceiving Saints, and not only with the hearers, among whom was the host of my sickness and my convalescence, but also with the Elect.
I still believed that it is not we who sin, but some alien nature or other that sins in us; and it pleased my pride to be outside of sin, and, when I did evil, not to confess myself guilty before You so as to obtain from Your mercy the healing of my soul; and I loved to excuse it by accusing some other being that was in me without being me. And yet the whole was I, and my impiety alone had divided me against myself, and the sin was in me, all the more incurable as I did not believe myself a sinner; and my execrable iniquity preferred, O almighty God, Your defeat in me, to my ruin, to Your victory over me, for my salvation.
“You had not yet set the sentinel at the entrance of my mouth, and the door of circumspection about my lips, so that my heart might not slip into words of malice to excuse its crimes, after the example of the Workers of iniquity.” That is why I still lived with their Elect, and yet, without any hope henceforth of gaining anything from that doctrine, and waiting for something better, I still held to it, but with more lukewarmness and indifference.
It even came into my mind that the philosophers called Academics had been wiser than the others in holding that we must doubt everything, and that man is capable of no truth. I thought, according to the common opinion, that such was their doctrine, whose true meaning I did not then penetrate.
Ps. CXL, 3, 4.
So I had no scruple about shaking my host’s excessive confidence in the fables that fill the Manichaean books. Yet I did not cease to keep up more familiar relations with these heretics than with others, and although I was less ardent in defending their opinions, my intimacy with them (for Rome harbors a great number of them) slackened the ardor of my search, above all since I despaired, O God of heaven and earth, Creator of the visible and the invisible, of finding in Your Church the truth from which they had turned me away.
It seemed to me so shameful to suppose that You had our fleshly shape, and our limbs with the limits of their outlines! And since, when I wished to picture my God, my thought always clung to a bodily mass (nothing, in my eyes, could exist without being so), there lay the chief, or rather the sole and invincible cause of my errors. And from this came that senseless belief that Evil had a bodily substance, an earthy mass, a heavy deformity, which they called earth, and another, subtle and thin, like the body of the air, a spirit of malice that had seeped, according to them, into this elemental world.
And as some remnant of piety forbade me to believe that a good God had created any evil nature, I set up two contrary and opposing natures, both of them infinite, but that of good more infinite than that of evil.
And from this principle of corruption flowed all my blasphemies. Whenever my mind strove to have recourse to the Catholic faith, I was driven back, for the Catholic faith was not what I supposed it to be, and I found myself more religious, O God! to whom Your mercies toward me bear witness, in believing You infinite on all sides, save at the point where the evil principle in conflict with You forced me to acknowledge a limit in You, than in holding You to be bounded by the forms of the human body.
And it was better, to my mind, to believe that You did not create evil (evil, which my ignorance made not only a substance, but a bodily substance, being unable to picture spirit otherwise than as a subtle body spread out in space), than to take You for the author of what seemed to me the nature of evil. Our Saviour Himself, Your only Son, I regarded as an extension emanating from Your luminous expanse for our salvation, so that I believed of Him nothing but the nothingness I imagined.
And so, ascribing this substance to Him, I was convinced that it could not be born of the Virgin Mary without mingling with the flesh; and I could not admit that such a being of my fancy could be so mingled without defilement. I feared, then, that in believing Him born in the flesh, I would be led to believe Him defiled by the flesh. May Your spiritual sons laugh at me gently and lovingly, if they come to read these confessions; but in the end, such was I then.