He breaks with the Manichaeans and remains a catechumen in the Church.
Indifferent to the truth, I paid attention only to the art of his discourses. And in me this vain concern had outlived the hope that the way that leads to You might be open to man. Yet the words I loved brought to my mind the very things I cared nothing for. They were inseparable, and my heart could not open itself to eloquence without the truth entering along with it, though by degrees. I saw first that everything he put forward could be defended, and that the Catholic faith could be affirmed without rashness against the attacks of the Manichaeans, which until then I had believed irresistible.
I was above all shaken on hearing him resolve, according to the spirit, several obscure passages of the Old Testament, whose literal interpretation had been death to me.
Enlightened by the exposition of the spiritual sense, I already condemned that discouragement which had made me believe all resistance impossible against the enemies and mockers of the law and the prophets. Yet I did not think myself bound to enter the Catholic way, because it too might have learned and eloquent defenders, nor to condemn the side I had embraced, because the defense offered it equal weapons. Thus the Catholic faith, while it ceased to appear vanquished to me, did not yet rise victorious before me.
I bent every power of my mind to the discovery of some decisive argument by which to convict the Manichaean opinions of falsehood. If my mind had been able to picture a spiritual substance, it would have shattered all those toys of error and swept them from my imagination; but I could not. Nevertheless, as regards this outer world, the domain of our senses, I found much more probability in the views of most of the philosophers; and serious reflection and repeated comparison supported this judgment.
Thus doubting everything, according to the supposed maxims of the Academy, and wavering amid every uncertainty, I resolved to leave the Manichaeans, not thinking that in this crisis of irresolution I ought to remain attached to a sect which in my esteem already gave way to this or that philosophical school. But to those philosophers, empty of the redeeming name of Jesus, I refused to entrust the cure of my soul’s languors. I decided, then, to remain a catechumen in the Catholic Church, the Church of my father and my mother, until some beacon of certainty should appear to guide my course.