Catholicism

Confessions, Book Seven, chapter XIX

He took Jesus Christ for a man of eminent wisdom.

But I thought otherwise, and my sentiments about our Lord Jesus Christ were those one may have of a man eminent in wisdom, an incomparable man; His miraculous birth from a virgin, His wholly divine devotion to us, had, in my view, invested His teaching with that sovereign authority which inspired, after His example, contempt for temporal goods for the sake of gaining immortality.

But all the holy mystery there was in the Word made flesh, this I could not even suspect. Only, the written tradition, teaching me that He ate, drank, slept, walked, that He knew joy and sorrow, that He conversed with us, made me understand that this flesh could have been united to Your Word only through the medium of a human soul and mind. Who does not know this, among those who know the unchangeableness of Your Word?

And I had even then enough knowledge of it to be beyond doubt certain that to move the limbs of the body at will, and then no longer move them; to be affected by some passion, then become indifferent; to express wise thoughts by signs, then remain in silence, are the distinctive marks of the changeableness of soul and mind. Now if these testimonies about Him were false, all the rest would be suspected of falsehood, and Scripture would offer to the faith of mankind no hope of salvation.

Now, what is written being true, I recognized the whole man in Jesus Christ, and not the body of a man alone, or body and soul without mind; I recognized man himself. But this was not truth in person; it was, in my view, a sublime exaltation of human nature, admitted in Him to a privileged share in wisdom, which assured Him pre-eminence over other men.

Alypius thought that, in their belief in a God clothed in flesh, the Catholics found in Jesus Christ only the God and the flesh, and he did not believe that they affirmed in Him the mind and soul of a man. And as he was firmly persuaded that everything tradition preserves of Him in human memory could not have been accomplished in the absence of the vital and rational principle, he came only with slow steps to the Catholic faith. But soon, discovering in this error the heresy of the Apollinarians, he joyfully embraced the faith of the Church.

As for me, I confess that I learned only some time afterward what disagreement about the mystery of the incarnate Word arises between Catholic truth and the falsehood of Photinus. The contradictions of heresy bring out the convictions of Your Church, and bring the holy doctrine to light. “There had to be heresies, so that hearts that stand the test might be made manifest among the weak.”

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents