Catholicism

Confessions, Book Twelve, chapter VI

How it must be conceived.

If, Lord, my voice and my pen must proclaim to Your glory all that You have taught me about this primordial matter, I confess that formerly, hearing its name on the lips of people who spoke to me of it, without being able to give me an understanding of it that they did not have themselves, my thought represented it to itself under an infinity of different forms; or rather it was not it that my thought represented to itself, it was a jumble of horrible, hideous forms, but a jumble of forms that I called formless, not because it was devoid of forms, but because it took on unheard-of, strange ones, such that a similar reality offered to my eyes would have filled my weak nature with trouble and horror.

This being of my imagination was therefore formless not through absence of forms, but in relation to more beautiful forms. And yet reason showed me that, to conceive of a being absolutely formless, I had to strip it of the last remnants of form, and I could not; I found it quicker to hold as nothing the object to which form was refused, than to conceive a middle between form and nothing, between nothingness and formed reality, a formlessness, an almost nothing.

And my reason ceased to consult my mind, full of formal images, which it varies and combines at will. I fixed a more attentive gaze on bodies themselves, and I meditated more deeply on that mutability which makes them cease to be what they were, and become what they were not; then I suspected that this passage from one form to another took place through some formless thing that was not absolutely nothing. But suspicion did not satisfy me; I desired certain knowledge.

And now, if my voice and my pen confessed to You all the light with which You have illumined these obscurities for me, what reader could lend a lasting enough attention? And yet my heart will not cease to glorify You and to sing You a canticle of thanksgiving; for words fail me to express what You have revealed to me. It is true, then, that the mutability of things is the possibility of all the forms they undergo. And it, what then is it? a spirit? a body? a spirit, a body of a certain nature?

If one could say a certain nothingness that is and is not, I would define it thus. And yet it had to have some sort of being in order to take on these visible and harmonious forms.

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents