Catholicism

Confessions, Book Twelve, chapter XXII

Several creations of God passed over in silence.

In vain would one try to refute these last two opinions by saying: If you will not admit that this material formlessness is designated by the name of heaven and earth, then something existed, independent of the creative act, which God used to make heaven and earth? For Scripture does not say that God created this matter, unless it is expressed by the name of heaven and earth, or of earth alone, when it says: “In the beginning God made heaven and earth: now the earth was invisible and formless”; and even if the Holy Spirit had meant, by these last words, formless matter, we could still understand only that divine creation attested by this verse: “God made heaven and earth.”

But, the holders of these two opinions will answer, we do not deny that this matter is the work of God, the principle of all good: for if we say that what has already received being and form is good in a higher degree than what has only the capacity for them, we nonetheless admit that this latter state is a good. As for the silence of Scripture on the creation of this material formlessness, the same objection could be made regarding the cherubim and seraphim, and so many other heavenly spirits, distinguished by the Apostle into Thrones, Dominations, Principalities, Powers, about which Scripture is silent, though they are evidently the work of God.

If one wishes everything to be included in these words: “He made heaven and earth,” what then shall we say of the waters over which the Spirit of God was borne? If they must be implicitly understood under the name of earth, how can this name express a formless matter, if it also designates these waters that our eyes see so transparent and so beautiful? And, if it is taken so, why does Scripture say that from this formless matter the firmament, called heaven, was formed, without mentioning the waters?

Are they, then, still invisible and formless, these waters whose limpid crystal we admire? Were they clothed in their adornment when God said: “Let the waters below the firmament be gathered together”? And is this gathering their creation? But what will be said of the waters above the firmament? Had they been formless, would they have received so honorable a place? And nowhere does Scripture say what word formed them.

Gen., I, 9.

Thus Genesis is silent about the creation of certain beings; and neither the uprightness of faith nor the certainty of reason allows us to doubt that God created them. Who but a fool would dare conclude that they are coeternal with Him, because Genesis affirms their existence without speaking of their creation? Why then should we refuse to conceive, in the light of Truth, that this invisible and unordered earth, this abyss of darkness, is the work of God, drawn from nothing; not coeternal with Him, though the divine account omits the moment of its creation?

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents