Hinduism

Jnana-Yoga — The Atman

(Delivered in America)

Many of you have read Max Müller's celebrated book, Three Lectures on the Vedanta Philosophy,

and some of you may, perhaps, have read, in German,

Professor Deussen's book on the same philosophy. In what is being written

and taught in the West about the religious thought of India, one school of

Indian thought is principally represented, that which is called Advaitism,

the monistic side of Indian religion; and sometimes it is thought that all

the teachings of the Vedas are comprised in that one system of philosophy.

There are, however, various phases of Indian thought; and, perhaps, this

non-dualistic form is in the minority as compared with the other phases.

From the most ancient times there have been various sects of thought in

India, and as there never was a formulated or recognised church or any body

of men to designate the doctrines which should be believed by each school,

people were very free to choose their own form, make their own philosophy

and establish their own sects. We, therefore, find that from the most

ancient times India was full of religious sects. At the present time, I do

not know how many hundreds of sects we have in India, and several fresh ones

are coming into existence every year. It seems that the religious activity

of that nation is simply inexhaustible.

Of these various sects, in the first place, there can be made two main

divisions, the orthodox and the unorthodox. Those that believe in the Hindu

scriptures, the Vedas, as eternal revelations of truth, are called orthodox,

and those that stand on other authorities, rejecting the Vedas, are the

heterodox in India. The chief modern unorthodox Hindu sects are the Jains

and the Buddhists. Among the orthodox some declare that the scriptures are

of much higher authority than reason; others again say that only that

portion of the scriptures which is rational should be taken and the rest

rejected.

Of the three orthodox divisions, the Sânkhyas, the Naiyâyikas, and the

Mimâmsakas, the former two, although they existed as philosophical schools,

failed to form any sect. The one sect that now really covers India is that

of the later Mimamsakas or the Vedantists. Their philosophy is called

Vedantism. All the schools of Hindu philosophy start from the Vedanta or

Upanishads, but the monists took the name to themselves as a speciality,

because they wanted to base the whole of their theology and philosophy upon

the Vedanta and nothing else. In the course of time the Vedanta prevailed,

and all the various sects of India that now exist can be referred to one or

other of its schools. Yet these schools are not unanimous in their opinions.

We find that there are three principal variations among the Vedantists. On

one point they all agree, and that is that they all believe in God. All

these Vedantists also believe the Vedas to be the revealed word of God, not

exactly in the same sense, perhaps, as the Christians or the Mohammedans

believe, but in a very peculiar sense. Their idea is that the Vedas are an

expression of the knowledge of God, and as God is eternal, His knowledge is

eternally with Him, and so are the Vedas eternal. There is another common

ground of belief: that of creation in cycles, that the whole of creation

appears and disappears; that it is projected and becomes grosser and

grosser, and at the end of an incalculable period of time it becomes finer

and finer, when it dissolves and subsides, and then comes a period of rest.

Again it: begins to appear and goes through the same process. They postulate

the existence of a material which they call Âkâsha, which is something like

the ether of the scientists, and a power which they call Prâna. About; this

Prana they declare that by its vibration the universe is produced. When a

cycle ends, all this manifestation of nature becomes finer and finer and

dissolves into that Akasha which cannot be seen or felt, yet out of which

everything is manufactured. All the forces that we see in nature, such as

gravitation, attraction, and repulsion, or as thought, feeling, and nervous

motion — all these various forces resolve into that Prana, and the vibration

of the Prana ceases. In that state it remains until the beginning of the

next cycle. Prana then begins to vibrate, and that vibration acts upon the

Akasha, and all these forms are thrown out in regular succession.

The first school I will tell you about is styled the dualistic school. The

dualists believe that God, who is the creator of the universe and its ruler,

is eternally separate from nature, eternally separate from the human soul.

God is eternal; nature is eternal; so are all souls. Nature and the souls

become manifested and change, but God remains the same. According to the

dualists, again, this God is personal in that He has qualities, not that He

has a body. He has human attributes; He is merciful, He is just, He is

powerful, He is almighty, He can be approached, He can be prayed to, He can

be loved, He loves in return, and so forth. In one word, He is a human God,

only infinitely greater than man; He has none of the evil qualities which

men have. "He is the repository of an infinite number of blessed qualities"

— that is their definition. He cannot create without materials, and nature

is the material out of which He creates the whole universe. There are some

non-Vedantic dualists, called "Atomists", who believe that nature is nothing

but an infinite number of atoms, and God's will, acting upon these atoms,

creates. The Vedantists deny the atomic theory; they say it is perfectly

illogical. The indivisible atoms are like geometrical points without parts

or magnitude; but something without parts or magnitude, if multiplied an

infinite number of times, will remain the same. Anything that has no parts

will never make something that has parts; any number of zeros added together

will not make one single whole number. So, if these atoms are such that they

have no parts or magnitude, the creation of the universe is simply

impossible out of such atoms. Therefore, according to the Vedantic dualists,

there is what they call indiscrete or undifferentiated nature, and out of

that God creates the universe. The vast mass of Indian people are dualists.

Human nature ordinarily cannot conceive of anything higher. We find that

ninety per cent of the population of the earth who believe in any religion

are dualists. All the religions of Europe and Western Asia are dualistic;

they have to be. The ordinary man cannot think of anything which is not

concrete. He naturally likes to cling to that which his intellect can grasp.

That is to say, he can only conceive of higher spiritual ideas by bringing

them down to his own level. He can only grasp abstract thoughts by making

them concrete. This is the religion of the masses all over the world. They

believe in a God who is entirely separate from them, a great king, a high,

mighty monarch, as it were. At the same time they make Him purer than the

monarchs of the earth; they give Him all good qualities and remove the evil

qualities from Him. As if it were ever possible for good to exist without

evil; as if there could be any conception of light without a conception of

darkness!

With all dualistic theories the first difficulty is, how is it possible that

under the rule of a just and merciful God, the repository of an infinite

number of good qualities, there can be so many evils in this world? This

question arose in all dualistic religions, but the Hindus never invented a

Satan as an answer to it. The Hindus with one accord laid the blame on man,

and it was easy for them to do so. Why? Because, as I have just now told

you, they did not believe that souls were created out of nothing We see in

this life that we can shape and form our future every one of us, every day,

is trying to shape the morrow; today we fix the fate of the morrow; tomorrow

we shall fix the fate of the day after, and so on. It is quite logical that

this reasoning can be pushed backward too. If by our own deeds we shape our

destiny in the future why not apply the same rule to the past? If, in an

infinite chain, a certain number of links are alternately repeated then, if

one of these groups of links be explained, we can explain the whole chain.

So, in this infinite length of time, if we can cut off one portion and

explain that portion and understand it, then, if it be true that nature is

uniform, the same explanation must apply to the whole chain of time. If it

be true that we are working out our own destiny here within this short space

of time if it be true that everything must have a cause as we see it now, it

must also be true that that which we are now is the effect of the whole of

our past; therefore, no other person is necessary to shape the destiny of

mankind but man himself. The evils that are in the world are caused by none

else but ourselves. We have caused all this evil; and just as we constantly

see misery resulting from evil actions, so can we also see that much of the

existing misery in the world is the effect of the past wickedness of man.

Man alone, therefore, according to this theory, is responsible. God is not

to blame. He, the eternally merciful Father, is not to blame at all. "We

reap what we sow."

Another peculiar doctrine of the dualists is, that every soul must

eventually come to salvation. No one will be left out. Through various

vicissitudes, through various sufferings and enjoyments, each one of them

will come out in the end. Come out of what? The one common idea of all Hindu

sects is that all souls have to get out of this universe. Neither the

universe which we see and feel, nor even an imaginary one, can be right, the

real one, because both are mixed up with good and evil. According to the

dualists, there is beyond this universe a place full of happiness and good

only; and when that place is reached, there will be no more necessity of

being born and reborn, of living and dying; and this idea is very dear to

them. No more disease there, and no more death. There will be eternal

happiness, and they will be in the presence of God for all time and enjoy

Him for ever. They believe that all beings, from the lowest worm up to the

highest angels and gods, will all, sooner or later, attain to that world

where there will be no more misery. But our world will never end; it goes on

infinitely, although moving in waves. Although moving in cycles it never

ends. The number of souls that are to be saved, that are to be perfected, is

infinite. Some are in plants, some are in the lower animals, some are in

men, some are in gods, but all of them, even the highest gods, are

imperfect, are in bondage. What is the bondage? The necessity of being born

and the necessity of dying. Even the highest gods die. What are these gods?

They mean certain states, certain offices. For instance, Indra the king of

gods, means a certain office; some soul which was very high has gone to fill

that post in this cycle, and after this cycle he will be born again as man

and come down to this earth, and the man who is very good in this cycle will

go and fill that post in the next cycle. So with all these gods; they are

certain offices which have been filled alternately by millions and millions

of souls, who, after filling those offices, came down and became men. Those

who do good works in this world and help others, but with an eye to reward,

hoping to reach heaven or to get the praise of their fellow-men, must when

they die, reap the benefit of those good works — they become these gods. But

that is not salvation; salvation never will come through hope of reward.

Whatever man desires the Lord gives him. Men desire power, they desire

prestige, they desire enjoyments as gods, and they get these desires

fulfilled, but no effect of work can be eternal. The effect will be

exhausted after a certain length of time; it may be aeons, but after that it

will be gone, and these gods must come down again and become men and get

another chance for liberation. The lower animals will come up and become

men, become gods, perhaps, then become men again, or go back to animals,

until the time when they will get rid of all desire for enjoyment, the

thirst for life, this clinging on to the "me and mine". This "me and mine"

is the very root of all the evil in the world. If you ask a dualist, "Is

your child yours?" he will say, "It is God's. My property is not mine, it is

God's." Everything should be held as God's.

Now, these dualistic sects in India are great vegetarians, great preachers

of non-killing of animals. But their idea about it is quite different from

that of the Buddhist. If you ask a Buddhist, "Why do you preach against

killing any animal?" he will answer, "We have no right to take any life;"

and if you ask a dualist, "Why do you not kill any animal?" he says,

"Because it is the Lord's." So the dualist says that this "me and mine" is

to be applied to God and God alone; He is the only "me" and everything is

His. When a man has come to the state when he has no "me and mine," when

everything is given up to the Lord, when he loves everybody and is ready

even to give up his life for an animal, without any desire for reward, then

his heart will be purified, and when the heart has been purified, into that

heart will come the love of God. God is the centre of attraction for every

soul, and the dualist says, "A needle covered up with clay will not be

attracted by a magnet, but as soon as the clay is washed off, it will be

attracted." God is the magnet and human soul is the needle, and its evil

works, the dirt and dust that cover it. As soon as the soul is pure it will

by natural attraction come to God and remain with Him for ever, but remain

eternally separate. The perfected soul, if it wishes, can take any form; it

is able to take a hundred bodies, if it wishes or have none at all, if it

so desires. It becomes almost almighty, except that it cannot create; that

power belongs to God alone. None, however perfect, can manage the affairs of

the universe; that function belongs to God. But all souls, when they become

perfect, become happy for ever and live eternally with God. This is the

dualistic statement.

One other idea the dualists preach. They protest against the idea of praying

to God, "Lord, give me this and give me that." They think that should not be

done. If a man must ask some material gift, he should ask inferior beings

for it; ask one of these gods, or angels or a perfected being for temporal

things. God is only to be loved. It is almost a blasphemy to pray to God,

"Lord, give me this, and give me that." According to the dualists,

therefore, what a man wants, he will get sooner or later, by praying to one

of the gods; but if he wants salvation, he must worship God. This is the

religion of the masses of India.

The real Vedanta philosophy begins with those known as the qualified

non-dualists. They make the statement that the effect is never different

from the cause; the effect is but the cause reproduced in another form. If

the universe is the effect and God the cause, it must be God Himself — it

cannot be anything but that. They start with the assertion that God is both

the efficient and the material cause of the universe; that He Himself is the

creator, and He Himself is the material out of which the whole of nature is

projected. The word "creation" in your language has no equivalent in

Sanskrit, because there is no sect in India which believes in creation, as

it is regarded in the West, as something coming out of nothing. It seems

that at one time there were a few that had some such idea, but they were

very quickly silenced. At the present time I do not know of any sect that

believes this. What we mean by creation is projection of that which already

existed. Now, the whole universe, according to this sect, is God Himself. He

is the material of the universe. We read in the Vedas, "As the Urnanâbhi

(spider) spins the thread out of its own body, . . . even so the whole

universe has come out of the Being."

If the effect is the cause reproduced, the question is: "How is it that we

find this material, dull, unintelligent universe produced from a God, who is

not material, but who is eternal intelligence? How, if the cause is pure and

perfect, can the effect be quite different?" What do these qualified

non-dualists say? Theirs is a very peculiar theory. They say that these

three existences, God, nature, and the soul, are one. God is, as it were,

the Soul, and nature and souls are the body of God. Just as I have a body

and I have a soul, so the whole universe and all souls are the body of God,

and God is the Soul of souls. Thus, God is the material cause of the

universe. The body may be changed — may be young or old, strong or weak —

but that does not affect the soul at all. It is the same eternal existence,

manifesting through the body. Bodies come and go, but the soul does not

change. Even so the whole universe is the body of God, and in that sense it

is God. But the change in the universe does not affect God. Out of this

material He creates the universe, and at the end of a cycle His body becomes

finer, it contracts; at the beginning of another cycle it becomes expanded

again, and out of it evolve all these different worlds.

Now both the dualists and the qualified non-dualists admit that the soul is

by its nature pure, but through its own deeds it becomes impure. The

qualified non-dualists express it more beautifully than the dualists, by

saving that the soul's purity and perfection become contracted and again

become manifest, and what we are now trying to do is to remanifest the

intelligence, the purity, the power which is natural to the soul. Souls have

a multitude of qualities, but not that of almightiness or all-knowingness.

Every wicked deed contracts the nature of the soul, and every good deed

expands it, and these souls, are all parts of God. "As from a blazing fire

fly millions of sparks of the same nature, even so from this Infinite Being,

God, these souls have come." Each has the same goal. The God of the

qualified non-dualists is also a Personal God, the repository of an infinite

number of blessed qualities, only He is interpenetrating everything in the

universe. He is immanent in everything and everywhere; and when the

scriptures say that God is everything, it means that God is interpenetrating

everything, not that God has become the wall, but that God is in the wall.

There is not a particle, not an atom in the universe where He is not. Souls

are all limited; they are not omnipresent. When they get expansion of their

powers and become perfect, there is no more birth and death for them; they

live with God for ever.

Now we come to Advaitism, the last and, what we think, the fairest flower of

philosophy and religion that any country in any age has produced, where

human thought attains its highest expression and even goes beyond the

mystery which seems to be impenetrable. This is the non-dualistic Vedantism.

It is too abstruse, too elevated to be the religion of the masses. Even in

India, its birthplace, where it has been ruling supreme for the last three

thousand years, it has not been able to permeate the masses. As we go on we

shall find that it is difficult for even the most thoughtful man and woman

in any country to understand Advaitism. We have made ourselves so weak; we

have made ourselves so low. We may make great claims, but naturally we want

to lean on somebody else. We are like little, weak plants, always wanting a

support. How many times I have been asked for a "comfortable religion!" Very

few men ask for the truth, fewer still dare to learn the truth, and fewest

of all dare to follow it in all its practical bearings. It is not their

fault; it is all weakness of the brain. Any new thought, especially of a

high kind, creates a disturbance, tries to make a new channel, as it were,

in the brain matter, and that unhinges the system, throws men off their

balance. They are used to certain surroundings, and have to overcome a huge

mass of ancient superstitions, ancestral superstition, class superstition,

city superstition, country superstition, and behind all, the vast mass of

superstition that is innate in every human being. Yet there are a few brave

souls in the world who dare to conceive the truth, who dare to take it up,

and who dare to follow it to the end.

What does the Advaitist declare? He says, if there is a God, that God must

be both the material and the efficient cause of the universe. Not only is He

the creator, but He is also the created. He Himself is this universe. How

can that be? God, the pure, the spirit, has become the universe? Yes;

apparently so. That which all ignorant people see as the universe does not

really exist. What are you and I and all these things we see? Mere

self-hypnotism; there is but one Existence, the Infinite, the Ever-blessed

One. In that Existence we dream all these various dreams. It is the Atman,

beyond all, the Infinite, beyond the known, beyond the knowable; in and

through That we see the universe. It is the only Reality. It is this table;

It is the audience before me; It is the wall; It is everything, minus the

name and form. Take away the form of the table, take away the name; what

remains is It. The Vedantist does not call It either He or She — these are

fictions, delusions of the human brain — there is no sex in the soul. People

who are under illusion, who have become like animals, see a woman or a man;

living gods do not see men or women. How can they who are beyond everything

have any sex idea? Everyone and everything is the Atman — the Self — the

sexless, the pure, the ever-blessed. It is the name, the form, the body,

which are material, and they make all this difference. If you take away

these two differences of name and form, the whole universe is one; there are

no two, but one everywhere. You and I are one. There is neither nature, nor

God, nor the universe, only that one Infinite Existence, out of which,

through name and form, all these are manufactured. How to know the Knower?

It cannot be known. How can you see your own Self? You can only reflect

yourself. So all this universe is the reflection of that One Eternal Being,

the Atman, and as the reflection falls upon good or bad reflectors, so good

or bad images are cast up. Thus in the murderer, the reflector is bad and

not the Self. In the saint the reflector is pure. The Self — the Atman — is

by Its own nature pure. It is the same, the one Existence of the universe

that is reflecting Itself from the lowest worm to the highest and most

perfect being. The whole of this universe is one Unity, one Existence,

physically, mentally, morally and spiritually. We are looking upon this one

Existence in different forms and creating all these images upon It. To the

being who has limited himself to the condition of man, It appears as the

world of man. To the being who is on a higher plane of existence, It may

seem like heaven. There is but one Soul in the universe, not two. It neither

comes nor goes. It is neither born, nor dies, nor reincarnates. How can It

die? Where can It go? All these heavens, all these earths, and all these

places are vain imaginations of the mind. They do not exist, never existed

in the past, and never will exist in the future.

I am omnipresent, eternal. Where can I go? Where am I not already? I am

reading this book of nature. Page after page I am finishing and turning

over, and one dream of life after another goes Away. Another page of life is

turned over; another dream of life comes, and it goes away, rolling and

rolling, and when I have finished my reading, I let it go and stand aside, I

throw away the book, and the whole thing is finished. What does the

Advaitist preach? He dethrones all the gods that ever existed, or ever will

exist in the universe and places on that throne the Self of man, the Atman,

higher than the sun and the moon, higher than the heavens, greater than this

great universe itself. No books, no scriptures, no science can ever imagine

the glory of the Self that appears as man, the most glorious God that ever

was, the only God that ever existed, exists, or ever will exist. I am to

worship, therefore, none but myself. "I worship my Self," says the

Advaitist. To whom shall I bow down? I salute my Self. To whom shall I go

for help? Who can help me, the Infinite Being of the universe? These are

foolish dreams, hallucinations; who ever helped any one? None. Wherever you

see a weak man, a dualist, weeping and wailing for help from somewhere above

the skies, it is because he does not know that the skies also are in him. He

wants help from the skies, and the help comes. We see that it comes; but it

comes from within himself, and he mistakes it as coming from without.

Sometimes a sick man lying on his bed may hear a tap on the door. He gets up

and opens it and finds no one there. He goes back to bed, and again he hears

a tap. He gets up and opens the door. Nobody is there. At last he finds that

it was his own heartbeat which he fancied was a knock at the door. Thus man,

after this vain search after various gods outside himself, completes the

circle, and comes back to the point from which he started — the human soul,

and he finds that the God whom he was searching in hill and dale, whom he

was seeking in every brook, in every temple, in churches and heavens, that

God whom he was even imagining as sitting in heaven and ruling the world, is

his own Self. I am He, and He is I. None but I was God, and this little I

never existed.

Yet, how could that perfect God have been deluded? He never was. How could a

perfect God have been dreaming? He never dreamed. Truth never dreams. The

very question as to whence this illusion arose is absurd. Illusion arises

from illusion alone. There will be no illusion as soon as the truth is seen.

Illusion always rests upon illusion; it never rests upon God, the Truth, the

Atman. You are never in illusion; it is illusion that is in you, before you.

A cloud is here; another comes and pushes it aside and takes its place.

Still another comes and pushes that one away. As before the eternal blue

sky, clouds of various hue and colour come, remain for a short time and

disappear, leaving it the same eternal blue, even so are you, eternally

pure, eternally perfect. You are the veritable Gods of the universe; nay,

there are not two — there is but One. It is a mistake to say, "you and I";

say "I". It is I who am eating in millions of mouths; how can I be hungry?

It is I who am working through an infinite number of hands; how can I be

inactive? It is I who am living the life of the whole universe; where is

death for me? I am beyond all life, beyond all death. Where shall I seek for

freedom? I am free by my nature. Who can bind me — the God of this universe?

The scriptures of the world are but little maps, wanting to delineate my

glory, who am the only existence of the universe. Then what are these books

to me? Thus says the Advaitist.

"Know the truth and be free in a moment." All the darkness will then vanish.

When man has seen himself as one with the Infinite Being of the universe,

when all separateness has ceased, when all men and women, an gods and

angels, all animals and plants, and the whole universe have melted into that

Oneness, then all fear disappears. Can I hurt myself? Can I kill myself? Can

I injure myself? Whom to fear? Can you fear yourself? Then will all sorrow

disappear. What can cause me sorrow? I am the One Existence of the universe.

Then all jealousies will disappear; of whom to be jealous? Of myself? Then

all bad feelings disappear. Against whom can I have bad feeling? Against

myself? There is none in the universe but I. And this is the one way, says

the Vedantist, to Knowledge. Kill out this differentiation, kill out this

superstition that there are many. "He who in this world of many sees that

One, he who in this mass of insentiency sees that one Sentient Being, he who

in this world of shadows catches that Reality, unto him belongs eternal

peace, unto none else, unto none else."

These are the salient points of the three steps which Indian religious

thought has taken in regard to God. We have seen that it began with the

Personal, the extra-cosmic God. It went from the external to the internal

cosmic body, God immanent in the universe, and ended in identifying the soul

itself with that God, and making one Soul, a unit of all these various

manifestations in the universe. This is the last word of the Vedas. It

begins with dualism, goes through a qualified monism and ends in perfect

monism. We know how very few in this world can come to the last, or even

dare believe in it, and fewer still dare act according to it. Yet we know

that therein lies the explanation of all ethics, of all morality and all

spirituality in the universe. Why is it that every one says, "Do good to

others?" Where is the explanation? Why is it that all great men have

preached the brotherhood of mankind, and greater men the brotherhood of all

lives? Because whether they were conscious of it or not, behind all that,

through all their irrational and personal superstitions, was peering forth

the eternal light of the Self denying all manifoldness, and asserting that

the whole universe is but one.

Again, the last word gave us one universe, which through the senses we see

as matter, through the intellect as souls, and through the spirit as God. To

the man who throws upon himself veils, which the world calls wickedness and

evil, this very universe will change and become a hideous place; to another

man, who wants enjoyments, this very universe will change its appearance and

become a heaven, and to the perfect man the whole thing will vanish and

become his own Self.

Now, as society exists at the present time, all these three stages are

necessary; the one does not deny the other, one is simply the fulfilment of

the other. The Advaitist or the qualified Advaitist does not say that

dualism is wrong; it is a right view, but a lower one. It is on the way to

truth; therefore let everybody work out his own vision of this universe,

according to his own ideas. Injure none, deny the position of none; take man

where he stands and, if you can, lend him a helping hand and put him on a

higher platform, but do not injure and do not destroy. All will come to

truth in the long run. "When all the desires of the heart will be

vanquished, then this very mortal will become immortal" — then the very man

will become God.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 2, en.wikisource.org · Contents