Hinduism

Jnana-Yoga — The Freedom of the Soul

The Katha Upanishad, which we have been studying, was written much later

than that to which we now turn — the Chhândogya. The language is more

modern, and the thought more organised. In the older Upanishads the language

is very archaic, like that of the hymn portion of the Vedas, and one has to

wade sometimes through quite a mass of unnecessary things to get at the

essential doctrines. The ritualistic literature about which I told you which

forms the second division of the Vedas, has left a good deal of its mark

upon this old Upanishad, so that more than half of it is still ritualistic.

There is, however, one great gain in studying the very old Upanishads. You

trace, as it were, the historical growth of spiritual ideas. In the more

recent Upanishads, the spiritual ideas have been collected and brought into

one place; as in the Bhagavad Gitâ, for instance, which we may, perhaps,

look upon as the last of the Upanishads, you do not find any inkling of

these ritualistic ideas. The Gita is like a bouquet composed of the

beautiful flowers of spiritual truths collected from the Upanishads. But in

the Gita you cannot study the rise of the spiritual ideas, you cannot trace

them to their source. To do that, as has been pointed out by many, you must

study the Vedas. The great idea of holiness that has been attached to these

books has preserved them, more than any other book in the world, from

mutilation. In them, thoughts at their highest and at their lowest have all

been preserved, the essential and the non-essential, the most ennobling

teachings and the simplest matters of detail stand side by side; for nobody

has dared to touch them. Commentators came and tried to smooth them down and

to bring out wonderful new ideas from the old things; they tried to find

spiritual ideas in even the most ordinary statements, but the texts

remained, and as such, they are the most wonderful historical study. We all

know that in the scriptures of every religion changes were made to suit the

growing spirituality of later times; one word was changed here and another

put in there, and so on. This, probably, has not been done with the Vedic

literature, or if ever done, it is almost imperceptible. So we have this

great advantage, we are able to study thoughts in their original

significance, to note how they developed, how from materialistic ideas finer

and finer spiritual ideas are evolved, until they attained their greatest

height in the Vedanta. Descriptions of some of the old manners and customs

are also there, but they do not appear much in the Upanishads. The language

used is peculiar, terse, mnemonic.

The writers of these books simply jotted down these lines as helps to

remember certain facts which they supposed were already well known. In a

narrative, perhaps, which they are telling, they take it for granted that it

is well known to everyone they are addressing. Thus a great difficulty

arises, we scarcely know the real meaning of any one of these stories,

because the traditions have nearly died out, and the little that is left of

them has been very much exaggerated. Many new interpretations have been put

upon them, so that when you find them in the Purânas they have already

become lyrical poems. Just as in the West, we find this prominent fact in

the political development of Western races that they cannot bear absolute

rule, that they are always trying to prevent any one man from ruling over

them, and are gradually advancing to higher and higher democratic ideas,

higher and higher ideas of physical liberty, so, in Indian metaphysics,

exactly the same phenomenon appears in the development of spiritual life.

The multiplicity of gods gave place to one God of the universe, and in the

Upanishads there is a rebellion even against that one God. Not only was the

idea of many governors of the universe ruling their destinies unbearable,

but it was also intolerable that there should be one person ruling this

universe. This is the first thing that strikes us. The idea grows and grows,

until it attains its climax. In almost all of the Upanishads, we find the

climax coming at the last, and that is the dethroning of this God of the

universe. The personality of God vanishes, the impersonality comes. God is

no more a person, no more a human being, however magnified and exaggerated,

who rules this universe, but He has become an embodied principle in every

being, immanent in the whole universe. It would be illogical to go from the

Personal God to the Impersonal, and at the same time to leave man as a

person. So the personal man is broken down, and man as principle is built

up. The person is only a phenomenon, the principle is behind it. Thus from

both sides, simultaneously, we find the breaking down of personalities and

the approach towards principles, the Personal God approaching the

Impersonal, the personal man approaching the Impersonal Man. Then come the

succeeding stages of the gradual convergence of the two advancing lines of

the Impersonal God and the Impersonal Man. And the Upanishads embody the

stages through which these two lines at last become one, and the last word

of each Upanishad is, "Thou art That". There is but One Eternally Blissful

Principle, and that One is manifesting Itself as all this variety.

Then came the philosophers. The work of the Upanishads seems to have ended

at that point; the next was taken up by the philosophers. The framework was

given them by the Upanishads, and they had to fill in the details. So, many

questions would naturally arise. Taking for granted that there is but One

Impersonal Principle which is manifesting Itself in all these manifold

forms, how is it that the One becomes many? It is another way of putting the

same old question which in its crude form comes into the human heart as the

inquiry into the cause of evil and so forth. Why does evil exist in the

world, and what is its cause? But the same question has now become refined,

abstracted. No more is it asked from the platform of the senses why we are

unhappy, but from the platform of philosophy. How is it that this One

Principle becomes manifold? And the answer, as we have seen, the best answer

that India has produced is the theory of Maya which says that It really has

not become manifold, that It really has not lost any of Its real nature.

Manifoldness is only apparent. Man is only apparently a person, but in

reality he is the Impersonal Being. God is a person only apparently, but

really He is the Impersonal Being.

Even in this answer there have been succeeding stages, and philosophers have

varied in their opinions. All Indian philosophers did not admit this theory

of Maya. Possibly most of them did not. There are dualists, with a crude

sort of dualism, who would not allow the question to be asked, but stifled

it at its very birth. They said, "You have no right to ask such a question,

you have no right to ask for an explanation; it is simply the will of God,

and we have to submit to it quietly. There is no liberty for the human soul.

Everything is predestined — what we shall do, have, enjoy, and suffer; and

when suffering comes, it is our duty to endure it patiently; if we do not,

we shall be punished all the more. How do we know that? Because the Vedas

say so." And thus they have their texts and their meanings and they want to

enforce them.

There are others who, though not admitting the Maya theory, stand midway.

They say that the whole of this creation forms, as it were, the body of God.

God is the Soul of all souls and of the whole of nature. In the case of

individual souls, contraction comes from evil doing. When a man does

anything evil, his soul begins to contract and his power is diminished and

goes on decreasing, until he does good works, when it expands again. One

idea seems to be common in all the Indian systems, and I think, in every

system in the world, whether they know it or not, and that is what I should

call the divinity of man. There is no one system in the world, no real

religion, which does not hold the idea that the human soul, whatever it be,

or whatever its relation to God, is essentially pure and perfect, whether

expressed in the language of mythology, allegory, or philosophy. Its real

nature is blessedness and power, not weakness and misery. Somehow or other

this misery has come. The crude systems may call it a personified evil, a

devil, or an Ahriman, to explain how this misery came. Other systems may try

to make a God and a devil in one, who makes some people miserable and others

happy, without any reason whatever. Others again, more thoughtful, bring in

the theory of Maya and so forth. But one fact stands out clearly, and it is

with this that we have to deal. After all, these philosophical ideas and

systems are but gymnastics of the mind, intellectual exercises. The one

great idea that to me seems to be clear, and comes out through masses of

superstition in every country and in every religion, is the one luminous

idea that man is divine, that divinity is our nature.

Whatever else comes is a mere superimposition, as the Vedanta calls it.

Something has been superimposed, but that divine nature never dies. In the

most degraded as well as in the most saintly it is ever present. It has to

be called out, and it will work itself out. We have to ask and it will

manifest itself. The people of old knew that fire lived in the flint and in

dry wood, but friction was necessary to call it out. So this fire of freedom

and purity is the nature of every soul, and not a quality, because qualities

can be acquired and therefore can be lost. The soul is one with Freedom, and

the soul is one with Existence, and the soul is one with Knowledge. The

Sat-Chit-Ânanda — Existence-Knowledge-Bliss Absolute — is the nature, the

birthright of the Soul, and all the manifestations that we see are Its

expressions, dimly or brightly manifesting Itself. Even death is but a

manifestation of that Real Existence. Birth and death, life and decay,

degeneration and regeneration — are all manifestations of that Oneness. So,

knowledge, however it manifests itself, either as ignorance or as learning,

is but the manifestation of that same Chit, the essence of knowledge; the

difference is only in degree, and not in kind. The difference in knowledge

between the lowest worm that crawls under our feet and the highest genius

that the world may produce is only one of degree, and not of kind. The

Vedantin thinker boldly says that the enjoyments in this life, even the most

degraded joys, are but manifestations of that One Divine Bliss, the Essence

of the Soul.

This idea seems to be the most prominent in Vedanta, and, as I have said, it

appears to me that every religion holds it. I have yet to know the religion

which does not. It is the one universal idea working through all religions.

Take the Bible for instance. You find there the allegorical statement that

the first man Adam was pure, and that his purity was obliterated by his evil

deeds afterwards. It is clear from this allegory that they thought that the

nature of the primitive man was perfect. The impurities that we see, the

weaknesses that we feel, are but superimpositions on that nature, and the

subsequent history of the Christian religion shows that they also believe in

the possibility, nay, the certainty of regaining that old state. This is the

whole history of the Bible, Old and New Testaments together. So with the

Mohammedans: they also believed in Adam and the purity of Adam, and through

Mohammed the way was opened to regain that lost state. So with the

Buddhists: they believe in the state called Nirvana which is beyond this

relative world. It is exactly the same as the Brahman of the Vedantins, and

the whole system of the Buddhists is founded upon the idea of regaining that

lost state of Nirvana. In every system we find this doctrine present, that

you cannot get anything which is not yours already. You are indebted to

nobody in this universe. You claim your own birthright, as it has been most

poetically expressed by a great Vedantin philosopher, in the title of one of

his books — "The attainment of our own empire". That empire is ours; we have

lost it and we have to regain it. The Mâyâvâdin, however, says that this

losing of the empire was a hallucination; you never lost it. This is the

only difference.

Although all the systems agree so far that we had the empire, and that we

have lost it, they give us varied advice as to how to regain it. One says

that you must perform certain ceremonies, pay certain sums of money to

certain idols, eat certain sorts of food, live in a peculiar fashion to

regain that empire. Another says that if you weep and prostrate yourselves

and ask pardon of some Being beyond nature, you will regain that empire.

Again, another says if you love such a Being with all your heart, you will

regain that empire. All this varied advice is in the Upanishads. As I go on,

you will find it so. But the last and the greatest counsel is that you need

not weep at all. You need not go through all these ceremonies, and need not

take any notice of how to regain your empire, because you never lost it. Why

should you go to seek for what you never lost? You are pure already, you are

free already. If you think you are free, free you are this moment, and if

you think you are bound, bound you will be. This is a very bold statement,

and as I told you at the beginning of this course, I shall have to speak to

you very boldly. It may frighten you now, but when you think over it, and

realise it in your own life, then you will come to know that what I say is

true. For, supposing that freedom is not your nature, by no manner of means

can you become free. Supposing you were free and in some way you lost that

freedom, that shows that you were not free to begin with. Had you been free,

what could have made you lose it? The independent can never be made

dependent; if it is really dependent, its independence was a hallucination.

Of the two sides, then, which will you take? If you say that the soul was by

its own nature pure and free, it naturally follows that there was nothing in

this universe which could make it bound or limited. But if there was

anything in nature which could bind the soul, it naturally follows that it

was not free, and your statement that it was free is a delusion. So if it is

possible for us to attain to freedom, the conclusion is inevitable that the

soul is by its nature free. It cannot be otherwise. Freedom means

independence of anything outside, and that means that nothing outside itself

could work upon it as a cause. The soul is causeless, and from this follow

all the great ideas that we have. You cannot establish the immortality of

the soul, unless you grant that it is by its nature free, or in other words,

that it cannot be acted upon by anything outside. For death is an effect

produced by some outside cause. I drink poison and I die, thus showing that

my body can be acted upon by something outside that is called poison. But if

it be true that the soul is free, it naturally follows that nothing can

affect it, and it can never die. Freedom, immortality, blessedness, all

depend upon the soul being beyond the law of causation, beyond this Maya. Of

these two which will you take? Either make the first a delusion, or make the

second a delusion. Certainly I will make the second a delusion. It is more

consonant with all my feelings and aspirations. I am perfectly aware that I

am free by nature, and I will not admit that this bondage is true and my

freedom a delusion.

This discussion goes on in all philosophies, in some form or other. Even in

the most modern philosophies you find the same discussion arising. There are

two parties. One says that there is no soul, that the idea of soul is a

delusion produced by the repeated transit of particles or matter, bringing

about the combination which you call the body or brain; that the impression

of freedom is the result of the vibrations and motions and continuous

transit of these particles. There were Buddhistic sects who held the same

view and illustrated it by this example: If young take a torch and whirl it

round rapidly, there will be a circle of light. That circle does not really

exist, because the torch is changing place every moment. We are but bundles

of little particles, which in their rapid whirling produce the delusion of a

permanent soul. The other party states that in the rapid succession of

thought, matter occurs as a delusion, and does not really exist. So we see

one side claiming that spirit is a delusion and the other, that matter is a

delusion. Which side will you take? Of course, we will take the spirit and

deny matter. The arguments are similar for both, only on the spirit side the

argument is little stronger. For nobody has ever seen what matter is. We can

only feel ourselves. I never knew a man who could feel matter outside of

himself. Nobody was ever able to jump outside of himself. Therefore the

argument is a little stronger on the side of the spirit. Secondly, the

spirit theory explains the universe, whiles materialism does not. Hence the

materialistic explanation is illogical. If you boil down all the

philosophies and analyse them, you will find that they are reduced to one;

or the other of these two positions. So here, too, in a more intricate form,

in a more philosophical form, we find the same question about natural purity

and freedom. Ones side says that the first is a delusion, and the other,

that the second is a delusion. And, of course, we side with the second, in

believing that our bondage is a delusion.

The solution of the Vedanta is that we are not bound, we are free already.

Not only so, but to say or to think that we are bound is dangerous — it is a

mistake, it is self-hypnotism. As soon as you say, "I am bound," "I am

weak," "I am helpless," woe unto you; you rivet one more chain upon

yourself. Do not say it, do not think it. I have heard of a man who lived in

a forest and used to repeat day and night, "Shivoham" — I am the Blessed One

— and one day a tiger fell upon him and dragged him away to kill him; people

on the other side of the river saw it, and heard the voice so long as voice

remained in him, saying, "Shivoham" — even in the very jaws of the tiger.

There have been many such men. There have been cases of men who, while being

cut to pieces, have blessed their enemies. "I am He, I am He; and so art

thou. I am pure and perfect and so are all my enemies. You are He, and so am

I." That is - the position of strength. Nevertheless, there are great and

wonderful things in the religions of the dualists; wonderful is the idea of

the Personal God apart from nature, whom we worship and love. Sometimes this

idea is very soothing. But, says the Vedanta, the soothing is something like

the effect that comes from an opiate, not natural. It brings weakness in the

long run, and what this world wants today, more than it ever did before, is

strength. It is weakness, says the Vedanta, which is the cause of all misery

in this world. Weakness is the one cause of suffering. We become miserable

because we are weak. We lie, steal, kill, and commit other crimes, because

we are weak. We suffer because we are weak. We die because we are weak.

Where there is nothing to weaken us, there is no death nor sorrow. We are

miserable through delusion. Give up the delusion, and the whole thing

vanishes. It is plain and simple indeed. Through all these philosophical

discussions and tremendous mental gymnastics we come to this one religious

idea, the simplest in the whole world.

The monistic Vedanta is the simplest form in which you can put truth. To

teach dualism was a tremendous mistake made in India and elsewhere, because

people did not look at the ultimate principles, but only thought of the

process which is very intricate indeed. To many, these tremendous

philosophical and logical propositions were alarming. They thought these

things could not be made universal, could not be followed in everyday

practical life, and that under the guise of such a philosophy much laxity of

living would arise.

But I do not believe at all that monistic ideas preached to the world would

produce immorality and weakness. On the contrary, I have reason to believe

that it is the only remedy there is. If this be the truth, why let people

drink ditch water when the stream of life is flowing by? If this be the

truth, that they are all pure, why not at this moment teach it to the whole

world? Why not teach it with the voice of thunder to every man that is born,

to saints and sinners, men, women, and children, to the man on the throne

and to the man sweeping the streets?

It appears now a very big and a very great undertaking; to many it appears

very startling, but that is because of superstition, nothing else. By eating

all sorts of bad and indigestible food, or by starving ourselves, we are

incompetent to eat a good meal. We have listened to words of weakness from

our childhood. You hear people say that they do not believe in ghosts, but

at the same time, there are very few who do not get a little creepy

sensation in the dark. It is simply superstition. So with all religious

superstitions There are people in this country who, if I told them there was

no such being as the devil, will think all religion is gone. Many people

have said to me, how can there be religion without a devil? How can there be

religion without someone to direct us? How can we live without being ruled

by somebody? We like to be so treated, because we have become used to it. We

are not happy until we feel we have been reprimanded by somebody every day.

The same superstition! But however terrible it may seem now, the time will

come when we shall look back, each one of us, and smile at every one of

those superstitions which covered the pure and eternal soul, and repeat with

gladness, with truth, and with strength, I am free, and was free, and always

will be free. This monistic idea will come out of Vedanta, and it is the one

idea that deserves to live. The scriptures may perish tomorrow. Whether this

idea first flashed into the brains of Hebrews or of people living in the

Arctic regions, nobody cares. For this is the truth and truth is eternal;

and truth itself teaches that it is not the special property of any

individual or nation. Men, animals, and gods are all common recipients of

this one truth. Let them all receive it. Why make life miserable? Why let

people fall into all sorts of superstitions? I will give ten thousand lives,

if twenty of them will give up their superstition. Not only in this country,

but in the land of its very birth, if you tell people this truth, they are

frightened. They say, "This idea is for Sannyâsins who give up the world and

live in forests; for them it is all right. But for us poor householders, we

must all have some sort of fear, we must have ceremonies," and so on.

Dualistic ideas have ruled the world long enough, and this is the result.

Why not make a new experiment? It may take ages for all minds to receive

monism, but why not begin now? If we have told it to twenty persons in our

lives, we have done a great work.

There is one idea which often militates against it. It is this. It is all

very well to say, "I am the Pure, the Blessed," but I cannot show it always

in my life. That is true; the ideal is always very hard. Every child that is

born sees the sky overhead very far away, but is that any reason why we

should not look towards the sky? Would it mend matters to go towards

superstition? If we cannot get nectar, would it mend matters for us to drink

poison? Would it be any help for us, because we cannot realise the truth

immediately, to go into darkness and yield to weakness and superstition?

I have no objection to dualism in many of its forms. I like most of them,

but I have objections to every form of teaching which inculcates weakness.

This is the one question I put to every man, woman, or child, when they are

in physical, mental, or spiritual training. Are you strong? Do you feel

strength? — for I know it is truth alone that gives strength. I know that

truth alone gives life, and nothing but going towards reality will make us

strong, and none will reach truth until he is strong. Every system,

therefore, which weakens the mind, makes one superstitious, makes one mope,

makes one desire all sorts of wild impossibilities, mysteries, and

superstitions, I do not like, because its effect is dangerous. Such systems

never bring any good; such things create morbidity in the mind, make it

weak, so weak that in course of time it will be almost impossible to receive

truth or live up to it. Strength, therefore, is the one thing needful.

Strength is the medicine for the world's disease. Strength is the medicine

which the poor must have when tyrannised over by the rich. Strength is the

medicine that the ignorant must have when oppressed by the learned; and it

is the medicine that sinners must have when tyrannised over by other

sinners; and nothing gives such strength as this idea of monism. Nothing

makes us so moral as this idea of monism. Nothing makes us work so well at

our best and highest as when all the responsibility is thrown upon

ourselves. I challenge everyone of you. How will you behave if I put a

little baby in your hands? Your whole life will be changed for the moment;

whatever you may be, you must become selfless for the time being. You will

give up all your criminal ideas as soon as responsibility is thrown upon you

— your whole character will change. So if the whole responsibility is thrown

upon our own shoulders, we shall be at our highest and best; when we have

nobody to grope towards, no devil to lay our blame upon, no Personal God to

carry our burdens, when we are alone responsible, then we shall rise to our

highest and best. I am responsible for my fate, I am the bringer of good

unto myself, I am the bringer of evil. I am the Pure and Blessed One. We

must reject all thoughts that assert the contrary. "I have neither death nor

fear, I have neither caste nor creed, I have neither father nor mother nor

brother, neither friend nor foe, for I am Existence, Knowledge, and Bliss

Absolute; I am the Blissful One, I am the Blissful One. I am not bound

either by virtue or vice, by happiness or misery. Pilgrimages and books and

ceremonials can never bind me. I have neither hunger nor thirst; the body is

not mine, nor am I subject to the superstitions and decay that come to the

body, I am Existence, Knowledge, and Bliss Absolute; I am the Blissful One,

I am the Blissful One."

This, says the Vedanta, is the only prayer that we should have. This is the

only way to reach the goal, to tell ourselves, and to tell everybody else,

that we are divine. And as we go on repeating this, strength comes. He who

falters at first will get stronger and stronger, and the voice will increase

in volume until the truth takes possession of our hearts, and courses

through our veins, and permeates our bodies. Delusion will vanish as the

light becomes more and more effulgent, load after load of ignorance will

vanish, and then will come a time when all else has disappeared and the Sun

alone shines.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 2, en.wikisource.org · Contents