← Back to the lesson (Lesson 156)

Buddhism

Bodhicaryâvatâra, Chapter VIII — Virtue of Meditation or Recollection

There have been many rich men, many glorious men: with their riches, with their glory, no one knows what has become of them.

Why rejoice in praise? I know that others blame me. Why grieve at blame, since others praise me?

Men are changeable and diverse: the Buddhas themselves cannot satisfy them, much less ignorant men like me. What good is it to be concerned with men?

If [a monk] is destitute of everything, he is blamed [: what sins he must have committed!]. If he possesses [garments, bowl and the rest,] he is despised all the more [: by what tricks or what baseness has he captured the goodwill of the almsgivers?]. Such is the nature of men, to be intractable: what pleasure is there in living with them?

“The man of the world is no one’s friend,” the Buddhas have declared, for he has affection only out of personal interest.

Now affection with a view to personal interest is only a form of selfishness: likewise, grief at the loss of riches comes from the thought of lost pleasure.

Trees are not malevolent or scornful: it is no great trouble to become their friend. Oh! when shall I be able to live with the trees, with whom it is so good to live!

My lodging shall be some deserted temple, the foot of a tree or some cave. Oh! when shall I go straight ahead, clinging to nothing, without looking back!

To live in those retreats that belong to no one, wide and virgin, in full freedom, without attachment as without a house; with, for all my goods, an earthen bowl and the monastic robe that will not tempt thieves; free from fear, without care for my body and my life!

When shall I go to the cemetery, the true house of my body, to compare with the skeletons of other men this body which is nothing but rottenness?

For this body, my body! will become a thing so foul that the jackals will not dare to brave its stench.

The bones of this body, which were united to it from the beginning and form part of its [apparent] unity, will be scattered: all the more will my friend leave me.

[But do my wife, my sons, my friends not take a share in my joys, in my sufferings?] — Man is born alone and dies alone: to each belongs his share of suffering. What use are those we love, if not to hinder merit?

Just as a traveller stops at some inn [meets other travellers, sets off again the next day]; so the traveller who follows the road of existences stops in one birth, [meets those who are called kinsfolk, and continues his way, alone].

Settle in the forest without waiting for the four bearers of the dead to carry you off [to the cemetery!] amid the lamentations of your kinsfolk.

He is free from hatred and attachment who lives in the forest; he possesses only this wretched body; long since he has been dead to the world: he dies without sadness.

He will not have around him kinsfolk whose despair afflicts him; no one, at the hour of death, will disturb his remembrance of the Buddha and of the Law.

You are lovely, [for you abound in delights], free from pains [, being the antidote to suffering], beatific [, for you are the source of temporal and supernatural felicities]! O Solitude [, mother of recollection, and] you who prevent all distraction of body, voice and thought, I wish to attach myself to you forever!

Detached from every foreign concern, my attention wholly absorbed in my thought, I shall apply myself to fixing my thought [by holding its edge upon its object] and to taming it [by bringing it back to its object when it strays, by withdrawing it from outward distractions].

Desires, loves, sources of cruel evils in this life as in the other: here below, prison, death, mutilations; later, the tortures of hell.

For your loves, how many base acts before go-betweens, men and women! no care for sin, for reputation, for life put in danger, for fortune squandered! Well then, here they are, the loves whose embrace was for you the supreme delight: here are bones, the same as before; but they are now without a master: embrace them, then, as much as you please, and enjoy this supreme delight!

This face was raised only with effort, for modesty lowered it; a veil hid it from the eyes that did not know it as from those that had already gazed upon it: and now the vultures unearth it, as if to favour your impatience. Look! ..., but why does it fill you with horror?

You jealously guarded this body from the gaze of other men: the beasts of prey devour it: what have you done with your jealousy, that you let them do so?

Now that you have seen the vultures and the jackals feast on this mass of flesh, it is their banquet, you know it, that you anoint with sandalwood and load with ornaments.

You shudder when your eyes fall on a skeleton, motionless and hardly frightening: you are not afraid of it when some vampire or other sets it in motion!

When this skeleton was clothed in flesh, you loved it with passion: here it is bare, and it fills you with horror! If you have no use for it, why caress it when the flesh covers it?

Saliva and excrement have a common origin, namely food; excrement disgusts you, and you drink lovingly from your mistress’s mouth!

Lovers have no use for soft cushions stuffed with cotton; for they do not find in them the repugnant odour that charms them. Is love, then, nothing but a foul obsession?

But if it is the foul that one loves, why seek in embraces an interlacing of bones bound by muscles, wrapped and soiled by flesh?

Your own body supplies you with what you seek; be content with it, without seeking elsewhere, O eater of filth, another receptacle of uncleanness.

“But,” you will say, “I love the flesh of this woman’s body; I love to see it, to touch it.” — What attraction can flesh have, essentially unintelligent as it is?

If what you love is the thought that resides in this body: you can neither see it nor touch it. What you touch is only insensible matter: why embrace it in vain?

That you are unaware of the essential impurity of the bodies of others is nothing surprising; but you do not know that your own body is impure, and that is very strange.

Scorning the young lotus opened by the rays of a cloudless sun, what is this delight that one goes seeking, drunk with impurity, in a receptacle of uncleanness?

It repels you to touch any object soiled by contact with filth: how do you find pleasure in touching the body from which filth comes forth?

Will you claim not to love what is foul? You embrace a body that was formed and nourished on impurities in a receptacle of impurities.

And if you admit it, the objection remains: you feel only disgust for worms, foul and born of filth: is it because of their tiny size? But you love a body, born of impurity, in which impurity is massed.

“But,” you will say, “if the woman’s body is impure, my body too is impure; it cannot be defiled by contact with hers: ‘such a god, such an offering,’ as they say.” — Extreme folly: not only do you not abhor your own impurity, but you seek still other vessels of impurity!

Things naturally pure, camphor for example, rice and condiments, are defiled by the body; the earth itself becomes impure through contact with the fragments of food fallen from the mouth.

If you do not admit the impurity of the body, attested by evidence, recognized by custom, go and see in the cemeteries what a frightful thing the most beautiful bodies become.

When the skin is removed, the body is an object of terror. How, once its nature is known, can you place your love in it?

Thought is drawn toward base desires.

No doubt the body is impure, but the perfume of sandalwood makes it lovable! — Does this perfume come from the sandalwood or from the body that is steeped in it? Why become attached to an object because of a foreign odour?

If the body, ill-smelling of itself, does not excite desire, is that not all the better? But men love what harms them, and the body shall be perfumed!

Does it change the nature of the body that sandalwood smells good? Why become attached to an object because of an odour that remains foreign to it?

It is truly a frightful thing, the body in its natural state, in its nakedness, with uncut hair and nails, dirty teeth, skin soiled with mud.

Why then weary oneself adorning it, as one would sharpen a knife to strike oneself? The world is full of madmen who seek only to deceive and ruin themselves!

You cannot bear the sight of a few skeletons in the cemetery; and you delight in the village, a cemetery swarming with walking skeletons!

And this body, your loves, impure as it is, cannot be had without money: what toil to earn money, what sufferings in hell if one earns it unjustly!

The child is not able to earn: what means will the young man have for pleasure? The flower of age withers in the labours of gain; and the old man, what will he do with pleasures?

Some, full of carnal desires, toil all day at tasks that exhaust them; they return home at night and fall into a sleep like death.

Others follow military or commercial expeditions; they suffer the pains of exile, and, for years, are deprived of their wives and children, for whom alone they toil.

Blinded by desire, they sell themselves for delights that escape them: their life flows away, useless, in the service of others.

Others have sold themselves to masters who employ them in continual journeys; their wives give birth by the roadside, in woods, in caves, on the banks of rivers.

Others, to earn their living, rush into battle at the peril of their lives; they seek glory and find slavery. O folly, O blindness of desire!

Those who steal the wife or the goods of others are mutilated, impaled, burned, put to death by the sword: such are the fruits of desire.

To acquire goods, to keep them, to grieve at their loss: fortune is a great misfortune. Wealth distracts thought, binds it wholly to itself, leaves no chance of thinking of deliverance.

O you who are slaves of desire, great are your pains, very wretched your satisfactions! — Like the measured fodder given to the beast that draws a cart.

And for this tiny and doubtful delight, which is not denied even to beasts of burden, man, blinded by destiny, renders useless this human birth, so rare and so fruitful.

For the body, condemned to a certain end, so paltry compared with the spiritual body, doomed to infernal tortures, what painful efforts since the beginning of time!

Not the millionth part of these efforts and this suffering is needed to obtain the state of a Buddha: the sufferings of those who desire are beyond all measure compared with the sufferings of the practice of a future Buddha, and yet remain barren of the fruit of Bodhi.

Neither the sword, nor poison, nor iron, nor precipices, nor any invention of a torturer can be compared to desires: think only of the tortures of the damned or of the ghosts.

Fear desires, then; learn to love recollection; live in the peaceful forests where quarrels and pains are unknown.

Happy are those who, on the natural terraces of rock, level and vast like the terraces of a palace, charming and cooled by the sandal rays of the star of the night, greeted by the silent and gentle breezes of the woods, come and go peacefully and meditate on the salvation of their neighbour!

They dwell anywhere, as long as they wish, always solitary, at the foot of a tree or in a cave; delivered from the trouble of acquiring or keeping, they live without care, as they please.

When a man has left his house and lives as he will, without attachment, what peace, what joy of heart! Indra himself envies him.

By meditating on the advantages of solitude, of which the foregoing may serve as an example, one calms all imaginings: one is then able to develop within oneself the thought of Bodhi.

The Bodhisattva applies himself first, with diligence and scruple, to making no difference between the self and his neighbour, which is of the essence of the practice of the future Buddha.

What joy is for me, it is for others;

What pain is for me, it is for others.

I must do for others what I do for myself.

Is the body not composed of parts? Is it not regarded as “one”, and, as such, protected and served by all its members as if they were bound together? Likewise, in this world of the living, which is manifold, pain and delight are common to all beings.

If my pain has no echo in the bodies of others, it is no less pain, hard to bear because of attachment to the “self”.

If the pain of others is not felt by me, it is no less painful for them, hard to bear because of attachment to the “self”.

I must destroy my neighbour’s pain, because it is pain, as my own pain is; I must serve my neighbour, because he is a living being as I am myself.

The self and the neighbour aspire equally to happiness: what special character does the self present, that we should devote our efforts to its service alone?

The self and the neighbour equally hate danger and suffering: what special character does the self present, that we should watch over it and not over our neighbour?

“But,” you will say, “my neighbour’s suffering does not hurt me: why seek to protect him?” — I answer: the pain of the body in the life to come does not hurt you, why guard against it?

Will you say that the self passes from one existence into another? Imagination! One is he who dies, another he who is reborn.

If, besides, only the one who can feel a suffering must guard against it, the hand does not suffer from the pain of the foot: why does it defend the foot?

In vain will you say that these altruistic acts, though unjustified, proceed from the feeling of personality: if altruism is not justified, it must be renounced as far as possible, whether it concerns what is called the self, in its successive existences or in its body made of diverse members, or whether it concerns one’s neighbour.

101a) This continuous and conscious series does not exist independently of the momentary phenomena that form it, just as a file does not exist independently of the ants; this aggregate is like an army without true individuality.

101b) Therefore there exists no being to whom pain can be attributed, of whom one can say “his pain”.

102) Sufferings, with no distinction possible, cannot be attributed to anyone: it is because they are “suffering” that they must be fought, and, consequently, no reservation is justified.

103) “But why fight suffering [since, according to you, there exists no being who suffers]?” — Because all schools, [the materialists included,] agree on this point. If it must be fought, it must be fought whatever it may be; if it must not be fought, do not go distinguishing the self [and the neighbour].

104) “But [if all pain must be fought,] why impose upon oneself by free choice the great sufferings of the charitable practice [of the future Buddhas]?” — Considering the sufferings of every creature, can one say that the sufferings of the Compassionate Ones are so great?

105) [And besides] if the suffering of one puts an end to the suffering of many, one must impose it upon oneself, compassionate toward oneself, compassionate toward one’s neighbour.

106) [This is what we see in the Samādhirājasūtra:] the [Bodhisattva] Supuṣpacandra, to save a crowd of unfortunates, defied the king and did not spare his own life.

107) It is thus that the [future Buddhas], whose soul is strengthened [in the equivalence of self and neighbour] and for whom personal delight is nothing but pain when their neighbour suffers, plunge into the Avīci hell like swans into the lotus wood.

108) The deliverance of creatures makes the river of their thoughts overflow into an ocean of joy; the measure [of felicity is full: deliverance itself, at this price, is without savour.

109) If, then, you do good to your neighbour, do not grow proud, admire yourself, count on a reward: the saint is nothing but thirst for the good of others.

110) [Let us sum up:] as I defend myself against all evil, jealous even of my reputation, so I will love, I will defend my neighbour.

111) Under the influence of false judgments repeated in the course of former lives, man attaches the illusory notion of the self, apart from all reality, to the combination of foreign elements, the elements of generation.

112) Why then not regard rather the body of another as our “self”? — As for our own body, to recognize that it is foreign to us is, in truth, all too simple!

113) The [saint] observes the defects of his “self” and the qualities in which his neighbour abounds; he applies himself to stripping himself of himself and clothing himself with his neighbour.

114) Man loves his feet and [his hands] because they are members of the body: living beings have a right to the same affection because they are members of the world of the living.

115) Habit has led us to regard as our “self” this body which does not even exist in itself. Through habit we shall come to see in our neighbour our [true] “self”.

116) Then we shall no longer draw glory, pride or hope of reward from the good we have done to our neighbour: what great merit is there in providing for one's own needs?

117) Just as, quite naturally, I used to protect my “self” against all pain, against all sorrow, so I shall accustom myself to this solicitude, to this tenderness for all living beings.

118) It is thus that the Lord Avalokita consecrated even his name, so that this name might protect creatures against all fear, even the embarrassment one feels before an assembly.

119) Do not say: “it is too difficult”; do not turn back; so great is the power of habit that one comes to be unable to do without what one could not hear named without horror.

120) Whoever wishes swiftly to succeed in safeguarding the self and the neighbour must practise the supreme mystery:

“To act toward the self as [worldly people act] toward others, and conversely.”

121) One has so violent a love for the “self” that its slightest peril terrifies: who would not hate this self, which terrorizes as an enemy does?

122) This self which, to fight sickness, hunger, thirst, [cold], sacrifices birds, fish and quadrupeds, and treats all of nature as an enemy,

123) This self which, out of greed, out of vanity, goes so far as to kill its father and mother, so far as to commit sacrilegious theft — without a care for the hell whose flames it will feed!

124) That is what I am: a worthy object indeed, for a sensible mind, of love, of solicitude, of worship! Rather, hateful as an enemy and worthy of every contempt.

125) “If I give, what shall I eat?” Selfish one, you will be reborn in the body of a piçâca. — “If I eat, what shall I give?” Charitable one, you will be reborn king of the gods!

126) You make your neighbour suffer for your own sake: you will burn in hell. You make yourself suffer for your neighbour's sake: every blessing is assured to you.

127) You claim to raise yourself [above others]: you will be reborn in evil destinies, and [if you then obtain human existence,] you will be base and stupid. But if you transfer your vanity to the benefit of others, you will obtain a good destiny, honours, intelligence.

128) You command your neighbour and make him work for you: you will be a slave and [wretched]; you put yourself at your neighbour's service: you will obtain power and [opulence].

129) All those who are unhappy here below are unhappy because they sought their own happiness; all those who are happy here below are happy because they sought the happiness of their neighbour.

130) What is the good of saying more? See only what a difference there is between the fool who desires his own happiness and the Buddha, the worker of others' good.

131) Surely he does not obtain the state of Buddha, he does not even obtain the joys of this world, who does not exchange his happiness for his neighbour's suffering.

132) And without speaking of the future life, where shall we be here below if the servant refuses to work and the master to pay the wages?

133) Men, instead of rendering service to one another, which is the source of all good in both lives, seek to harm one another: their folly hurls them into extreme ills.

134) Of all the calamities, of all the sufferings, of all the terrors of this world, the sole principle is the feeling or love of self: it must be renounced.

135) One cannot avoid suffering except by leaving the “self”: one cannot avoid being burned except by leaving the fire.

136) If I give my “self” to my neighbour and adopt my neighbour as “self”, it is therefore as much to soothe my own suffering as to soothe my neighbour's.

137) Let it therefore be well understood, O my soul: you belong to your neighbour, and henceforth you may think only of the good of all creatures.

138) These eyes, which are no longer mine, will no longer see “my” interest; and so with all the senses. These hands, which belong to my neighbour, is it fitting that they should work for me? And so with all the organs of action.

139) Wholly given over to creatures, I shall take from this body all its resources to put them at my neighbour's service.

140) I shall hold myself a stranger, and it is in the humblest first that I shall recognize my “self”: then will be the time to be envious and haughty, without faltering or hesitation.

141) “How is it, [I shall say,] that this [self] is honoured and I am not; he is rich and I am not; he is praised and I am blamed; he is happy and I suffer?

142) “I work while he stays at his ease with folded arms: apparently it is because he is great in this world, and I am small, for lack of qualities!

143) “But what use, then, could a man devoid of qualities be? Everyone has his qualities! There are people worth more than I, and there are also some less good.

144) “[Besides,] if I lack morality or doctrine, is it my fault or that of the passions? Let him heal me, then, as far as it lies in him: I accept the treatment, however harsh.

145) “But he is incapable of healing me: why, then, does he despise me? — Because of his excellent virtues? — What does it matter to me, if he is holy only for himself?

146) “Has he even any compassion for the unfortunate whom evil destinies are about to devour? And yet, in the pride of his virtues, he claims to excel among the saints.

147) “When he recognizes an equal, he will fight him when the occasion arises to be first, to satisfy his covetousness or his vanity.

“Ah! if only my qualities were manifest everywhere throughout the world; and if no one heard any more of his, such as they are!

“If my faults remained unknown, if men honoured me without paying heed to him! — At last, here are riches and honours, turned away from him, rightly acquired by me.

“Let us rejoice, a little late, it is true, at the spectacle of the ill-treatment, the mockery and the reproaches with which everyone overwhelms him.

“It is amusing, truly, that this wretch dares to measure himself against me! Is he then learned in the holy books, wise, handsome, noble, rich?

“On hearing all my qualities proclaimed [which he falsely attributed to himself], my hair stands on end in a transport of joy, and I savour my happiness!

“If he possesses any good, we shall take it from him by force; we shall give him what he needs to live, nothing more, and on condition that he serves us.

“For he must stumble from his prosperity; he must bear our sufferings: too often and for too long this wretch has tortured us all.”

[Such are the feelings you will nourish, O my soul, against yourself and in favour of creatures. — Does this seem hard to you? But reflect: have you not, through countless periods of ages, pursued your own good? And what have you gathered from your long efforts, if not suffering, nothing but suffering?

Apply yourself, then, without wavering to the good of your neighbour, I will it! You will see its benefits later, for the word of the Buddha does not deceive.

[Will you say that you were, in fact, charitable? A lie!] Had you practised [charity and humility], you would not be in the wretched state in which I see you — not to speak of the supreme bliss of the Buddhas [that you would have acquired].

Just as you have, for so long, adopted as your “self” this body formed of foreign matter, of seed and blood, learn then to regard your neighbour as your [true] “self”.

Become a spy in your neighbour's service, and whatever you see in your body that is good for anything, steal it from it in your neighbour's interest.

My “self”, you will think, is at its ease: my neighbour is in distress; it is held in honour, my neighbour is humiliated; it rests, my neighbour works. Rouse yourself to jealousy against yourself.

Strip your “self” of all enjoyment and let it bear the pains of others; with a watchfulness of every moment, examine all its faults and all its weaknesses.

Make fall upon its head, upon its head alone, even the faults of others; and confess to the Buddha even its slightest faults.

Tarnish its reputation by proclaiming the greater reputation of others; put it, like a worthless slave, at the service of creatures.

It is not for a few shreds of qualities, all of them due to chance, that it can deserve praise; its depths are nothing but vice. See to it that no one knows its qualities, [if it has any].

In a word, all the harm you did not fear to do to your neighbour in your own interest, make it fall back on yourself in your neighbour's interest.

Do not even grant it the freedom to speak; be bashful, timid, discreet as a new bride.

The “self” must obey you: “Do this, hold yourself thus, do not do that”; it must be punished when it disobeys.

“What, O my mind, say what I will, you do not obey! I shall surely know how to punish you and tame you, O self, you who are the receptacle of all evil.

“Do you hope to escape me? I have seen you, I am destroying all your prides. — The time is past when I let myself be ruined by you.

“Give up all hope that there may still be any interest of your own for you: I have sold you to your neighbour, without a care for [your] sufferings.

“For if I were mad enough not to deliver you over to creatures, it is you, I have no doubt, who would deliver me over to the demons, the guardians of the hells.

“How many times have you already delivered me over to these executioners, and for what long tortures! I remember your cruel enmity, and I crush you, O self, slave of self-interest!”

If I truly love myself, I must not love myself! If I wish to safeguard myself, I must not safeguard myself!

The more you do to spare the body suffering, the more sensitive you make it and the lower you make it fall.

But, despite its fall [and its baseness], the whole world could not appease its thirst for enjoyment; — and who will fulfil its desires?

Now the desire for the impossible brings in its wake disillusion and hatred. He who is without hope possesses a bliss that cannot grow old.

Do not give free rein to the desires of the body. That alone is good which is not conceived as desirable.

[What is the body?] — It will end by being nothing but ashes; it is an inert mass that another sets in motion; it is a heap of filth. Why, then, place my “self” in it?

Living or decomposed, this machine can be of no use to me. What difference is there between the body and a mass of earth or wood? The feeling of “self” must indeed be hard to kill!

Accomplice and friend of my body I have been, to my misfortune, without any profit; whether this puppet is pleased or displeased, a fine affair indeed!

Does it love me when I make myself its defender? Does it hate the vultures that devour it? It is therefore folly to love it.

I am furious when it is ill-treated, joyful when it is honoured. Since it knows nothing of it, what is the good of troubling myself?

Those who love this body [which is said to be mine], I regard them, do I not, as my friends: but all men love their bodies, so it is fitting that I love them.

I have therefore, without reserve, given up my body for the benefit of beings: and if I continue to carry it, despite its vices, it is as an instrument of action.

I renounce the practices of the world and I walk in the path the Saints have followed: I remember the “Sermon on Attention”; I shake off languor and sloth, and, so as no longer to have to fear them, I fix my mind; I withdraw it from evil ways and apply it closely to what must be its object.

Source Shântideva, Bodhicaryâvatâra, trad. L. de La Vallée-Poussin (1907), archive.org (OCR corrigé) — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents