Catholicism

Introduction to the Devout Life, chapter xxix (74)

Of slander.

Rash judgment produces disquiet, contempt for one's neighbour, pride and self-complacency, and a hundred other very harmful effects, among which slander holds first place, as the true plague of conversation. Oh! that I had one of the coals of the holy altar to touch the lips of men and purify them of their sins, as a seraph once purified the lips of the prophet Isaiah! Whoever took slander out of the world would take out of it one of the greatest causes of sin that exist.

If anyone unjustly takes away his neighbour's good name, besides the sin he commits, he is bound to make reparation for it, according to the nature of the slander; for no one can enter Heaven with another's goods; and of all outward goods, reputation is the most precious. Slander is a kind of murder; for we have three lives: the spiritual, which lies in the grace of God; the bodily, of which the soul is the principle; and the civil, which consists in reputation.

Sin takes the first from us, death takes the second, and slander takes the third. But the slanderer has this peculiarity, that with a single stroke of the tongue he usually commits three murders: he kills his own soul and the soul of the one who listens to him, by a spiritual homicide, and he takes away the civil life of the one he slanders; for, as Saint Bernard said, both he who slanders and he who listens to the slanderer have the devil upon them; but the one has him on his tongue, and the other in his ear.

David says, speaking of slanderers, that _they have sharpened their tongue like the tongue of a serpent_. Now the serpent has a forked tongue with two points, as Aristotle remarks; and such indeed is the tongue of the slanderer, which with a single stroke stings and poisons the ear of the one who listens and the reputation of the one he speaks of.

I beg you, then, dear Philothea, never to speak ill of anyone, either directly or indirectly: beware of attributing false crimes to your neighbour, or of revealing those that are secret, or of exaggerating those that are known, or of misinterpreting his good works, or of denying the good you know to be in someone, or of maliciously hiding it, or of lessening it by your words; for in all this you would greatly offend God, above all if it were by falsely accusing your neighbour or by denying the truth to his prejudice; for then there would be the double sin of lying and of harming your neighbour.

Those who prepare their slander with honourable preliminaries, or who intersperse their slanders with little pleasantries and witticisms, are the subtlest and most dangerous slanderers of all. I protest, they say, that I love him, and that besides he is a fine gentleman; but still the truth must be told: he was wrong to commit that act of treachery. She is a very virtuous girl, but she was taken by surprise; and other such turns of phrase.

Do you not see the artifice? He who wants to shoot with the bow draws the arrow towards himself as far as he can, but only to shoot it more powerfully; these people too seem to draw their slander back towards themselves, but only to loose it more forcefully, so that it may pierce deeper into the hearts of those present.

Slander spoken in the form of a joke is crueller still than all the others. For, as hemlock is not in itself a very violent poison, but on the contrary rather slow in its effects and easy to counteract, whereas when taken with wine it is beyond remedy; so slander, which by itself would pass lightly in at one ear and out at the other, lodges firmly in the minds of the hearers when it is accompanied by some subtle and merry word.

To those who slander in this way, we may apply these words of David: _They have the venom of the asp under their lips._ Indeed, the asp makes its bite almost imperceptible, and its venom at first excites a pleasant itching, by means of which the heart and the entrails dilate and receive the poison, so that afterwards no remedy can be applied.

Do not say, such a one is a drunkard, because you have seen him drunk, nor such a one is a thief, because you once caught him stealing; for a single act does not make a habit. The sun once stood still for the victory of Joshua, and another time grew dark for that of the Saviour: yet no one will say that it is motionless or dark. Noah got drunk once, and Lot another time; yet neither of them was a drunkard, any more than Saint Peter was bloodthirsty for having once shed blood, or a blasphemer for having once blasphemed.

The name of vicious or virtuous supposes the habit of vice or of virtue: it is therefore a falsehood to say that a man is quick-tempered or a rogue because we have once seen him lose his temper or steal. And even if a man had long been vicious, we would still risk lying by calling him so. Simon the Leper called Magdalene a sinner because she had once been one: yet he lied; for she was one no longer, but a most holy penitent: and so Our Lord took her under His protection.

The Pharisee regarded the publican as a great sinner, stained perhaps with injustice, adultery and theft; but he was greatly mistaken; for at that very moment the publican had just been justified. Alas! since the goodness of God is so great that a single moment is enough to obtain and receive His grace, what assurance can we have that a man who was a sinner yesterday is still one today? The previous day must not judge the present day, nor the present day judge the previous day: only the last day should judge all the others.

We can never say, then, that a man is wicked without danger of lying. What we can say, if we must speak of it, is that he did such a bad action, that he lived badly at such a time, that he is doing wrong now. But no conclusion can be drawn from yesterday to today, nor from today to yesterday, and still less from today to tomorrow.

Although we must be extremely careful never to speak ill of our neighbour, we must still guard against another excess into which many fall, which is, in order to avoid slander, to praise vice. If there is a person who is truly a slanderer, do not say, to excuse her, that she is free and frank; if there is one who is plainly vain, do not say that she is noble and generous; dangerous familiarities, do not call them simplicity or naïveté; do not disguise disobedience under the name of zeal, nor arrogance under the name of frankness, nor impurity under the name of friendship.

No, dear Philothea, we must not, in fleeing the vice of slander, favour, flatter or nourish other vices, but we must speak plainly and frankly ill of evil, and blame blameworthy things; which will redound only to the glory of God, under the following conditions:

First, to be able to blame the vices of others, the benefit either of the one spoken of or of the one spoken to must require it. For example, someone tells young people about the indiscretions of certain men and women, which are plainly perilous; the disorderly conduct of such a man or such a woman, in words or actions that are plainly bad; if I do not openly blame this evil, and if I try to excuse it, these tender souls who are listening will take occasion from it to go on to something similar; their benefit therefore demands that I blame these things quite frankly and without delay, unless I can do so at a more opportune time, when the reputation of those spoken of will suffer less.

Second, I must have some obligation to speak on the subject; as if I am among the foremost of the company, so that my silence would pass for approval: but if I am among the least, I must not undertake to censure anything, but must be perfectly measured in my expressions, so as not to say a single word too many. If, for example, I blame the familiarities of this young man and this young woman, O God! Philothea, I must hold the scales very true, so as not to enlarge the thing by even a single hair: if there is only a faint appearance, I will say only that; if there is only a simple imprudence, I will say no more; if there is neither imprudence nor any real appearance of evil, but only something to give a malicious mind occasion to slander, I will either say nothing at all or say just that.

My tongue, while I speak of my neighbour, is in my mouth like a razor in the hand of the surgeon who wants to cut between the nerves and the tendons. The stroke I make must be so exact that I say neither more nor less than what is.

Finally, in blaming vice, we must take care to spare as much as we can the person in whom it is found. We may nevertheless speak freely of infamous, public and notorious sinners, provided it is with a spirit of charity and compassion, and not with arrogance and presumption, taking pleasure in the misfortune of others; for this last is the mark of a base and abject heart. I except from this rule the declared enemies of God and of His Church; for those must be decried as much as possible, such as the leaders of heresies and schisms; it is charity to cry wolf when the wolf is among the sheep, wherever it may be.

Everyone allows himself to judge and censure princes, and to speak ill of whole nations, according to the various feelings he has towards them. Philothea, do not commit this fault; for, besides offending God, you could bring a thousand troubles upon yourself.

When you hear your neighbour spoken ill of, make the accusation doubtful, if you can justly do so; if you cannot, excuse the intention of the accused; and if that is not possible, show compassion for his state; turn the dart aside, remembering and reminding the company that those who do not fall into fault owe it solely to the grace of God; recall the slanderer to himself in some gentle way, and say of the person offended all the good you know of him.

Source François de Sales, Introduction à la vie dévote (1609), Project Gutenberg #53540 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents