Catholicism

Confessions, Book Five, chapter V

The folly of Mani

Ah! who asked a Mani to write on subjects entirely foreign to the science of piety? You said to man: “Behold, knowledge is piety”; a knowledge he might have lacked while possessing human science; and he lacked even that, and he had the impudence to teach what he did not know; could he then be initiated into the science of the saints? It is vanity to profess the knowledge one has in the natural order; it is piety to confess Your name.

So this man was allowed to multiply his scientific ramblings, so that his ignorance, evident to the eyes of true scholars, might show the worth of his opinions on hidden things. He did not want to be thought little of, even seeking to make people believe that the Comforter, the Holy Spirit, who lavishes His heavenly riches on Your faithful, dwelt personally in him, in all the fullness of His authority. Thus, whenever he is caught in flagrant error about the sky, the stars, the movements of the sun and moon, although the doctrine of religion is in no way concerned, his presumption appears no less sacrilegious; for he utters not only ignorance but also falsehood, with such a frenzy of pride that he would authorize these discourses by the pretended divinity of his person.

Job, XXVIII, 28.

If one of my brothers in Jesus Christ is ignorant or in error regarding this knowledge, I bear his opinions with patience. Nothing in them hinders his progress; his ignorance of the situation and state of a bodily creature gives him no feeling unworthy of You, Lord, creator of all things. But it becomes harmful to him if he identifies it with the essential doctrines of piety, and if he stubbornly asserts what he does not know.

This feeble infancy, in the cradle of faith, finds in charity a mother who sustains it, “until the new man rises to that manly perfection which ceases to be tossed about by every wind of doctrine.” And this doctor, this guide, this master, this sovereign, bold enough to persuade his disciples that it was not a man but Your Holy Spirit they followed in him, who would not hold him a madman, whose folly, convicted of imposture, deserves only hatred and contempt?

Ephes., IV, 13, 14.

However, I was not yet sure that one could not explain according to his doctrine the variations in the length of days and nights, the very alternation of night and day, the eclipses of the heavenly bodies, and the other phenomena my reading had presented to me, so that, on doubtful points and in complete uncertainty, my faith in his holiness inclined my belief to his authority.

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents