Catholicism

Confessions, Book Seven, chapter II

Nebridius's objection against the Manichaeans.

It was enough for me, Lord, in order to confound those deceived deceivers and those mute chatterers, for their mouth is always mute for Your Word, it was enough for me to have the objection that Nebridius, at Carthage itself, used to put to them, and which had deeply stirred all those who, like me, had heard it. What could that nation of darkness, which they set against You like an enemy army, have done against You, he asked them, if You had not willed to fight against it?

If they answer that it could have harmed You, You are no longer either inviolable or incorruptible. If they grant that it was powerless, no reason can any longer be given for this struggle; a struggle so stubborn that a part of Yourself, one of Your members, an offspring of Your own substance, caught up among these hostile powers and natures independent of Your creation, is infected by such corruption that, cast down from beatitude into misery, it needs a deliverer and a purifier: now, if we are to believe them, this part of Yourself is the soul of man, which Your Word comes, free, to deliver from its chains; pure, from its defilements; whole, from its corruption, and yet corruptible itself, since it is one and the same substance with it and with You.

If, then, they acknowledge that whatever You are, that is, the substance by which You are, is incorruptible, all their hypotheses are false and odious. If they hold You to be corruptible, that alone is a blasphemy abominable to utter. It was enough to make one press one's breast in disgust and vomit out those pernicious teachers who, shut up in a circle from which they could not escape without a horrible sacrilege of heart and tongue, were condemned to think and speak thus of You.

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents