The difficulty he experiences in conceiving the origin of evil.
But while acknowledging You incapable of defilement, alteration and change, however firm I was in the belief that You are our Lord, true God, creator of our souls and our bodies, and not only of souls and bodies, but of every being and every thing, I did not yet grasp, however, the knot of the origin of evil. And yet, whatever it might be, I felt that I must conduct my reflections with enough prudence not to be so entangled in them as to find the immutable God subject to change, and not to let myself be caught by the object of my pursuit.
And I thought about it in safety, certain that there was nothing but error in the discourses of those men whom I fled with all my soul, because it was evident to me that they sought the cause of evil in a spirit of malice, preferring to believe Your substance capable of suffering it rather than their own capable of doing it.
And I applied myself to grasp this truth, often affirmed before me, that the free choice of the will is the cause of the evil of our actions, and the equity of Your judgments the cause of the evil of our sufferings. But here my feeble sight grew dim. In vain I labored to draw the eyes of my soul out of this abyss of darkness; I plunged into it again; and I renewed my efforts, and I kept plunging.
One thing lifted me a little toward Your light: I was no more certain that I lived than that I had a will. Thus, when I willed or did not will, I was entirely certain that it was none other than I who willed or did not will; and I already suspected that there lay the cause of my sin. As for the acts into which I was carried against my will, I felt that I was suffering rather than acting, and I presumed that it was less a fault than a punishment, by which I acknowledged myself justly struck, when I thought of Your justice.
But then I asked myself: Who made me? Is it not my God, who is good, who is goodness itself? Whence did it come to me to will evil, not to will good, my crime, my torment? Who then sowed and planted in me this seed of bitterness, I whose whole Being came from my supremely gentle God? If the devil is its author, whence is the devil himself the devil? And if, by the malice of his will, from an angel he became a demon, whence came to him that evil will which made him a devil, he whom his Creator, supremely good, had made an angel of goodness?
And these thoughts were a deadly weight that dragged me to the bottom, but nevertheless I did not go down to the gulf of horror where one no longer confesses You, where one subjects You to evil so as not to acknowledge the crime of man.