His doubts about the origin of evil.
And I sought the source of evil, and I sought it badly, and I did not see the evil in my very search, and I summoned before the eyes of my mind the whole of creation, and all that is visible in its extent, the earth, the sea, the air, the stars, the plants and the mortal animals; and all that is invisible, such as the firmament, the angels and the spiritual substances; and these very substances my imagination distributed in various places, as if they had been bodily beings.
And I made of Your creation one great mass, which I sorted by kinds of bodies, either real ones or those my error substituted for spirits. And this mass I pictured as immense, not according to its real immensity, which I could not possibly reach, but according to the sole limits that my imagination assigned to it. And I pictured it, Lord, surrounded and penetrated on every side by Your essence; and I imagined a sea without bottom and without shore, alone in the infinite, which would contain a sponge of finite immensity, wholly filled with the immense sea.
Thus I believed Your creatures finite, filled with Your infinity, and I said to myself: Here is God, there are His creatures, God who is good, infinitely better than they, but whose Goodness could make them only good, and it is thus that He surrounds and fills them. Where then is evil, where does it come from, and by what way did it creep in? what is its root? what is its seed? But perhaps it does not exist? Why then do we dread, why do we flee what does not exist?
And if our fear is vain, that very fear is an evil; it is an evil, this nothingness that stirs and torments our heart, an evil all the more painful since, with less reason to fear, it delivers us over to fear. So then, either we have the fear of evil, or we have the evil of fear.
And where does this come from? For God, who is all good, has made nothing but what is good. He is the sovereign Good; His creatures, it is true, are only diminished participations in His goodness; but nevertheless, Creator and creatures, all is good. Where, then, does evil proceed from? Is it from the matter He worked with? Perhaps, when He gave it form and order, it concealed an evil element, which He left there without converting it into good.
And why? Was He powerless to convert, to change the essence of this matter, so that no trace of evil would remain in it, He who is almighty? Why did He wish to make something out of such matter, and why, with this almighty power, did He not rather reduce it to nothing? Could it, then, exist against His will? And if it was eternal, why did He leave it so through infinite stretches of past time, and decide so late to make something of it?
And if a sudden will to act came to Him, why did He not rather make it cease to be, so that He alone might be, as the true, sovereign, infinite Good? Or finally, if it was not good that the hand of Him who is all good should remain barren of good work, ought He not to have dispersed this evil matter and returned it to nothingness, so as to establish a good one, from which He would have created all things? for He would not be almighty if He could make nothing good except with the help of this matter that He Himself had not made.
And such were the thoughts that my poor heart turned over, heavy with all the gnawing cares with which the fear of death and the sadness of not having found the truth pierced it. And yet I bore rooted in my soul the faith of the Catholic Church in Your Christ, our Savior and Master; and although it was still in many respects unformed and wavering against the rule of doctrine, it nevertheless held fast in my mind, and took hold there more each day.