Hinduism

Jnana-Yoga — Unity in Diversity

( Delivered in London, 3rd November 1896 )

"The Self-existent One projected the senses outwards and, therefore, a man

looks outward, not within himself. A certain wise one, desiring immortality,

with inverted senses, perceived the Self within." As I have already said,

the first inquiry that we find in the Vedas was concerning outward things,

and then a new idea came that the reality of things is not to be found in

the external world; not by looking outwards, but by turning the eyes, as it

is literally expressed, inwards. And the word used for the Soul is very

significant: it is He who has gone inward, the innermost reality of our

being, the heart centre, the core, from which, as it were, everything comes

out; the central sun of which the mind, the body, the sense-organs, and

everything else we have are but rays going outwards. "Men of childish

intellect, ignorant persons, run after desires which are external, and enter

the trap of far-reaching death, but the wise, understanding immortality,

never seek for the Eternal in this life of finite things." The same idea is

here made clear that in this external world, which is full of finite things,

it is impossible to see and find the Infinite. The Infinite must be sought

in that alone which is infinite, and the only thing infinite about us is

that which is within us, our own soul. Neither the body, nor the mind, not

even our thoughts, nor the world we see around us, are infinite. The Seer,

He to whom they all belong, the Soul of man, He who is awake in the internal

man, alone is infinite, and to seek for the Infinite Cause of this whole

universe we must go there. In the Infinite Soul alone we can find it. "What

is here is there too, and what is there is here also. He who sees the

manifold goes from death to death." We have seen how at first there was the

desire to go to heaven. When these ancient Aryans became dissatisfied with

the world around them, they naturally thought that after death they would go

to some place where there would be all happiness without any misery; these

places they multiplied and called Svargas — the word may be translated as

heavens — where there would be joy for ever, the body would become perfect,

and also the mind, and there they would live with their forefathers. But as

soon as philosophy came, men found that this was impossible and absurd. The

very idea of an infinite in place would be a contradiction in terms, as a

place must begin and continue in time. Therefore they had to give up that

idea. They found out that the gods who lived in these heavens had once been

human beings on earth, who through their good works had become gods, and the

godhoods, as they call them, were different states, different positions;

none of the gods spoken of in the Vedas are permanent individuals.

For instance, Indra and Varuna are not the names of certain persons, but the

names of positions as governors and so on. The Indra who had lived before is

not the same person as the Indra of the present day; he has passed away, and

another man from earth has filled his place. So with all the other gods

These are certain positions, which are filled successively by human souls

who have raised themselves to the condition of gods, and yet even they die.

In the old Rig-Veda we find the word "immortality" used with regard to these

gods, but later on it is dropped entirely, for they found that immortality

which is beyond time and space cannot be spoken of with regard to any

physical form, however subtle it may be. However fine it may be, it must

have a beginning in time and space, for the necessary factors that enter

into the make-up of form are in space. Try to think of a form without

space: it is impossible. Space is one of the materials, as it were, which

make up the form, and this is continually changing Space and time are in

Maya, and this idea is expressed in the line — "What is hole, that is there

too." If there are these gods, they must be bound by the same laws that

apply here, and all laws involve destruction and renewal again and again.

These laws are moulding matter into different forms, and crushing them out

again. Everything born must die; and so, if there are heavens, the same laws

must hold good there.

In this world we find that all happiness is followed by misery as its

shadow. Life has its shadow, death. They must go together, because they are

not contradictory, not two separate existences, but different manifestations

of the same unit, life and death, sorrow and happiness, good and evil. The

dualistic conception that good and evil are two separate entities, and that

they are both going on eternally is absurd on the face of it. They are the

diverse manifestations of one and the same fact, one time appearing as bad,

and at another time as good. The difference does not exist in kind, but only

in degree. They differ from each other in degree of intensity. We find as a

fact that the same nerve systems carry good and bad sensations alike, and

when the nerves are injured, neither sensation comes to us. If a certain

nerve is paralysed, we do not get the pleasurable feelings that used to come

along that wires and at the same time we do not get the painful feelings

either. They are never two, but the same. Again. the same thing produces

pleasure and pain at different times of life. The same phenomenon will

produce pleasure in one, and pain in another. The eating of meat produces

pleasure to a man, but pain to the animal which is eaten. There has never

been anything which gives pleasure to all alike. Some are pleased, others

displeased. So on it will go. Therefore, this duality of existence is

denied. And what follows? I told you in my last lecture that we can never

have ultimately everything good on this earth and nothing bad. It may have

disappointed and frightened some of you, but I cannot help it, and I am open

to conviction when I am shown to the contrary; but until that can be proved

to me, and I can find that it is true, cannot say so.

The general argument against my statement, and apparently a very convincing

one, is this that in the course of evolution, all that is evil in what we

see around us is gradually being eliminated, and the result is that if this

elimination continues for millions of years, a time will come when all the

evil will have been extirpated, and the good alone will remain. This is

apparently a very sound argument. Would to God it were true! But there is a

fallacy in it, and it is this that it takes for granted that both good and

evil are things that are eternally fixed. It takes for granted that there is

a definite mass of evil, which may be represented by a hundred, and likewise

of good, and that this mass of evil is being diminished every day, leaving

only the good. But is it so? The history of the world shows that evil is a

continuously increasing quantity, as well as good. Take the lowest man; he

lives in the forest. His sense of enjoyment is very small, and so also is

his power to suffer. His misery is entirely on the sense-plane. If he does

not get plenty of food, he is miserable; but give him plenty of food and

freedom to rove and to hunt, and he is perfectly happy. His happiness

consists only in the senses, and so does his misery also. But if that man

increases in knowledge, his happiness will increase, the intellect will open

to him, and his sense-enjoyment will evolve into intellectual enjoyment. He

will feel pleasure in reading a beautiful poem, and a mathematical problem

will be of absorbing interest to him. But, with these, the inner nerves will

become more and more susceptible to miseries of mental pain, of which the

savage does not think. Take a very simple illustration. In Tibet there is no

marriage, and there is no jealousy, yet we know that marriage is a much

higher state. The Tibetans have not known the wonderful enjoyment, the

blessing of chastity, the happiness of having a chaste, virtuous wife, or a

chaste, virtuous husband. These people cannot feel that. And similarly they

do not feel the intense jealousy of the chaste wife or husband, or the

misery caused by unfaithfulness on either side, with all the heart-burnings

and sorrows which believers in chastity experience. On one side, the latter

gain happiness, but on the other, they suffer misery too.

Take your country which is the richest in the world, and which is more

luxurious than any other, and see how intense is the misery, how many more

lunatics you have, compared with other races, only because the desires are

so keen. A man must keep up a high standard of living, and the amount of

money he spends in one year would be a fortune to a man in India. You cannot

preach to him of simple living because society demands so much of him. The

wheel of society is rolling on; it stops not for the widow's tears or the

orphans' wails. This is the state of things everywhere. Your sense of

enjoyment is developed, your society is very much more beautiful than some

others. You have so many more things to enjoy. But those who have fewer have

much less misery. You can argue thus throughout, the higher the ideal you

have in the brain, the greater is your enjoyment, and the more profound your

misery. One is like the shadow of the other. That the evils are being

eliminated may be true, but if so, the good also must be dying out. But are

not evils multiplying fast, and good diminishing, if I may so put it? If

good increases in arithmetical progression, evil increase in geometrical

progression. And this is Maya. This is neither optimism nor pessimism.

Vedanta does not take he position that this world is only a miserable one.

That would be untrue. At the same time, it is a mistake to say that this

world is full of happiness and blessings. So it is useless to tell children

that this world is all good, all flowers, all milk and honey. That is what

we have all dreamt. At the same time it is erroneous to think, because one

man has suffered more than another, that all is evil. It is this duality,

this play of good and evil that makes our world of experiences. At the same

time the Vedanta says, "Do not think that good and evil are two, are two

separate essences, for they are one and the same thing, appearing in

different degrees and in different guises and producing differences of

feeling in the same mind." So, the first thought of the Vedanta is the

finding of unity in the external; the One Existence manifesting Itself,

however different It may appear in manifestation. Think of the old crude

theory of the Persians — two gods creating this world, the good God doing

everything that is good, and the bad one, everything bad. On the very face

of it, you see the absurdity, for if it be carried out, every law of nature

must have two parts, one of which is manipulated by one god, and then he

goes away and the other God manipulates the other part. There the difficulty

comes that both are working in the same world, and these two gods keep

themselves in harmony by injuring one portion and doing good to another.

This is a crude case, of course, the crudest way of expressing the duality

of existence. But, take the more advanced, the more abstract theory that

this world is partly good and partly bad. This also is absurd, arguing from

the same standpoint. It is the law of unity that gives us our food, and it

is the same law that kills many through accidents or misadventure.

We find, then, that this world is neither optimistic nor pessimistic; it is

a mixture of both, and as we go on we shall find that the whole blame is

taken away from nature and put upon our own shoulders. At the same time the

Vedanta shows the way out, but not by denial of evil, because it analyses

boldly the fact as it is and does not seek to conceal anything. It is not

hopeless; it is not agnostic. It finds out a remedy, but it wants to place

that remedy on adamantine foundations: not by shutting the child's mouth and

blinding its eyes with something which is untrue, and which the child will

find out in a few days. I remember when I was young, a young man's father

died and left him poorly off, with a large family to support, and he found

that his father's friends were unwilling to help him. He had a conversation

with a clergyman who offered this consolation, "Oh, it is all good, all is

sent for our good." That is the old method of trying to put a piece of gold

leaf on an old sore. It is a confession of weakness, of absurdity. The young

man went away, and six months afterwards a son was born to the clergyman,

and he gave a thanksgiving party to which the young man was invited. The

clergyman prayed, "Thank God for His mercies." And the young man stood up

and said, "Stop, this is all misery." The clergyman asked, "Why?" "Because

when my father died you said it was good, though apparently evil; so now,

this is apparently good, but really evil." Is this the way to cure the

misery of the world? Be good and have mercy on those who suffer. Do not try

to patch it up, nothing will cure this world; go beyond it.

This is a world of good and evil. Wherever there is good, evil follows, but

beyond and behind all these manifestations, all these contradictions, the

Vedanta finds out that Unity. It says, "Give up what is evil and give up

what is good." What remains then? Behind good and evil stands something

which is yours, the real you, beyond every evil, and beyond every good too,

and it is that which is manifesting itself as good and bad. Know that first,

and then and then alone you will be a true optimist, and not before; for

then you will be able to control everything. Control these manifestations

and you will be at liberty to manifest the real "you". First be master of

yourself, stand up and be free, go beyond the pale of these laws, for these

laws do not absolutely govern you, they are only part of your being. First

find out that you are not the slave of nature, never were and never will be;

that this nature, infinite as you may think it, is only finite, a drop in

the ocean, and your Soul is the ocean; you are beyond the stars, the sun,

and the moon. They are like mere bubbles compared with your infinite being. Know

that, and you will control both good and evil. Then alone the whole vision

will change and you will stand up and say, "How beautiful is good and how

wonderful is evil!"

That is what the Vedanta teaches. It does not propose any slipshod remedy by

covering wounds with gold leaf and the more the wound festers, putting on

more gold leaf. This life is a hard fact; work your way through it boldly,

though it may be adamantine; no matter, the soul is stronger. It lays no

responsibility on little gods; for you are the makers of your own fortunes.

You make yourselves suffer, you make good and evil, and it is you who put

your hands before your eyes and say it is dark. Take your hands away and see

the light; you are effulgent, you are perfect already, from the very

beginning. We now understand the verse: "He goes from death to death who

sees the many here." See that One and be free.

How are we to see it? This mind, so deluded, so weak, so easily led, even

this mind can be strong and may catch a glimpse of that knowledge, that

Oneness, which saves us from dying again and again. As rain falling upon a

mountain flows in various streams down the sides of the mountain, so all the

energies which you see here are from that one Unit. It has become manifold

falling upon Maya. Do not run after the manifold; go towards the One. "He is

in all that moves; He is in all that is pure; He fills the universe; He is

in the sacrifice; He is the guest in the house; He is in man, in water, in

animals, in truth; He is the Great One. As fire coming into this world is

manifesting itself in various forms, even so, that one Soul of the universe

is manifesting Himself in all these various forms. As air coming into this

universe manifests itself in various forms, even so, the One Soul of all

souls, of all beings, is manifesting Himself in all forms." This is true for

you when you have understood this Unity, and not before Then is all

optimism, because He is seen everywhere. The question is that if all this be

true that that Pure One — the Self, the Infinite — has entered all this, how

is it that He suffers, how is it that He becomes miserable, impure? He does

not, says the Upanishad. "As the sun is the cause of the eyesight of every

being, yet is not made defective by the defect in any eye, even so the Self

of all is not affected by the miseries of the body, or by any misery that is

around you." I may have some disease and see everything yellow, but the sun

is not affected by it. "He is the One, the Creator of all, the Ruler of all,

the Internal Soul of every being — He who makes His Oneness manifold. Thus

sages who realise Him as the Soul of their souls, unto them belongs eternal

peace; unto none else, unto none else. He who in this world of evanescence

finds Him who never changes, he who in this universe of death finds that One

Life, he who in this manifold finds that Oneness, and all those who realise

Him as the Soul of their souls, to them belongs eternal peace; unto none

else, unto none else. Where to find Him in the external world, where to find

Him in the suns, and moons, and stars? There the sun cannot illumine, nor

the moon, nor the stars, the flash of lightning cannot illumine the place;

what to speak of this mortal fire? He shining, everything else shines. It is

His light that they have borrowed, and He is shining through them." Here is

another beautiful simile. Those of you who have been in India and have seen

how the banyan tree comes from one root and spreads itself far around, will

understand this. He is that banyan tree; He is the root of all and has

branched out until He has become this universe, and however far He extends,

every one of these trunks and branches is connected.

Various heavens are spoken of in the Brâhmana portions of the Vedas, but the

philosophical teaching of the Upanishads gives up the idea of going to

heaven. Happiness is not in this heaven or in that heaven, it is in the

soul; places do not signify anything. Here is another passage which shows

the different states of realisation "In the heaven of the forefathers, as a

man sees things in a dream, so the Real Truth is seen." As in dreams we see

things hazy and not so distinct, so we see the Reality there. There is

another heaven called the Gandharva, in which it is still less clear; as a

man sees his own reflection in the water, so is the Reality seen there. The

highest heaven, of which the Hindus conceive is called the Brahmaloka; and

in this, the Truth is seen much more clearly, like light and shade, but not

yet quite distinctly. But as a man sees his own face in a mirror, perfect,

distinct, and clear, so is the Truth shining in the soul of man. The highest

heaven, therefore, is in our own souls; the greatest temple of worship is

the human soul, greater than all heavens, says the Vedanta; for in no heaven

anywhere, can we understand the reality as distinctly and clearly as in this

life, in our own soul. Changing places does not help one much. I thought

while I was in India that the cave would give me clearer vision. I found it

was not so. Then I thought the forest would do so, then, Varanasi. But the

same difficulty existed everywhere, because we make our own worlds. If I am

evil, the whole world is evil to me. That is what the Upanishad says. And

the same thing applies to all worlds. If I die and go to heaven, I should

find the same, for until I am pure it is no use going to caves, or forests,

or to Varanasi, or to heaven, and if I have polished my mirror, it does not

matter where I live, I get the Reality just as It is. So it is useless,

running hither and thither, and spending energy in vain, which should be

spent only in polishing the mirror. The same idea is expressed again: "None

sees Him, none sees His form with the eyes. It is in the mind, in the pure

mind, that He is seen, and this immortality is gained."

Those who were at the summer lectures on Râja-Yoga will be interested to

know that what was taught then was a different kind of Yoga. The Yoga which

we are now considering consists chiefly in controlling the senses. When the

senses are held as slaves by the human soul, when they can no longer disturb

the mind, then the Yogi has reached the goal. "When all vain desires of the

heart have been given up, then this very mortal becomes immortal, then he

becomes one with God even here. When all the knots of the heart are cut

asunder, then the mortal becomes immortal, and he enjoys Brahman here."

Here, on this earth, nowhere else.

A few words ought to be said here. You will generally hear that this

Vedanta, this philosophy and other Eastern systems, look only to something

beyond, letting go the enjoyments and struggle of this life. This idea is

entirely wrong. It is only ignorant people who do not know anything of

Eastern thought, and never had brain enough to understand anything of its

real teaching, that tell you so. On the contrary, we read in our scriptures

that our philosophers do not want to go to other worlds, but depreciate them

as places where people weep and laugh for a little while only and then die.

As long as we are weak we shall have to go through these experiences; but

whatever is true, is here, and that is the human soul. And this also is

insisted upon, that by committing suicide, we cannot escape the inevitable;

we cannot evade it. But the right path is hard to find. The Hindu is just as

practical as the Western, only we differ in our views of life. The one says,

build a good house, let us have good clothes and food, intellectual culture,

and so on, for this is the whole of life; and in that he is immensely

practical. But the Hindu says, true knowledge of the world means knowledge

of the soul, metaphysics; and he wants to enjoy that life. In America there

was a great agnostic, a very noble man, a very good man, and a very fine

speaker. He lectured on religion, which he said was of no use; why bother

our heads about other worlds? He employed this simile; we have an orange

here, and we want to squeeze all the juice out of it. I met him once and

said, "I agree with you entirely. I have some fruit, and I too want to

squeeze out the juice. Our difference lies in the choice of the fruit. You

want an orange, and I prefer a mango. You think it is enough to live here

and eat and drink and have a little scientific knowledge; but you have no

right to say that that will suit all tastes. Such a conception is nothing to

me. If I had only to learn how an apple falls to the ground, or how an

electric current shakes my nerves, I would commit suicide. I want to

understand the heart of things, the very kernel itself. Your study is the

manifestation of life, mine is the life itself. My philosophy says you must

know that and drive out from your mind all thoughts of heaven and hell and

all other superstitions, even though they exist in the same sense that this

world exists. I must know the heart of this life, its very essence, what it

is, not only how it works and what are its manifestations. I want the why of

everything, I leave the how to children. As one of your countrymen said,

'While I am smoking a cigarette, if I were to write a book, it would be the

science of the cigarette.' It is good and great to be scientific, God bless

them in their search; but when a man says that is all, he is talking

foolishly, not caring to know the raison d'être of life, never studying

existence itself. I may argue that all your knowledge is nonsense, without a

basis. You are studying the manifestations of life, and when I ask you what

life is, you say you do not know. You are welcome to your study, but leave

me to mine."

I am practical, very practical, in my own way. So your idea that only the

West is practical is nonsense. You are practical in one way, and I in

another. There are different types of men and minds. If in the East a man is

told that he will find out the truth by standing on one leg all his life, he

will pursue that method. If in the West men hear that there is a gold mine

somewhere in an uncivilised country, thousands will face the dangers there,

in the hope of getting the gold; and, perhaps, only one succeeds. The same

men have heard that they have souls but are content to leave the care of

them to the church. The first man will not go near the savages, he says it

may be dangerous. But if we tell him that on the top of a high mountain

lives a wonderful sage who can give him knowledge of the soul, he tries to

climb up to him, even if he be killed in the attempt. Both types of men are

practical, but the mistake lies in regarding this world as the whole of

life. Yours is the vanishing point of enjoyment of the senses — there is

nothing permanent in it, it only brings more and more misery — while mine

brings eternal peace.

I do not say your view is wrong, you are welcome to it. Great good and

blessing come out of it, but do not, therefore, condemn my view. Mine also

is practical in its own way. Let us all work on our own plans. Would to God

all of us were equally practical on both sides. I have seen some scientists

who were equally practical, both as scientists and as spiritual men, and it

is my great hope that in course of time the whole of humanity will be

efficient in the same manner. When a kettle of water is coming to the boil,

if you watch the phenomenon, you find first one bubble rising, and then

another and so on, until at last they all join, and a tremendous commotion

takes place. This world is very similar. Each individual is like a bubble,

and the nations, resemble many bubbles. Gradually these nations are joining,

and I am sure the day will come when separation will vanish and that Oneness

to which we are all going will become manifest. A time must come when every

man will be as intensely practical in the scientific world as in the

spiritual, and then that Oneness, the harmony of Oneness, will pervade the

whole world. The whole of mankind will become Jivanmuktas — free whilst

living. We are all struggling towards that one end through our jealousies

and hatreds, through our love and co-operation. A tremendous stream is

flowing towards the ocean carrying us all along with it; and though like

straws and scraps of paper we may at times float aimlessly about, in the

long run we are sure to join the Ocean of Life and Bliss.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 2, en.wikisource.org · Contents