Hinduism

Practical Vedanta and other lectures — A study of the Sankhya philosophy

Prakriti is called by the Sânkhya philosophers indiscrete, and defined as

the perfect balance of the materials in it; and it naturally follows that in

perfect balance there cannot be any motion. In the primal state before any

manifestation, when there was no motion but perfect balance, this Prakriti

was indestructible, because decomposition or death comes from instability or

change. Again, according to the Sankhya, atoms are not the primal state.

This universe does not come out of atoms: they may be the secondary or the

tertiary state. The primordial material may form into atoms and become

grosser and bigger things; and as far as modern investigations go, they

rather point towards the same conclusion. For instance, in the modern theory

of ether, if you say ether is atomic, it will not solve anything. To make it

clearer, say that air is composed of atoms, and we know that ether is

everywhere, interpenetrating, omnipresent, and that these air atoms are

floating, as it were, in ether. If ether again be composed of atoms, there

will still be spaces between every two atoms of ether. What fills up these?

If you suppose that there is another ether still finer which does this,

there will again be other spaces between the atoms of that finer ether which

require filling up, and so it will be regressus ad infinitum, what the

Sankhya philosophers call the "cause leading to nothing" So the atomic

theory cannot be final. According to Sankhya, nature is omnipresent, one

omnipresent mass of nature, in which are the causes of everything that

exists. What is meant by cause? Cause is the fine state of the manifested

state; the unmanifested state of that which becomes manifested. What do you

mean by destruction? It is reverting to the cause If you have a piece of

pottery and give it a blow, it is destroyed. What is meant by this is that

the effects go back to their own nature, they materials out of which the

pottery was created go back into their original state. Beyond this idea of

destruction, any idea such as annihilation is on the face of it absurd.

According to modern physical science, it can be demonstrated that all

destruction means that which Kapila said ages ago — simply reverting to the

cause. Going back to the finer form is all that is meant by destruction. You

know how it can be demonstrated in a laboratory that matter is

indestructible. At this present stage of our knowledge, if any man stands up

and says that matter or this soul becomes annihilated, he is only making

himself, ridiculous; it is only uneducated, silly people who would advance

such a proposition; and it is curious that modern knowledge coincides with

what those old philosophers taught. It must be so, and that is the proof of

truth. They proceeded in their inquiry, taking up mind as the basis; they

analysed the mental part of this universe and came to certain conclusions,

which we, analysing the physical part, must come to, for they both must lead

to the same centre.

You must remember that the first manifestation of this Prakriti in the

cosmos is what the Sankhya calls "Mahat". We may call it intelligence — the

great principle, its literal meaning. The first change in Prakriti is this

intelligence; I would not translate it by self-consciousness, because that

would be wrong. Consciousness is only a part of this intelligence. Mahat is

universal. It covers all the grounds of sub-consciousness, consciousness,

and super-consciousness; so any one state of consciousness, as applied to

this Mahat, would not be sufficient. In nature, for instance, you note

certain changes going on before your eyes which you see and understand, but

there are other changes, so much finer, that no human perception can catch

them. The are from the same cause, the same Mahat is making these changes.

Out of Mahat comes universal egoism. These are all substance. There is no

difference between matter and mind, except in degree. The substance is the

same in finer or grosser form; one changes into the other, and this exactly

coincides with the conclusions of modern physiological research. By

believing in the teaching that the mind is not separate from the brain, you

will be saved from much fighting and struggling. Egoism again changes into

two varieties. In one variety it changes into the organs. Organs are of two

kinds, organs of sensation and organs of reaction. They are not the eyes or

the ears, but back of those are what you call brain-centres, and

nerve-centres, and so on. This egoism, this matter or substance, becomes

changed, and out of this material are manufactured these centres. Of the

same substance is manufactured the other variety, the Tanmatras, fine

particles of matter, which strike our organs of perception and bring about

sensations. You cannot perceive them but only know they are there. Out of

the Tanmatras is manufactured the gross matter — earth, water, and all the

things that we see and feel. I want to impress this on your mind. It is

very, hard to grasp it, because in Western countries the ideas are so queer

about mind and matter. It is hard to get those impressions out of our

brains. I myself had a tremendous difficulty, being educated in Western

philosophy in my boyhood. These are all cosmic things. Think of this

universal extension of matter, unbroken, one substance, undifferentiated,

which is the first state of everything, and which begins to change in the

same way as milk becomes curd. This first change is called Mahat. The

substance Mahat changes into the grosser matter called egoism. The third

change is manifested as universal sense-organs, and universal fine

particles, and these last again combine and become this gross universe which

with eyes, nose, and ears, we see, smell, and hear. This is the cosmic plan

according to the Sankhya, and what is in the cosmos must also be

microcosmic. Take an individual man. He has first a part of undifferentiated

nature in him, and that material nature in him becomes changed into this

Mahat, a small particle of this universal intelligence, and this particle of

universal intelligence in him becomes changed into egoism, and then into the

sense-organs and the fine particles of matter which combine and manufacture

his body. I want this to be clear, because it is the stepping-stone to

Sankhya, and it is absolutely necessary for you to understand it, because

this is the basis of the philosophy of the whole world. There is no

philosophy in the world that is not indebted to Kapila. Pythagoras came to

India and studied this philosophy, and that was the beginning of the

philosophy of the Greeks. Later, it formed the Alexandrian school, and still

later, the Gnostic. It became divided into two; one part went to Europe and

Alexandria, and the other remained in India; and out of this, the system of

Vyasa was developed. The Sankhya philosophy of Kapila was the first rational

system that the world ever saw. Every metaphysician in the world must pay

homage to him. I want to impress on your mind that we are bound to listen to

him as the great father of philosophy. This wonderful man, the most ancient

of philosophers, is mentioned even in the Shruti: "O Lord, Thou who produced

the sage Kapila in the Beginning." How wonderful his perceptions were, and

if there is ant proof required of the extraordinary power of the perception

of Yogis, such men are the proof. They had no microscopes or telescopes. Yet

how fine their perception was, how perfect and wonderful their analysis of

things!

I will here point out the difference between Schopenhauer and the Indian

philosophy. Schopenhauer says that desire, or will, is the cause of

everything. It is the will to exist that make us manifest, but we deny this.

The will is identical with the motor nerves. When I see an object there is

no will; when its sensations are carried to the brain, there comes the

reaction, which says "Do this", or "Do not do this", and this state of the

ego-substance is what is called will. There cannot be a single particle of

will which is not a reaction. So many things precede will. It is only a

manufactured something out of the ego, and the ego is a manufacture of

something still higher — the intelligence — and that again is a modification

of the indiscrete nature. That was the Buddhistic idea, that whatever we see

is the will. It is psychologically entirely wrong, because will can only be

identified with the motor nerves. If you take out the motor nerves, a man

has no will whatever. This fact, as is perhaps well known to you, has been

found out after a long series of experiments made with the lower animals.

We will take up this question. It is very important to understand this

question of Mahat in man, the great principle, the intelligence. This

intelligence itself is modified into what we call egoism, and this

intelligence is the cause of all the powers in the body. It covers the whole

ground, sub-consciousness, consciousness, and super-consciousness. What are

these three states? The sub-conscious state we find in animals, which we

call instinct. This is almost infallible, but very limited. Instinct rarely

fails. An animal almost instinctively knows a poisonous herb from an edible

one, but its instinct is very limited. As soon as something new comes, it is

blind. It works like a machine. Then comes a higher state of knowledge which

is fallible and makes mistakes often, but has a larger scope, although it is

slow, and this you call reason. It is much larger than instinct, but

instinct is surer than reason. There are more chances of mistakes in

reasoning than in instinct. There is a still higher state of the mind, the

super-conscious, which belongs only to Yogis, to men who have cultivated it.

This is infallible and much more unlimited in its scope than reason. This is

the highest state. So we must remember, this Mahat is the real cause of all

that is here, that which manifests itself in various ways, covers the whole

ground of sub-conscious, conscious, and super-conscious, the three states in

which knowledge exists.

Now comes a delicate question which is being always asked. If a perfect God

created the universe, why is there imperfection in it? What we call the

universe is what we see, and that is only this little plane of consciousness

and reason; beyond that we do not see at all. Now the very question is an

impossible one. If I take only a small portion out of a mass of something

and look at it, it seems to be inharmonious. Naturally. The universe is

inharmonious because we make it so. How? What is reason? What is knowledge?

Knowledge is finding the association about things. You go into the street

and see a man and say, I know this is a man; because you remember the

impressions on your mind, the marks on the Chitta. You have seen many men,

and each one has made an impression on your mind; and as you see this man,

you refer this to your store and see many similar pictures there; and when

you see them, you are satisfied, and you put this new one with the rest.

When a new impression comes and it has associations in your mind, you are

satisfied; and this state of association is called knowledge. Knowledge is,

therefore, pigeon-holing one experience with the already existing fund of

experience, and this is one of the great proofs of the fact that you cannot

have any knowledge until you have already a fund in existence. If you are

without experience, as some European philosophers think, and that your mind

is a tabula rasa to begin with, you cannot get any knowledge, because the

very fact of knowledge is the recognition of the new by means of

associations already existing in the mind. There must be a store at hand to

which to refer a new impression. Suppose a child is born into this world

without such a fund, it would be impossible for him ever to get any

knowledge. Therefore, the child must have been previously in a state in

which he had a fund, and so knowledge is eternally increasing. Slow me a way

of getting round this argument. It is a mathematical fact. Some Western

schools of philosophy also hold that there cannot be any knowledge without a

fund of past knowledge. They have framed the idea that the child is born

with knowledge. These Western philosophers say that the impressions with

which the child comes into the world are not due to the child's past, but to

the experiences of his forefathers: it is only hereditary transmission. Soon

they will find out that this idea is all wrong; some German philosophers are

now giving hard blows to these heredity ideas. Heredity is very good, but

incomplete, it only explains the physical side. How do you explain the

environments influencing us? Many causes produce one effect. Environment is

one of the modifying effects. We make our own environment: as our past is,

so we find the present environment. A drunken man naturally gravitates to

the lowest slums of the city.

You understand what is meant by knowledge. Knowledge is pigeon-holing a new

impression with old ones, recognising a new impression. What is meant by

recognition? Finding associations with similar impressions that one already

has. Nothing further is meant by knowledge. If that is the case, if

knowledge means finding the associations, then it must be that to know

anything we have to set the whole series of its similars. Is it not so?

Suppose you take a pebble; to find the association, you have to see the

whole series of pebbles similes to it. But with our perception of the

universe as a whole we cannot do that, because in the pigeon-hole of our

mind there is only one single record of the perception, we have no other

perception of the same nature or class, we cannot compare it with any other.

We cannot refer it to its associations. This bit of the universe, cut off by

our consciousness, is a startling new thing, because we have not been able

to find its associations. Therefore, we are struggling with it, and thinking

it horrible, wicked, and bad; we may sometimes think it is good, but we

always think it is imperfect. It is only when we find its associations that

the universe can be known. We shall recognise it when we go beyond the

universe and consciousness, and then the universe will stand explained.

Until we can do that, all the knocking of our heads against a wall will

never explain the universe, because knowledge is the finding of similars,

and this conscious plane only gives us one single perception of it. So with

our idea of God. All that we see of God is only a part just as we see only

one portion of the universe, and all the rest is beyond human cognition. "I,

the universal; so great am I that even this universe is but a part of Me."

That is why we see God as imperfect, and do not understand Him. The only way

to understand Him and the universe is to go beyond reason, beyond

consciousness. "When thou goest beyond the heard and the hearing, the

thought and the thinking, then alone wilt thou come to Truth." "Go thou

beyond the scriptures, because they teach only up to nature, up to the three

qualities." When we go beyond them, we find the harmony, and not before.

The microcosm and the macrocosm are built on exactly the same plan, and in

the microcosm we know only one part, the middle part. We know neither the

sub-conscious, nor the super-conscious. We know the conscious only. If a man

stands up and says, "I am a sinner", he makes an untrue statement because he

does not know himself. He is the most ignorant of men; of himself he knows

only one part, because his knowledge covers only a part of the ground he is

on. So with this universe, it is possible to know only a part of it with the

reason, not the whole of it; for the sub-conscious, the conscious and the

super-conscious, the individual Mahat and the universal Mahat, and all the

subsequent modifications, constitute the universe.

What makes nature (Prakriti) change? We see so far that everything, all

Prakriti, is Jada, insentient. It is all compound and insentient. Wherever

there is law, it is proof that the region of its play is insentient. Mind,

intelligence, will, and everything else is insentient. But they are all

reflecting the sentiency, the "Chit" of some being who is beyond all this,

whom the Sankhya philosophers call "Purusha". The Purusha is the unwitting

cause of all the changes in the universe. That is to say, this Purusha,

taking Him in the universal sense, is the God of the universe. It is said

that the will of the Lord created the universe. It is very good as a common

expression, but we see it cannot be true. How could it be will? Will is the

third or fourth manifestation in nature. Many things exist before it, and

what created them? Will is a compound, and everything that is a compound is

a product of nature. Will, therefore, could not create nature. So, to say

that the will of the Lord created the universe is meaningless. Our will only

covers a little portion of self-consciousness and moves our brain. It is not

will that is working your body or that is working the universe. This body is

being moved by a power of which will is only a manifestation in one part.

Likewise in the universe there is will, but that is only one part of the

universe. The whole of the universe is not guided by will; that is why we

cannot explain it by the will theory. Suppose I take it for granted that it

is will moving the body, then, when I find I cannot work it at will, I begin

to fret and fume. It is my fault, because I had no right to take the will

theory for granted. In the same way, if I take the universe and think it is

will that moves it and find things which do not coincide, it is my fault. So

the Purusha is not will; neither can it be intelligence, because

intelligence itself is a compound. There cannot be any intelligence without

some sort of matter corresponding to the brain. Wherever there is

intelligence, there must be something akin to that matter which we call

brain which becomes lumped together into a particular form and serves the

purpose of the brain. Wherever there is intelligence, there must be that

matter in some form or other. But intelligence itself is a compound. What

then is this Purusha? It is neither intelligence nor will, but it is the

cause of all these. It is its presence that sets them all going and

combining. It does not mix with nature; it is not intelligence, or Mahat;

but the Self, the pure, is Purusha. "I am the witness, and through my

witnessing, nature is producing; all that is sentient and all that is

insentient."

What is this sentiency in nature? We find intelligence is this sentiency

which is called Chit. The basis of sentiency is in the Purusha, it is the

nature of Purusha. It is that which cannot be explained but which is the

cause of all that we call knowledge. Purusha is not consciousness, because

consciousness is a compound; buts whatever is light and good in

consciousness belongs to Purusha. Purusha is not conscious, but whatever is

light in intelligence belongs to Purusha. Sentiency is in the Purusha, but

the Purusha is not intelligent, not knowing. The Chit in the Purusha plus

Prakriti is what we see around us. Whatever is pleasure and happiness and

light in the universe belongs to Purusha; but it is a compound, because it

is Purusha plus Prakriti. "Wherever there is any happiness, wherever there

is any bliss, there is a spark of that immortality which is God." "Purusha

is the; great attraction of the universe; though untouched by and

unconnected with the universe, yet it attracts the whole; universe." You see

a man going after gold, because behind it is a spark of the Purusha though

mixed up with a good deal of dirt. When a man loves his children or a woman

her husband, what is the attracting power? A spark of Purusha behind them.

It is there, only mixed up with "dirt". Nothing else can attract. "In this

world of insentiency the Purusha alone is sentient." This is the Purusha of

the Sankhya. As such, it necessarily follows that the Purusha must be

omnipresent. That which is not omnipresent must be limited. All limitations

are caused; that which is caused must have a beginning and end. If the

Purusha is limited, it will die, will not be free, will not be final, but

must have some cause. Therefore it is omnipresent. According to Kapila,

there are many Purushas; not one, but an infinite number of them. You and I

have each of us one, and so has everyone else; an infinite number of

circles, each one infinite, running through this universe. The Purusha is

neither mind nor matter, the reflex from it is all that we know. We are sure

if it is omnipresent it has neither death nor birth. Nature is casting her

shadow upon it, the shadow of birth and death, but it is by its nature pure.

So far we have found the philosophy of the Sankhya wonderful.

Next we shall take up the proofs against it. So far the analysis is perfect,

the psychology incontrovertible. We find by the division of the senses into

organs and instruments that they are not simple, but compound; by dividing

egoism into sense and matter, we find that this is also material and that

Mahat is also a state of matter, and finally we find the Purusha. So far

there is no objection. But if we ask the Sankhya the question, "Who created

nature?" — the Sankhya says that the Purusha and the Prakriti are uncreate

and omnipresent, and that of this Purusha there is an infinite number. We

shall have to controvert these propositions, and find a better solution, and

by so doing we shall come to Advaitism. Our first objection is, how can

there be these two infinites? Then our argument will be that the Sankhya is

not a perfect generalization, and that we have not found in it a perfect

solution. And then we shall see how the Vedantists grope out of all these

difficulties and reach a perfect solution, and yet all the glory really

belongs to the Sankhya. It is very easy to give a finishing touch to a

building when it is constructed.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 2, en.wikisource.org · Contents