Hinduism

Bhakti-Yoga — The Philosophy of Ishvara

Who is Ishvara? Janmâdyasya yatah — "From whom is the birth, continuation,

and dissolution of the universe," — He is Ishvara — "the Eternal, the Pure,

the Ever-Free, the Almighty, the All-Knowing, the All-Merciful, the Teacher

of all teachers"; and above all, Sa Ishvarah anirvachaniya-premasvarupah —

"He the Lord is, of His own nature, inexpressible Love." These certainly are

the definitions of a Personal God. Are there then two Gods — the "Not this,

not this," the Sat-chit-ânanda, the Existence-Knowledge-Bliss of the

philosopher, and this God of Love of the Bhakta? No, it is the same

Sat-chit-ananda who is also the God of Love, the impersonal and personal in

one. It has always to be understood that the Personal God worshipped by the

Bhakta is not separate or different from the Brahman. All is Brahman, the

One without a second; only the Brahman, as unity or absolute, is too much of

an abstraction to be loved and worshipped; so the Bhakta chooses the

relative aspect of Brahman, that is, Ishvara, the Supreme Ruler. To use a

simile: Brahman is as the clay or substance out of which an infinite variety

of articles are fashioned. As clay, they are all one; but form or

manifestation differentiates them. Before every one of them was made, they

all existed potentially in the clay, and, of course, they are identical

substantially; but when formed, and so long as the form remains, they are

separate and different; the clay-mouse can never become a clay-elephant,

because, as manifestations, form alone makes them what they are, though as

unformed clay they are all one. Ishvara is the highest manifestation of the

Absolute Reality, or in other words, the highest possible reading of the

Absolute by the human mind. Creation is eternal, and so also is Ishvara.

In the fourth Pâda of the fourth chapter of his Sutras, after stating the

almost infinite power and knowledge which will come to the liberated soul

after the attainment of Moksha, Vyâsa makes the remark, in an aphorism, that

none, however, will get the power of creating, ruling, and dissolving the

universe, because that belongs to God alone. In explaining the Sutra it is

easy for the dualistic commentators to show how it is ever impossible for a

subordinate soul, Jiva, to have the infinite power and total independence of

God. The thorough dualistic commentator Madhvâchârya deals with this passage

in his usual summary method by quoting a verse from the Varâha Purâna.

In explaining this aphorism the commentator Râmânuja says, "This doubt being

raised, whether among the powers of the liberated souls is included that

unique power of the Supreme One, that is, of creation etc. of the universe

and even the Lordship of all, or whether, without that, the glory of the

liberated consists only in the direct perception of the Supreme One, we get

as an argument the following: It is reasonable that the liberated get the

Lordship of the universe, because the scriptures say, 'He attains to extreme

sameness with the Supreme One and all his desires are realised.' Now extreme

sameness and realisation of all desires cannot be attained without the

unique power of the Supreme Lord, namely, that of governing the universe.

Therefore, to attain the realisation of all desires and the extreme sameness

with the Supreme, we must all admit that the liberated get the power of

ruling the whole universe. To this we reply, that the liberated get all the

powers except that of ruling the universe. Ruling the universe is guiding

the form and the life and the desires of all the sentient and the

non-sentient beings. The liberated ones from whom all that veils His true

nature has been removed, only enjoy the unobstructed perception of the

Brahman, but do not possess the power of ruling the universe. This is proved

from the scriptural text, "From whom all these things are born, by which all

that are born live, unto whom they, departing, return — ask about it. That

is Brahman.' If this quality of ruling the universe be a quality common even

to the liberated then this text would not apply as a definition of Brahman

defining Him through His rulership of the universe. The uncommon attributes

alone define a thing; therefore in texts like — 'My beloved boy, alone, in

the beginning there existed the One without a second. That saw and felt, "I

will give birth to the many." That projected heat.' — 'Brahman indeed alone

existed in the beginning. That One evolved. That projected a blessed form,

the Kshatra. All these gods are Kshatras: Varuna, Soma, Rudra, Parjanya,

Yama, Mrityu, Ishâna.' — 'Atman indeed existed alone in the beginning;

nothing else vibrated; He thought of projecting the world; He projected the

world after.' — 'Alone Nârâyana existed; neither Brahmâ, nor Ishana, nor the

Dyâvâ-Prithivi, nor the stars, nor water, nor fire, nor Soma, nor the sun.

He did not take pleasure alone. He after His meditation had one daughter,

the ten organs, etc.' — and in others as, 'Who living in the earth is

separate from the earth, who living in the Atman, etc.' — the Shrutis speak

of the Supreme One as the subject of the work of ruling the universe. . . .

Nor in these descriptions of the ruling of the universe is there any

position for the liberated soul, by which such a soul may have the ruling of

the universe ascribed to it."

In explaining the next Sutra, Râmânuja says, "If you say it is not so,

because there are direct texts in the Vedas in evidence to the contrary,

these texts refer to the glory of the liberated in the spheres of the

subordinate deities." This also is an easy solution of the difficulty.

Although the system of Ramanuja admits the unity of the total, within that

totality of existence there are, according to him, eternal differences.

Therefore, for all practical purposes, this system also being dualistic, it

was easy for Ramanuja to keep the distinction between the personal soul and

the Personal God very clear.

We shall now try to understand what the great representative of the Advaita

School has to say on the point. We shall see how the Advaita system

maintains all the hopes and aspirations of the dualist intact, and at the

same time propounds its own solution of the problem in consonance with the

high destiny of divine humanity. Those who aspire to retain their individual

mind even after liberation and to remain distinct will have ample

opportunity of realising their aspirations and enjoying the blessing of the

qualified Brahman. These are they who have been spoken of in the Bhâgavata Purâna

thus: "O king, such are the, glorious qualities of the Lord that the

sages whose only pleasure is in the Self, and from whom all fetters have

fallen off, even they love the Omnipresent with the love that is for love's

sake." These are they who are spoken of by the Sânkhyas as getting merged in

nature in this cycle, so that, after attaining perfection, they may come out

in the next as lords of world-systems. But none of these ever becomes equal

to God (Ishvara). Those who attain to that state where there is neither

creation, nor created, nor creator, where there is neither knower, nor

knowable, nor knowledge, where there is neither I, nor thou, nor he, where

there is neither subject, nor object, nor relation, "there, who is seen by

whom?" — such persons have gone beyond everything to "where words cannot go

nor mind", gone to that which the Shrutis declare as "Not this, not this";

but for those who cannot, or will not reach this state, there will

inevitably remain the triune vision of the one undifferentiated Brahman as

nature, soul, and the interpenetrating sustainer of both — Ishvara. So, when

Prahlâda forgot himself, he found neither the universe nor its cause; all

was to him one Infinite, undifferentiated by name and form; but as soon as

he remembered that he was Prahlada, there was the universe before him and

with it the Lord of the universe — "the Repository of an infinite number of

blessed qualities". So it was with the blessed Gopis. So long as they had

lost sense of their own personal identity and individuality, they were all

Krishnas, and when they began again to think of Him as the One to be

worshipped, then they were Gopis again, and immediately

(Bhagavata) — "Unto them appeared Krishna with a smile on His lotus face,

clad in yellow robes and having garlands on, the embodied conqueror (in

beauty) of the god of love."

Now to go back to our Acharya Shankara: "Those", he says, "who by

worshipping the qualified Brahman attain conjunction with the Supreme Ruler,

preserving their own mind — is their glory limited or unlimited? This doubt

arising, we get as an argument: Their glory should be unlimited because of

the scriptural texts, 'They attain their own kingdom', 'To him all the gods

offer worship', 'Their desires are fulfilled in all the worlds'. As an

answer to this, Vyasa writes, 'Without the power of ruling the universe.'

Barring the power of creation etc. of the universe, the other powers such as

Animâ etc. are acquired by the liberated. As to ruling the universe, that

belongs to the eternally perfect Ishvara. Why? Because He is the subject of

all the scriptural texts as regards creation etc., and the liberated souls

are not mentioned therein in any connection whatsoever. The Supreme Lord

indeed is alone engaged in ruling the universe. The texts as to creation

etc. all point to Him. Besides, there is given the adjective 'ever-perfect'.

Also the scriptures say that the powers Anima etc. of the others are from

the search after and the worship of God. Therefore they have no place in the

ruling of the universe. Again, on account of their possessing their own

minds, it is possible that their wills may differ, and that, whilst one

desires creation, another may desire destruction. The only way of avoiding

this conflict is to make all wills subordinate to some one will. Therefore

the conclusion is that the wills of the liberated are dependent on the will

of the Supreme Ruler."

Bhakti, then, can be directed towards Brahman, only in His personal aspect.

— "The way is more difficult for those whose mind is attached to the Absolute!"

Bhakti has to float on smoothly

with the current of our nature. True it is that we cannot have; any idea of

the Brahman which is not anthropomorphic, but is it not equally true of

everything we know? The greatest psychologist the world has ever known,

Bhagavan Kapila, demonstrated ages ago that human consciousness is one of

the elements in the make-up of all the objects of our perception and

conception, internal as well as external. Beginning with our bodies and

going up to Ishvara, we may see that every object of our perception is this

consciousness plus something else, whatever that may be; and this

unavoidable mixture is what we ordinarily think of as reality. Indeed it is,

and ever will be, all of the reality that is possible for the human mind to

know. Therefore to say that Ishvara is unreal, because He is

anthropomorphic, is sheer nonsense. It sounds very much like the occidentals

squabble on idealism and realism, which fearful-looking quarrel has for its

foundation a mere play on the word "real". The idea of Ishvara covers all

the ground ever denoted and connoted by the word real, and Ishvara is as

real as anything else in the universe; and after all, the word real means

nothing more than what has now been pointed out. Such is our philosophical

conception of Ishvara.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 3, en.wikisource.org · Contents