Hinduism

Bhakti-Yoga — Worship of Substitutes and Images

The next points to be considered are the worship of Pratikas or of things

more or less satisfactory as substitutes for God, and the worship of

Pratimâs or images. What is the worship of God through a Pratika?

— Joining the mind with devotion to that which is not Brahman, taking it to

be Brahman" — says Bhagavân Râmânuja. "Worship the mind as Brahman this is

internal; and the Âkâsha as Brahman, this is with regard to the Devas", says

Shankara. The mind is an internal Pratika, the Akasha is an external one,

and both have to be worshipped as substitutes of God. He continues,

"Similarly — 'the Sun is Brahman, this is the command', 'He who worships

Name as Brahman' — in all such passages the doubt arises as to the worship

of Pratikas." The word Pratika means going towards; and worshipping a

Pratika is worshipping something as a substitute which is, in some one or

more respects, like Brahman more and more, but is not Brahman. Along with

the Pratikas mentioned in the Shrutis there are various others to be found

in the Purânas and the Tantras. In this kind of Pratika-worship may be

included all the various forms of Pitri-worship and Deva-worship.

Now worshipping Ishvara and Him alone is Bhakti; the worship of anything

else — Deva, or Pitri, or any other being — cannot be Bhakti. The various

kinds of worship of the various Devas are all to be included in ritualistic

Karma, which gives to the worshipper only a particular result in the form of

some celestial enjoyment, but can neither give rise to Bhakti nor lead to

Mukti. One thing, therefore, has to be carefully borne in mind. If, as it

may happen in some cases, the highly philosophic ideal, the supreme Brahman,

is dragged down by Pratika-worship to the level of the Pratika, and the

Pratika itself is taken to be the Atman of the worshipper or his Antaryâmin

(Inner Ruler), the worshipper gets entirely misled, as no Pratika can really

be the Atman of the worshipper.

But where Brahman Himself is the object of worship, and the Pratika stands

only as a substitute or a suggestion thereof, that is to say, where, through

the Pratika the omnipresent Brahman is worshipped — the Pratika itself being

idealised into the cause of all, Brahman — the worship is positively

beneficial; nay, it is absolutely necessary for all mankind until they have

all got beyond the primary or preparatory state of the mind in regard to

worship. When, therefore, any gods or other beings are worshipped in and for

themselves, such worship is only a ritualistic Karma; and as a Vidyâ

(science) it gives us only the fruit belonging to that particular Vidya; but

when the Devas or any other beings are looked upon as Brahman and

worshipped, the result obtained is the same as by the worshipping of

Ishvara. This explains how, in many cases, both in the Shrutis and the

Smritis, a god, or a sage, or some other extraordinary being is taken up and

lifted, as it were, out of his own nature and idealised into Brahman, and is

then worshipped. Says the Advaitin, "Is not everything Brahman when the name

and the form have been removed from it?" "Is not He, the Lord, the innermost

Self of every one?" says the Vishishtâdvaitin.

— "The fruition of even the worship of Adityas etc. Brahman Himself bestows,

because He is the Ruler of all." Says Shankara in his Brahma-Sutra-Bhâsya—

"Here in this way does Brahman become the object of worship, because He, as

Brahman, is superimposed on the Pratikas, just as Vishnu etc. are

superimposed upon images etc."

The same ideas apply to the worship of the Pratimas as to that of the

Pratikas; that is to say, if the image stands for a god or a saint, the

worship is not the result of Bhakti, and does not lead lo liberation; but if

it stands for the one God, the worship thereof will bring both Bhakti and

Mukti. Of the principal religions of the world we see Vedantism, Buddhism,

and certain forms of Christianity freely using images; only two religions,

Mohammedanism and Protestantism, refuse such help. Yet the Mohammedans use

the grave of their saints and martyrs almost in the place of images; and the

Protestants, in rejecting all concrete helps to religion, are drifting away

every year farther and farther from spirituality till at present there is

scarcely any difference between the advanced Protestants and the followers

of August Comte, or agnostics who preach ethics alone. Again, in

Christianity and Mohammedanism whatever exists of image worship is made to

fall under that category in which the Pratika or the Pratima is worshipped

in itself, but not as a "help to the vision" (Drishtisaukaryam) of God;

therefore it is at best only of the nature of ritualistic Karmas and cannot

produce either Bhakti or Mukti. In this form of image-worship, the

allegiance of the soul is given to other things than Ishvara, and,

therefore, such use of images, or graves, or temples, or tombs, is real

idolatry; it is in itself neither sinful nor wicked — it is a rite — a

Karma, and worshippers must and will get the fruit thereof.

Source Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works, Volume 3, en.wikisource.org · Contents