Islam

Masnavi, Book III, Story XVI — The woman who lost all her infants

A woman gave birth to several children one after another, but none lived beyond three or four months. Overwhelmed with grief, she cried out to God, then saw in a dream the beautiful gardens of Paradise and the many magnificent palaces that stood there; on one of these palaces, she read her own name engraved. A voice from heaven announced to her that God would accept the sorrows she had endured in exchange for the blood she would have shed in the holy war, since, because of her sex, she could not go off to battle like the men.

Looking again, the woman saw in Paradise all the children she had lost and cried out: “O Lord! They were lost to me, but they were safe with You!”

This tale is followed by anecdotes about Hamza going into battle without his coat of mail, about the Prophet advising a man who complained of being cheated in his dealings to take time to reflect before concluding them, and about the death of Bilal, Muhammad’s crier. Then come illustrations of the illusory nature of the world, of the difference between things self-evident and mere conclusions drawn by inference, as well as between knowing a thing by means of illustrations and through the testimony of others, and knowing it as it really is in its essence.

Difference between knowing a thing only by analogy and on the authority of others, and knowing its very essence.

The mercy of God is known by its fruits,

But who, save God, knows His essence?

No one knows the very essence of the attributes of God,

Except by their effects and by analogy.

A child knows nothing of the nature of the sexual act,

Except what you tell him: that it is like sweets.

But how far does the pleasure of the sexual act

Really resemble that which sweets afford?

Yet this fiction establishes a link

Between you, who possess perfect knowledge, and the child;

Thus the child knows the thing by analogy,

Though he knows neither its essence nor its real nature.

So, if he says: “I know it,” he is not altogether wrong;

And if he says: “I do not know it,” he is not wrong either.

If someone were to say: “Do you know Noah,

“That prophet of God and luminary of the Spirit?”

If you say: “Do I not know him, since that moon

Is more famous than the sun and the moon of heaven?

The little children in their schools,

And the elders in their mosques,

All read his name prominently in the Koran,

And preachers tell his story from ancient times”;

You speak truly, for you know him by hearsay,

Though the true nature of Noah is not revealed to you.

On the other hand, if you say: “What do I know of Noah,

As his contemporaries knew him?

I am but a poor ant; what can I know of the elephant?

What does a fly know of the movements of the elephant?”

This assertion is equally true, O brother,

Since you do not know his true nature.

But this inability to perceive the true essence,

Though common to ordinary men, is not universal;

For the essence and its deepest secrets

Are open and manifest to the eyes of the perfect.

The negation and the affirmation of one and the same proposition are legitimate;

When the aspects differ, the relation is twofold.

“You did not throw, when you threw” 2 illustrates such a relation:

Here, negation and affirmation are both right.

You throw it, since it is in your hand;

You do not throw it, since it is God who gives you the strength.

The power of the sons of Adam is limited:

How could a handful of sand put an army to flight?

The sand was in the man’s hands, but it was God who threw it.

Because of these two relations, negation and affirmation are both true.

The unbelievers know the prophets,

Just as they know beyond any doubt their own children;

Yes, the unbelievers know them as well as their own sons,

Through a hundred signs and a hundred proofs,

But, out of envy and malice, they hide what they know

And are inclined to say: “We do not know them.”

Thus, when God says in one place: “He knows them,”

in another, He says: “None knows them but Me.”

For, in truth, they are hidden beneath the protecting shadow of God,

and none, save God, knows them by direct experience.

Understand this declaration, then, in its context,

remembering the way in which you know and do not know Noah.

NOTES:

Source Rûmî, Masnavi i Ma’navi, trans. E. H. Whinfield (1887), en.wikisource.org — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents