An ignorant youth entered an assembly of pious men, who were being addressed by a holy sheikh. He saw the sheikh weeping abundantly and, out of sheer blind and senseless imitation, he copied his behaviour and wept bitterly too, although he had not understood a single word of the discourse. In reality, he behaved like a deaf man who sees those around him laughing and laughs himself out of politeness, without knowing what amuses them, and who must have the joke explained to him before he can laugh again, truly understanding it.
After weeping for some time in this ignorant way, he paid the sheikh the homage due to him and took his leave. But one of the sheikh’s true disciples, jealous for his master’s honour, followed him and said to him: “I adjure you by Allah not to go away saying: ‘I saw the sheikh weep, and I too wept like him.’ Your ignorant weeping, due to mere imitation, has nothing in common with that of this holy man. Such weeping is possible only for one who, like him, has waged the spiritual war for thirty years.
His weeping is not caused by the sorrows of the world, but by the deep concerns of the spirit. You cannot perceive by reason or by the senses the spiritual mysteries that are open and manifest to his enlightened vision, any more than darkness can behold light. His breaths are like those of ‘Isa, and not mere human sighs called forth by the sorrows of the world. His tears, his smiles and his words are not his own, but come from Allah.
Fools like you are ignorant of the motive and purpose of the acts of the saints; so they only harm themselves if they try to imitate them without understanding their meaning.”
To illustrate this, a curious story is told: a foolish woman imitated a stratagem of her ingenious maidservant, without understanding how it worked, and thus caused her own death. In the same way, parrots are taught to speak without understanding the words. The method consists in placing a mirror between the parrot and its trainer. Hidden behind the mirror, the trainer utters the words; the parrot, seeing its own reflection in the mirror, imagines that another parrot is speaking and imitates everything the trainer says behind the mirror.
Thus God uses the prophets and saints as mirrors to instruct men, while He Himself remains hidden behind these mirrors, that is, the bodies of these saints and prophets; and when men hear the words that issue from these mirrors, they are utterly unaware that they are in reality spoken by the “Universal Reason” or the “Word of God,” behind the mirrors of the saints.
The vanity of mere blind imitation (taqlid) of religious practices.
When a friend tells a joke to his friend,
The deaf man listening laughs twice;
The first time, out of imitation and foolishness,
Because he sees the whole assembly laughing;
Yet, though he laughs like the others,
He does not then know what makes them laugh;
Then he asks what it was about,
And, when he is told, begins to laugh a second time.
So the blind imitator is like a deaf man,
As regards the joy he pretends to feel.
The light is the Sheikh’s, the source is the Sheikh’s,
And the outpouring of joy is the Sheikh’s too, not his own.
It is like water in a vessel, or light through a glass;
If they think it comes from themselves, they are mistaken.
When the vessel moves away from the source, it recognizes its error;
It sees that the water it holds comes from the source.
The glass too learns, when the moon sets,
That its light came from the radiance of the moon.
When the command “Arise!” opens his eyes,
Then this disciple smiles a second time, like the dawn.
He laughs too at his earlier laughter,
Which had come to him through sheer blind imitation.
When he returns from his long, distant wanderings,
He says: “Here is the truth, here is the secret!
With what blindness and what error I claimed
To feel joy in that distant valley!
What illusion led me astray! What error!
My feeble mind forged vain fancies.”
How could an infant on the way know the thoughts of men?
How far its daydreams are from true knowledge!
The thoughts of infants turn to the nurse and to milk,
Or to raisins and nuts, or to cries and tears.
The blind imitator is like a frail infant,
Even if he possesses subtle arguments and proofs.
His concern for obscure arguments and proofs
Draws him away from the understanding of the truth.
His learning, which is the salve of his eyes,
Carries him off and plunges him into difficult questions.
Ah! man of imitation, come out of Bukhara!
And humble yourself, that you may be exalted.
Then, see, you will discover within yourself another Bukhara,
Whose heroes know nothing of these questions of law.
Though a foot soldier may run fast on land,
On the sea he is like a man with severed sinews.
That foot soldier is only “carried on the land,”
But he who is “carried by the sea” is the true sage.
The King of kings grants him special favours;
Know this, O man given over to vain illusions!
The mere jurist theologian is powerless to behold the light of the Spirit.
When day rises in the sky, night takes flight;
What then can its darkness know of the nature of light?
The gnat flies off headlong before the gust of the winds;
What then does the gnat know of the fragrance of the winds?
When the Eternal appears, the transient is abolished;
What then does the transient know of the Eternal?
When He sets foot upon the transient, He plunges it into confusion;
When it has become nothing, He sheds His light upon it.
If you wish, you may cite hundreds of examples,
But I pay them no heed, O man of poor heart!
The letters Lam, Mim and Ha, Mim placed at the head of certain suras
Are like the rod of Moses, when they are fully understood.
Ordinary letters resemble them at first sight,
But their meaning is far less.
If an ordinary man takes a rod and puts it to the test,
Will it prove like the rod of Moses in the trial?
That breath of ‘Isa is not like any ordinary breath,
Which proceeds from mere human joy or mere human sorrow.
These Alif, Mim, Ha and Mim, O father,
proceed from the Lord of men.
If you have discernment, do not regard as these
all the ordinary Alifs and Lams that resemble them;
although these sacred letters are made of common letters,
and resemble them in their composition.
Muhammad himself was made of flesh and skin,
although no man is of the same nature as he.
He had flesh, skin and bones,
although no man resembles him in his composition;
for divine powers were contained in his composition,
and all human flesh was confounded by them.
Likewise, the composition of the letters Ha, Mim
rises far above ordinary combinations of letters;
for from these mysterious compositions life is born,
as utter chaos follows the last trumpet.
That rod becomes a serpent and parts the Nile,
like the rod of Ha, Mim, by the grace of God.
Its outward form resembles those of others,
Yet the round of a cake differs greatly from that of the moon.
The weeping, the laughter and the speech of the saint
Do not belong to him, but proceed from God.
While fools consider only outward appearances,
These mysteries are wholly hidden from them;
Of necessity, the true meaning is veiled from them,
For the mystery is lost in the intermediary.
There follows the anecdote of a man who heard puppies barking in their mother’s womb. A voice from heaven explained that these puppies were like men who have not yet come out into the light of truth, but who remain veiled in spiritual darkness; though they claim to see spiritually, their talk is useless, both for procuring spiritual food for themselves and for warning their hearers of spiritual dangers.
Next comes the anecdote of a pious man of Zarwan, who made a point of giving the poor four times the legal amount of alms due on his crops. Thus, instead of taking a tenth of each crop, as the law laid down by the Prophet requires, 6 he used to give a tenth of the green ears, another tenth of the ripe wheat, a third tenth of the threshed grain, and a fourth of the bread made from it; and so on for the grapes and the other produce of his garden.
In recognition of his piety, God blessed his garden and made it abundant in fruit. But his sons, blind to spiritual realities, saw only his largesse towards the poor; they did not see the divine blessing upon the garden, drawn down by his generosity, and they reproached him for his extravagance. Divine munificence has no limit, for God’s capacity to bestow His blessings, unlike that of men, is boundless and infinite.