Ah, if only I knew what heart they bore!
And if only my heart knew by what mountain pass they went!
Do you think they are safe, or that they are dead?
Lovers go astray in love and become entangled in it.
1. “They,” that is, the Divine Ideas, with which the hearts (of the gnostics) are passionately enamoured, which lead minds astray and for whose sake pious men perform their works of devotion.
“What heart”: he alludes to the perfect heart of Muhammad, for it is not limited by the stations. It is nevertheless possessed by the Divine Ideas, for they seek it and it seeks them. They cannot know that they possess it, since they belong to its essence, inasmuch as it sees in them nothing other than its own nature.
2. “What pass they crossed,” that is, into what gnostic’s heart they entered when they vanished from mine. The “pass” denotes a “station,” which is fixed, as opposed to a “state,” which is fleeting.
3. The Divine Ideas, as Ideas, exist only in the existence of the one who contemplates them; they are “dead” insofar as the one who contemplates them does not exist.
4. Lovers are torn between two opposite things, for the lover wishes to be in accord with the Beloved and also wishes to be united with Him, so that if the Beloved wishes to be separated from the lover, the lover finds himself at an impasse.