Catholicism

Confessions, Book Thirteen, chapter XXIII

Of what the spiritual man may judge.

Now “the spiritual man judges all things”, and this is what Scripture calls “having dominion over the fish of the sea, the birds of the air, the tame and wild beasts, over all the earth, over everything that creeps upon its face”. And this dominion he exercises through that understanding which makes him able to penetrate “the things of the Spirit of God”! “Fallen from glory through want of understanding, has he not sunk to the rank of the brutes, has he not become like them”?

I Cor., II, 14; Ps. XLVIII, 13.

And we, my God, we, children of grace in Your Church, “we, Your workmanship, created in good works”, we are spiritual judges, whether we hold authority according to the spirit or obey spiritually. “You made man male and female”; and so it is in the creation of Your grace, where nevertheless there is no longer male nor female according to bodily sex; neither Jew nor Greek, neither free nor slave. And these men of the spirit, whether they command or obey, are spiritual judges.

But their judgment is not exercised upon the spiritual thoughts that shine in the firmament. It is not for them to pronounce upon so sublime an authority, to set themselves up as judges of Your holy book, even when shadows veil its light there. For we owe it the submission of our understanding, and a firm assurance of the rightness and truth of every letter closed to our eyes. Man, “even spiritual, and renewed in the knowledge of God after the image of the Creator”, must be the observer, and not the judge, of the law.

Nor does his judgment extend to discerning the men of the spirit from the men of the flesh, unless he knows them by their works, as “the tree is known by its fruit”. Your gaze alone sees them, my God; You already know them, Lord, and You had already set them apart; You had called them in the secret of Your counsel, even before creating the firmament.

Matth., VII, 20.

Spiritual though he is, neither does he judge the turbulent generations of the age. “Why should he judge those who are outside”, since he does not know which among them are the elect called one day to taste the sweetness of Your grace, and which the souls destined to remain in the eternal bitterness of impiety?

I Cor., V, 12.

Thus, in forming man in Your image, You gave him dominion neither over the stars of heaven, nor over the hidden heaven, nor over that day and that night which You named before creation, nor over that gathering of the waters which is called the sea; he received dominion only over the fish of the sea, the birds of the air, all the animals, all the earth, and everything that creeps upon its face.

He judges, he approves or condemns what he finds good or evil, both in the solemnity of the initiating sacrament that consecrates to Your service those whom Your mercy has fished from the depths of the waters, and in that sacred banquet where the mystical fish, drawn from the depths of the abyss, is served to feed the earth; and in discourses and words, faithful birds that fly beneath the firmament of the authority of the holy Scriptures; interpretations, expositions, discussions, controversies, blessings, prayers, which the lips utter in sonorous formulas, so that the people may answer: Amen!

The abyss of the age, and the blindness of this flesh which has no eyes to see thoughts, such is the reason for the use of sounds and of the noise with which the ears are struck. And that is how these birds, which multiply upon the earth, nevertheless have their origin in the waters.

The spiritual man also judges, approves or condemns what he finds good or evil in the works and the ways of the faithful; he judges almsgiving as the fruits of the earth; he judges the living soul that knows how to tame its passions through charity, fasting and devout thoughts; he judges all that comes about through sensible effects; he is judge, in short, wherever he has the power to correct and to reprove.

Source Saint Augustin, Confessions, trad. L. Moreau, Project Gutenberg #67320 — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents