Islam

Masnavi, Book IV, Story I — The lover and his mistress

THE fourth book begins with an address to Husamu-'d-Din, followed by the story of the lover and his mistress, already begun in the third book. A certain lover had been separated from his mistress for seven years, without ever ceasing to strive to find her again. At last his faithfulness and perseverance were rewarded, in accordance with the promises: “He who seeks shall find” and “Whoever has done an atom’s weight of good shall see it.”

1 One night, as he wandered through the town, he was pursued by the watch and, to escape them, took refuge in a garden, where he found his mistress, whom he had sought for so long. This led him to reflect on how often men “hate what is good for them,” 2 and to bless the harsh watch that had brought him the bliss of finding his mistress again.

In this connection is told the anecdote of a preacher who was in the habit of blessing thieves and oppressors, because their bad example had led him to righteousness. As soon as the lover found himself alone with his mistress, he tried to embrace her, but she repulsed him, saying that, even if no man was present, the wind was blowing, which proved that God, who sets the wind in motion, was also present. The lover replied: “I may be lacking in good manners, but I lack neither constancy nor faithfulness toward you.”

His mistress retorted: “What is hidden must be judged by what is manifest; I see with my own eyes that your outward conduct is bad, and so I can only conclude that your claims to hidden virtues are not borne out by the facts. You are ashamed to behave badly under the gaze of men, but you have no scruple in doing so in the presence of the all-seeing God; I therefore doubt the existence of the virtuous feelings you claim to possess, but which you alone can know.”

To illustrate this, she told the story of a Sufi and his unfaithful wife. One day this wife was entertaining a lover when she was surprised by the sudden return of her husband. In the heat of the moment, she threw a woman’s robe over her lover and presented him to her husband as a rich lady who had come to propose a marriage between her son and the Sufi’s daughter; she added that the lady cared nothing for wealth, but took into account only modesty and uprightness of conduct.

The Sufi replied that, since the lady had come without an escort, it was evident that she did not possess the wealth she boasted of, and that it was therefore very likely that her claims to extraordinary modesty and humility were equally fictitious. The lover then set about excusing himself, claiming that he had wanted to put his mistress to the test and see for himself whether she was a modest woman or not. He said that he knew well beforehand that she would prove modest, but that he nonetheless wanted to have proof of it with his own eyes.

His mistress reproached him for trying to deceive her with false pretexts, assuring him that, having been caught at fault, the only conduct befitting him was to confess it, as Adam had done. She added moreover that trying to put her to the test would have been an utterly unworthy act, which could only be compared to Abu Jahl’s attempt to verify the truth of the Prophet’s claims by asking him to perform a miracle.

The essence of good in evil things. Evil is only relative.

The lover invoked blessings on those harsh guards,

For their harshness had brought him bliss.

They were poison to most men, but sweetness to him,

For those harsh men had united him with his love.

In the world, nothing is absolutely evil;

Know also that evil is only relative.

In the world there is neither poison nor antidote

That is not a foot for one and a fetter for another;

For one, the power to move; for another, an obstacle;

For one, a poison; for another, an antidote.

The venom of serpents is life to serpents;

To human beings, it is deadly.

To the creatures of the sea, the sea is a garden;

To the creatures of the land, it is fatal.

So too, O man, consider with intelligence

The relations of these things, infinitely varied.

To this man, Zaid is like Satan;

To another, he is like a Sultan.

The second calls Zaid a sincere Muslim,

The first calls him a Gueber worthy of death.

Zaid, one and the same person, is the life of the one,

And for the other, a nuisance and a plague.

If you desire that God be favorable to you,

Look upon Him with the eyes of those who love Him.

Do not look upon that Beauty with your own eyes;

Contemplate that Object of desire with the eyes of His worshippers.

Close your own eyes to the sight of that delightful Object,

And borrow the eyes of those who admire Him.

Better still, borrow from Him both the eyes and the sight,

And, with His eyes, look upon His face,

So that you may not be disappointed by what you see.

God says: “Whoever belongs to God, God belongs to him also.”

God says: “I am his eye, his hand, his heart,”

so that his good fortune may be born of adversity.

Whatever displeases you, if it is to lead you

to your beloved, at once becomes pleasing to you.

Why God is named “He who hears,” “He who sees” and “He who knows.”

God names Himself “He who sees,” so that

His eye may turn you away from sin at every moment.

God names Himself “He who hears,” so that

you may close your lips to impure speech.

God names Himself “He who knows,” so that

you may fear to plot evil.

These names are not mere chance appellations of God,

as one might call a Black man Kafu’r (white);

they are names drawn from the essential attributes of God,

and not empty titles of the First Cause.

For, if it were so, they would be nothing but empty jests,

like calling a deaf man “he who hears,” and a blind man “he who sees,”

or calling a modest man “insolent,”

Or “handsome” an ugly Black man,

Or again the title of “Haji” for a newborn child,

Or that of “Ghazi” applied to an idle noble.

To use such titles in praise of persons

Who do not possess the qualities they imply is a fault;

It would be jesting, mocking or being senseless.

“God is exalted above” what the wicked say.

I knew you before I met you face to face;

I knew that you had a handsome face, but an evil heart;

Yes, I knew you before I saw you,

I knew that you were rooted in iniquity through cunning.

When my eye is red with inflammation,

I know it by the pain, even if I do not see it.

You took me for a lamb without a shepherd;

You imagined that I had no keeper.

Lovers have been punished for this reason:

They cast ill-advised glances upon beautiful persons.

They thought that the fawn had no shepherd,

They thought that the captive would go begging;

But, in the twinkling of an eye, an arrow pierces them,

Saying: “I am her keeper; do not look upon her boldly!”

What! am I less than a lamb or a doe,

That I should have no one to guard me?

No, I have a Keeper worthy to reign,

Who knows every wind that blows upon me.

He knows whether that wind is cold or mild,

He is neither ignorant nor absent, O wretch.

God created the carnal soul blind and deaf;

I saw from afar, with the eye of the heart, your blindness.

That is why I never inquired after you for eight years,

For I saw you full of ignorance and duplicity.

Why then inquire after someone who is in the furnace,

Bowed down under disgrace, like you?

Comparison of the world to a bath stove,

and of piety to the hot bath.

The desire for the world is like a bath stove,

which heats the bath of piety;

but the lot of the pious is to be cleansed of the dirt of the stove,

for they dwell in the bath and in cleanliness.

The rich are like those who carry dung

to heat the furnace of the bath as well.

God has instilled covetousness in them,

so that the bath may be hot and pleasant.

Leave this stove and go forward into the bath;

know that to leave the stove is to enter the bath itself.

Whoever is in the stove room is like a servant

to the one who is temperate and prudent.

Your desire is like a fire in the world,

with a hundred greedy mouths gaping wide.

In the judgment of reason, this gold is foul dung,

though, like dung, it serves to kindle the fire.

Whoever was born in the stove room and has never seen purity,

The scent of sweet musk is unpleasant to him.

By way of illustration, here is the story of a tanner who, in the practice of his trade, was used to foul smells and who nearly died of the scent of musk in the perfumers’ bazaar, but was cured by the familiar smell of dung.

NOTES:

Source Rûmî, Masnavi i Ma’navi, trans. E. H. Whinfield (1887), en.wikisource.org — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents