← Back to the lesson (Lesson 260)

Islam

Masnavi, Book VI, Story III — The drunken Turkish emir and the minstrel

Next come exhortations to endure “the pains of negation,” as they are called in the Gulshan i Raz: just as the great saint and poet Faridu-'d-Din 'Attar got rid of his drugs, one must cast one’s own will, one’s knowledge, one’s power and one’s “self” into the single river of “annihilation,” 1 and then rise from that state to the higher state of eternal existence in God. The aim and object of all negation is to arrive afterward at affirmation; thus, in the profession of faith, the negation “There is no god” finds its complement and its reason for being in the affirmation “but God.”

Likewise, the aim of the negation of self is to clear the way for grasping this truth: nothing exists apart from the One. The intoxication of life, of its pleasures and its occupations, veils the Truth from men’s eyes; they should pass on to the spiritual intoxication that takes them out of themselves and raises them to the beatific vision of the eternal Truth. This amounts to saying that they must pass from negation to affirmation, from ignorance to the highest knowledge.

The tale of the Turkish noble and the minstrel illustrates this, and is accompanied by apologies for the use of examples drawn from drunkenness. A Turkish noble awoke from his drunken sleep and called his minstrel to entertain him. The minstrel was a spiritual man and took the opportunity to edify him by singing an air with a deeply spiritual meaning:

“I know not whether you are the moon or an idol,

I know not what you expect of me.

I know not what service to render you,

Whether to keep silent or to speak.

You are not separate from me, and yet, strange to say,

I know not where I am nor where you are.

I know not why you draw me on,

Now embracing me, now wounding me!”

Thus his whole song consisted of repeating the words: “I do not know.” At last the noble could bear it no longer; he took a stick and threatened to beat the minstrel, saying: “Wretch, tell us something you do know, and stop repeating what you do not know. If I ask you where you come from or what you have eaten, and you answer only with negations, your answer is a waste of time. Say what you mean by all these negations.”

The minstrel replied: “What I mean is hidden. I fear to affirm the contrary of your negations; so I formulate negations so that you may deduce the corresponding affirmations from them. By my song I now suggest the truth to you; and when death comes to you, you will learn the mysteries that, for now, I can only suggest.”

Spiritual mysteries set forth in the Masnavi under images of intoxication.

This wine of God is obtained from this musician,

That wine of the body, from the other.

Both bear the same name in speech,

But their worth is very different.

The bodies of men are like jars with sealed mouths;

Take heed, until you see what they contain.

The jar of this body holds the water of life,

While that one holds a deadly poison.

If you look at the contents, you are wise;

If you look only at the vessel, you will go astray.

Know that words are like these bodies,

And that the meaning is like the soul.

The eyes of the body are ever fixed on bodies,

Those of the soul, on the reasoning soul;

That is why, in the figures of the words of the Masnavi,

The form leads astray, but the deep meaning guides.

In the Koran it is declared that its parables

“Lead some astray and guide others.”

O God! when a spiritual man speaks of wine,

how could another spiritual man mistake his meaning?

So the minstrel began his intoxicating song:

“Give me Your cup, You whom I do not see!

You are my face; what wonder if I do not see it?

Extreme nearness acts as a veil that obscures.

You are my reason; what wonder if I do not see You

through the multitude of obstacles that stand between?

You are “nearer to me than the vein of my neck,”

how could I call out to You, “Ho!”, as if You were far away?

No, but I will lead some astray by calling out in the desert,

to hide my Beloved from those of whom I am jealous!”

This is illustrated by an anecdote about the Prophet and Ayisha. One day Ayisha was sitting with the Prophet without her veil, when a blind man came in. Knowing well that her husband was jealous, Ayisha was at once about to withdraw, when the Prophet said to her: “This man is blind and cannot see you.” Ayisha answered by gestures that, though the man could not see her, she could see him. In the same way, the spiritual man is jealous of exposing his mysteries to the gaze of the profane and, out of excess of caution, veils them with signs and allusions.

Next comes a commentary on this tradition: “Die before you die,” that is to say, mortify your passions and carnal desires, and deny and annihilate your carnal “self” before the death of the body takes you by surprise. Men who put off their repentance until the moment when they are about to die are compared to the Shi’ites of Aleppo, who every year, at Ashura, or the tenth day of Muharram, gather at the gate of Antioch to mourn the martyrdom of Hasan and Husain.

One day, while they were thus occupied, a Sunni poet arrived in the city and inquired the reason for this excessive grief and mourning. The Shi’ites reproached him for his ignorance of sacred history, and he said: “This martyrdom took place long ago; but, to see your excessive grief, one would think the news had only just reached you. You must have been asleep all this time not to have learned it sooner; and now you are weeping over your own sleep!”

For those who are truly spiritual, who have drunk the wine of God and bear its “marks on their foreheads,” 6 death is an occasion for rejoicing, not for lamenting. The man absorbed in the petty pleasures of the world and blind to the abundant provisions prepared for the soul is like an ant in a granary of wheat, which toils to carry off a single grain when it already has abundant stores. Spiritual men must go on exhorting worldly people to repent and to profit from these heavenly provisions for their souls, without caring, like Noah, whether their preaching is heeded or not.

This is illustrated by the anecdote of a man who, in the middle of the night, knocked at the door of an empty house to announce that it was time to prepare the meal taken at dawn during Ramadan.

Why knock at an empty house.

You have spoken; now hear my answer,

So as not to remain in astonishment and perplexity.

Although this hour seems to you to be midnight,

In my eyes the dawn of a joyful morning is near.

To the common folk, all the parts of the world seem dead,

But to God, they are alive with sense and love.

And as for your words: “This house is empty,

Why then beat the drum before it?”

Know that the people of God spend their money,

And build many mosques and holy places,

And devote their health and their wealth to distant pilgrimages,

In ecstatic joy, like intoxicated lovers;

And none of them ever says: “The Ka’ba is empty”;

How could one who knows the Truth say that?

These people are drawn up in battle array,

And risk their lives to win the favor of God;

One of them, plunged in calamities like Job himself,

Another showing patience like Jacob.

There are thousands of them who thirst and suffer,

Striving ardently to accomplish the will of God.

I too, to please God the Merciful,

Beat the drum at every door, in hope of the dawn.

Seek a buyer who will pay you in gold;

Where will you find one more generous than God?

He buys the worthless refuse that is your wealth,

And pays you with the light that illumines your heart.

He accepts your frozen and lifeless bodies,

And gives you a kingdom beyond your dreams.

He takes a few drops of your tears,

And gives you the divine spring, sweeter than sugar.

He takes your sighs laden with pain and sadness,

And for every sigh grants you in return a rank in heaven.

In exchange for the wind of sighs that raised the clouds of tears,

God gave Abraham the title of “Father of the faithful.”

Come! In this incomparable and crowded market,

Sell your old wares and take a kingdom in payment!

NOTES:

Source Rûmî, Masnavi i Ma’navi, trans. E. H. Whinfield (1887), en.wikisource.org — traduction I Choose Peace depuis l’anglais — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents