Islam

Mantic uttaïr, Praise of Ali

Ali is the master of truth, the chief who possesses uprightness, the mountain of gentleness, the ocean of knowledge, the pole of religion. He is the cupbearer who pours out the water of Kauçar to drink, the imâm who shows the true path, the cousin of Muhammad, the lion of God, the chosen one, the elect, the husband of the virgin, the chaste lord, the son-in-law of the Prophet. He came to explain right guidance; he came to unveil the secret of “ask me”; he is the guide full of merit of religion; he is its absolute judge.

As Ali is the sole confidant of the secrets of God, one can feel no doubt about his eminent knowledge. According to a saying of Muhammad, Ali knows the divine essence; what am I saying! he is part of it. If someone was raised to life by the breath of Jesus, Ali with one word healed a severed hand. In the Kaaba he was accepted by God; he broke its idols, standing even on the back and shoulders of the Prophet. His heart held the secrets of the mystery; he could have drawn his white hand from his bosom.

Had his hand not been truly white, how would the sword Zulfikar have rested in it? Sometimes he was moved because of his preoccupations, sometimes he whispered secrets into a well; he found no one on the horizons whom he could make his companion; he entered the sanctuary and there was no mahram there.

O you who are a prey to fanaticism, you who remain now in hatred, now in love! If you pride yourself on having intelligence and heart, why give way to fanaticism? O ignorant one! there is no deviation in the caliphate; for how can one think that it could have come from Abû Bekr and Omar? Had it existed in these two chiefs, both of them would have designated their son as their successor, and, although these two eminent personages had caused testimony to the truth to be borne by trustworthy people, the others would have raised an impediment.

Now since no one raised any obstacle, it is because there were no opposing claims. If, then, no one came forward to prevent Abû Bekr from being proclaimed caliph, will you give the lie to everyone? But if you give the lie to the companions of the Prophet, you do not accept the words of the Prophet himself, who said: “Each of my friends is a shining star, and my tribe is the best tribe. The best men are my friends; they are my allies and my beloved ones.”

If the best becomes for you the worst, how can anyone call you clear-sighted? Can you admit that the companions of the Prophet would willingly have accepted unworthy people to seat them in the place of Muhammad? That is not admissible for the companions of the Prophet. If the choice of the majority was not good, in that case the collection of the Koran into a volume was no better. Now all that the companions of the Prophet did, they did justly and fittingly.

In refusing to recognize the election of one person, you condemn thirty-three thousand. He who has placed his hope in God alone has not hobbled the knee of his camel. If he is in suspense in this matter, how can he receive the truth of God? Do not, then, hold such an opinion.

If the deviation had occurred in favour of Abû Bekr, would he ever have said: “Kill me”? If it had occurred for Omar, would he have killed his child by wounding him with a stick? Abû Bekr was always the man of the spiritual way, heedless of everything and assiduous at the heavenly court. He gave Muhammad his wealth and his daughter; he devoted himself to him, and, timid as he was, he never betrayed him; he was free of the husk of fictions, for he was in the marrow of true knowledge.

If one considers the pulpit of the caliphate as one should, one will want to place Abû Bekr in it. When one reflects on all that happened before and after, how can one call this eminent personage unjust?

Then comes Omar, the separator, who had nothing in view but justice. Sometimes he moved bricks, and sometimes he gathered thorns; sometimes he carried wood on his back; sometimes, being in the town, he asked his way. Every day he was actively occupied, and he took for all his food only a few mouthfuls of bread. Those who shared his bread at his table received nothing from the public treasury. When he slept, the sand was his bed, and the earth of the valley his pillow.

He would load himself with a skin of water like a water carrier, and carry water to drink to an old woman while she slept. At night he went to watch ardently over his army. He said to Khadija: “O you who are clear-sighted! have you seen in Omar the least hypocrisy? It is in vain that my faults, which I know, are disguised from me, and that presents are offered to me!”

If Omar had obtained the caliphate unjustly, why would he have worn a garment that weighed seventeen manns? He had neither robe nor carpet, and he sewed two pieces of leather together to mend his torn belt. He who exercised so considerable a kingship in this manner could not have been guilty of partiality.

He who now carried bricks, and now worked the clay, would he not then have performed these hard labours in vain? But if he had cast the caliphate to the winds, at least he should have accepted the sultanate. Indeed, in his time, the cities of the infidels were, in his name, emptied of infidelity. If you set yourself in fanatical opposition to Omar, you have no fairness; die of your anger on this account. Omar perished by poison, and you, how many times do you not die of anger because of him, although you have not swallowed poison as he did?

O ignorant one who misjudge justice! do not judge the caliphate according to your own way of seeing. If it were so, a hundred fires would fall upon your heart as a result of this grief. In any case, supposing that one of the first three caliphs had usurped the caliphate, he would have taken upon himself the burden of a hundred kinds of ills which they suffered. It is not easy, while the soul is in the body, to be charged with a thing with which another person was to be charged.

Source Attar, Mantic uttaïr ou le Langage des oiseaux, trad. Garcin de Tassy (1863), archive.org manticuttaroule00goog (OCR corrigé) — I Choose Peace translation from the French · Contents